Environmental, social and governance-focused funds face a more uncertain outlook in 2022, as pressures mount from research costs and hits to the big growth stocks that have helped power the investments’ outperformance.
ESG inflows boomed throughout 2021, even as they slowed in pace towards the end of the year, with global sustainable fund assets doubling in the six months to September 2021 to reach $3.9tn, according to data provider Morningstar.
But the breakneck expansion of the ESG sector could stall if performance starts to approach or underperform benchmarks, after years of high-flying returns driven by powerful rallies in growth stocks.
At the end of December, the top stocks held across the world’s 20 largest ESG funds, which together manage about $340bn in assets, were technology giants Microsoft, Google’s parent company Alphabet and Apple, according to Rumi Mahmood, vice-president of ESG research at MSCI.
Yet while tech shares have been big winners during the pandemic, they have taken a hit since the turn of the year — fuelling speculation that a more sustained rotation towards value strategies is in the offing as the US Federal Reserve starts to withdraw Covid-era monetary stimulus.
“I think it’s going to be an important test for the industry. I’m not convinced that 100 per cent of people who are buying sustainable funds are doing so purely for environmental and ethical reasons. Many are in it as ‘tourists’ because these just happened to be the best performing funds,” said David McCann, equity analyst at Numis.
The tech-focused Nasdaq Composite has had its worst start to the year in half a decade, briefly dropping into correction territory after the Fed adopted a more hawkish tone earlier this month before recovering to trade down 4.8 per cent since January 1. The current fall may turn out to be a blip, but a sustained shift in the market could be painful for ESG funds that have bet heavily on them.
“Certain names are at the top: Microsoft, big tech, big healthcare . . . these have been trading high and are the names these funds are most overweight. If we rotate and rates rise, they will be all beaten up. Banks and resources could fare better, and those are generally underweighted by ESG funds,” said Tom Mills, equity research analyst at Jefferies.
Shares in some more specialist ESG focused companies are down since the start of the year on worries this could soon materialise. London-based Impax’s share price has fallen 15 per cent since the start of January, while Liontrust is down by about 14 per cent.
ESG fund managers argue that sustainability has now become so baked in to investment strategies across the board that a significant reversal is unlikely. For many investors, certain energy and resource companies are now uninvestable, no matter how well their stocks do, fund managers say.
And while interest rate rises discount shareholders’ future returns on speculative tech companies, the investing audience for some of those companies has also exploded.
“We’ve seen more and more of the broader market coming around to the idea that they need a net zero target and therefore need to buy clean energy in order to fuel their growth, so the addressable market for these companies has grown very rapidly,” said Amanda O’Toole, who runs a cleantech thematic fund at Axa Investment Managers.
Much store has been placed in the ability of cutting-edge technology to address sustainability issues. But fund managers are also looking for ESG prospects among more traditional companies.
“ESG and climate investing isn’t all about highly priced concept stocks. We have climate plays in every sector of the market,” said Simon Webber, fund manager at Schroders, who thinks companies such as homebuilder Kingfisher, insurer Munich Re and carmaker BMW will be big winners in the climate transition.
If there is a shakeout in sustainability investing’s fortunes, “there have been a lot of new entrants to the climate and ESG fund management business and we’ll find out, just like with companies, who is good at what they do,” Webber added.
Sustainable investing is also subject to mounting research costs that are expected to reach $1.3bn globally in 2022, straining already thin investment house margins and potentially endangering sustainable strategies if a market correction takes hold.
In Europe, research budgets at asset management houses have more than halved between 2016 and 2022, according to estimates from Frost Consulting, since the companies started financing them out of their own budgets instead of through investor fees under Mifid II reforms.
At the same time, the costs of running ESG strategies have ballooned as funds have launched and grown, and may eclipse overall research budgets by 2024.
“Ironically, European asset managers are less resilient and less sustainable than they were [at the onset of the financial crisis],” said Neil Scarth, of Frost Consulting. “One reason is that in 2008 asset owners rather than asset managers were paying that huge research bill, and that has now evolved to be a significant ESG cost that didn’t [previously] exist for many managers.”
ESG strategies have substantial overheads because of high data and specialised research costs, and the need to hire stewardship departments to engage with companies multiple times per year on sustainability targets.
“We are talking to some senior managers at investment firms who are starting to re-examine the relationship between ESG revenues and costs, in an environment where none of these additional costs are met by asset owners,” Scarth said.
Where climate change meets business, markets and politics. Explore the FT’s coverage here.
Are you curious about the FT’s environmental sustainability commitments? Find out more about our science-based targets here
buy levaquin 500mg levofloxacin 500mg tablet
buy avodart 0.5mg generic buy avodart 0.5mg sale buy zofran 8mg sale
buy spironolactone online generic spironolactone order diflucan 200mg online
ampicillin order online cephalexin brand erythromycin 500mg drug
brand fildena 50mg careprost online order buy methocarbamol 500mg generic
cheap suhagra 100mg buy generic sildenafil buy estrace online cheap
order lamotrigine 200mg for sale buy prazosin for sale tretinoin cream us
order generic tadalis 20mg tadalafil 10mg tablet diclofenac 100mg sale
accutane 20mg canada zithromax 250mg uk zithromax sale
order indomethacin online cheap buy trimox 500mg online trimox 250mg generic
real cialis pharmacy prescription medication for ed sildenafil viagra
order anastrozole pill Us pharmacy viagra real viagra 100mg
cialis 10mg prix vrai sildenafil 100mg prix viagra 200mg comprimГ©
purchase prednisone generic buy tadalafil cialis sildenafil dosage
cialis 10mg kaufen ohne rezept tadalafil 20mg fГјr mГ¤nner viagra 200mg kaufen generika
order modafinil generic Cialis order acetazolamide 250mg without prescription
buy doxycycline 100mg for sale doxycycline 100mg oral order furosemide 100mg sale
buy ramipril 5mg for sale buy azelastine 10ml for sale purchase astelin sprayer
buy clonidine pills tiotropium bromide 9mcg without prescription tiotropium bromide cheap
buspar over the counter cordarone 100mg uk order ditropan online
hytrin 5mg cheap buy leflunomide 10mg sale oral sulfasalazine
order alendronate pill ibuprofen 600mg uk order famotidine 40mg pill
benicar over the counter verapamil 120mg sale acetazolamide 250mg pills
brand tacrolimus buy prograf generic buy ursodiol
order imdur 40mg online order generic imuran 50mg micardis 80mg cost
order zyban 150 mg pills buy strattera sale quetiapine for sale
buy generic zoloft buy sildenafil for sale sildenafil 50mg uk
buy imuran 100 mcg pills imuran online buy order sildenafil 50mg
cheap cialis online fluoxetine uk sildenafil 50mg uk
buy tadalafil 5mg cheap cialis for sale oral symmetrel 100 mg
order revia generic oral naltrexone 50 mg order generic aripiprazole
buy dapsone 100mg pills buy avlosulfon online aceon 8mg oral
order generic provera 10mg buy microzide online purchase periactin generic
provigil 100mg price approved canadian pharmacy ivermectin 6 mg pills
order fluvoxamine generic order generic luvox glipizide online order
isotretinoin us isotretinoin 40mg pill order deltasone online cheap
order piracetam 800 mg sale female viagra sildenafil purchase sildenafil online
zithromax pills order prednisolone 10mg for sale neurontin 100mg price
cialis tadalafil 10mg viagra canada real viagra pills
cialis sale clomipramine price order generic clomipramine
buy chloroquine sale chloroquine generic baricitinib cheap
buy metformin 1000mg online cheap buy generic lipitor 40mg real cialis fast shipping
olanzapine 10mg over the counter zyprexa over the counter purchase diovan pill
purchase norvasc order sildenafil online cheap buy cialis 40mg for sale
clozaril generic buy decadron 0,5 mg for sale buy dexamethasone
oral viagra 50mg brand lisinopril order lisinopril 10mg pills
linezolid 600 mg without prescription online blackjack spins website online casinos real money
purchase omeprazole for sale poker game free slot play
lopressor online buy vardenafil 20mg buy vardenafil 10mg online
assignment website pay for term paper roulette free
cost vardenafil levitra generic medrol oral
very informative articles or reviews at this time.
write essay for money buy thesis paper buy sildenafil 100mg pill
clomid 100mg tablet buy clomiphene 100mg pills caesars casino online
canadian cialis and healthcare tadalafil over the counter sildenafil india
purchase aristocort pills desloratadine 5mg ca buy desloratadine pill
order dapoxetine 30mg without prescription dapoxetine order buy generic synthroid 75mcg
tadalafil 10mg cost cialis 40mg price brand sildenafil 100mg
purchase xenical without prescription purchase diltiazem generic order zovirax 400mg online cheap
brand cialis pills buy propranolol pill buy plavix 150mg generic
zyloprim medication cost allopurinol order ezetimibe 10mg without prescription
brand domperidone domperidone generic order flexeril sale
losartan order online cozaar ca buy topamax 100mg without prescription
order baclofen 25mg for sale purchase lioresal generic buy toradol without prescription
order sumatriptan 50mg sale buy generic dutasteride buy dutasteride pill
colchicine over the counter best casino online best online gambling sites
roulette online with real money online roulette game real money casino online games
tamsulosin generic order generic tamsulosin 0.2mg buy spironolactone 100mg pill
order cialis 40mg pill order generic ampicillin 250mg order cipro generic
buy simvastatin 10mg generic buy zocor 20mg pill order propecia 1mg for sale
metronidazole generic buy metronidazole 200mg order bactrim 480mg
order diflucan 100mg without prescription viagra usa sildenafil 50mg usa
order keflex 500mg without prescription order cleocin pill erythromycin 250mg for sale
tadalafil 5mg cheap order cialis 20mg for sale sildenafil 50mg pills
sildenafil 100mg brand oral tadalafil 5mg cialis 40mg without prescription
order generic ceftin 250mg bimatoprost pill buy methocarbamol sale
cash poker online cialis 5mg cheap cialis for men
cost trazodone order sildenafil 100mg without prescription aurogra 100mg price
where can i buy a research paper stromectol drug generic ivermectin
sildenafil 20mg order lamotrigine online lamotrigine 50mg canada
buy prednisone generic generic prednisone amoxil 500mg usa
viagra 100mg price viagra 50mg ca cialis 40mg canada
casino online slots best drug for ed cialis 40mg uk
azithromycin tablet buy gabapentin 100mg gabapentin online
play poker online free casino world stromectol 12mg oral order provigil online cheap
deltasone pill prazosin 2mg price buy mebendazole
order generic retin retin price brand avanafil
tadalafil online order buy indomethacin 50mg without prescription order indocin pill
Veery nnice style аnd excellent articles, verу litttle
elѕe we want :D.
My blog; cbd vape juice
buy terbinafine 250mg pills purchase lamisil pills amoxicillin 500mg brand
cheap clarithromycin buy catapres sale brand antivert 25mg
buy naproxen generic buy lansoprazole 30mg pills lansoprazole 15mg drug
buy tiotropium bromide 9mcg for sale cost hytrin 1mg order hytrin 1mg generic
purchase proventil online cheap albuterol 100mcg us cipro order online
pioglitazone over the counter cheap sildenafil tablets order sildenafil 50mg online cheap
tadalafil 40mg pill global poker online gambling site
cialis 40mg tablet best pill for ed order cialis 20mg for sale
online gambling slots games best casinos
ivermectin australia buy amantadine 100 mg dapsone 100 mg ca
best casino games big fish casino online blackjack card game
best poker online real money purchase essays writing paper online
edit my paper sulfasalazine price azulfidine 500 mg cheap
buy doxycycline 200mg pill albuterol cheap order cleocin 150mg
buy asacol 800mg generic irbesartan 300mg uk order avapro 300mg generic
olmesartan 10mg usa olmesartan 20mg generic purchase depakote generic
diamox usa buy generic acetazolamide 250mg imuran usa
cost digoxin 250 mg buy molnupiravir 200mg pill order molnunat online cheap
order clobetasol clobetasol over the counter amiodarone pills
order carvedilol 25mg online order coreg 6.25mg for sale generic elavil
purchase amoxicillin without prescription amoxil 1000mg generic ivermectin drug
buy priligy generic avanafil 100mg ca order motilium 10mg pill
order nortriptyline 25mg pills brand nortriptyline order generic paroxetine 20mg
indocin 50mg cheap cenforce 100mg for sale cenforce 50mg us
buy doxycycline 200mg sale chloroquine brand methylprednisolone cost in usa
order fenofibrate 200mg generic buy fenofibrate generic buy generic viagra 100mg
tadalafil 10mg pill order tadalafil 10mg online amoxicillin for sale online
cheap cialis generic sildenafil for sale sildenafil over counter
oral esomeprazole order esomeprazole 20mg generic buy furosemide 100mg for sale
buy cialis tablets buy erectile dysfunction meds buy ed pills cheap
generic minocin oral minocin buy hytrin 5mg online
modafinil 200mg price provigil 200mg oral order phenergan generic
glucophage 1000mg for sale glucophage over the counter buy generic nolvadex 20mg
order prednisone online order isotretinoin 40mg pill amoxicillin 500mg oral
clomid 50mg for sale lipitor 20mg canada prednisolone 5mg sale
best natural ed pills buy ed medications online order proscar 1mg pills
order isotretinoin 10mg online ampicillin 500mg canada ampicillin 250mg generic
purchase zofran pills cheap zofran 8mg trimethoprim tablet
ivermectin uk buy erectile dysfunction medication prednisone 40mg cheap
For the reason that the admin of this site is working, no uncertainty very quickly it will be renowned, due to its quality contents. 온라인카지노 Glance complicated to more delivered agreeable from you!
albuterol 2mg cost levoxyl uk augmentin 375mg tablet
accutane pills buy accutane 20mg generic zithromax 250mg brand
provigil 100mg pills lopressor uk purchase lopressor online
generic prednisolone 20mg gabapentin canada purchase lasix for sale
order dutasteride online orlistat price xenical 120mg pill
azathioprine 25mg tablet order azathioprine generic naprosyn pills
vibra-tabs order vibra-tabs ca acyclovir canada