If you have a question like this one, send it in. I’ll tackle case studies that have educational value.
“I am anxious to pay off my mortgage since, with the current standard deduction, there is no advantage in claiming mortgage interest.
“My wife and I are retired. I am 72, with a pension along with Social Security, and have $850,000 in my IRA. I have a mortgage balance of $134,000. To get that after tax I would have to take a distribution of $185,000, which obviously will reduce my portfolio dramatically.
“Is this a good move? My return on investment with Fidelity has been 10-15 percent annually with a 60/40 mix of stock and bond funds.”
Readers send in queries like this. I’m going to be answering the ones that illustrate tricky tax and investment decisions.
My answer to the Missourian:
Good move? Probably. Retirees should pay off their mortgages. You’re lucky to be in a position to do that.
For many people, no doubt you included, taking out a mortgage in order to get into a house turned out to be a good decision. But we have to deconstruct home ownership. A mortgaged house is two things, an asset and a liability. Having a house is a good investment. Having a mortgage is a bad investment. The goal of a retiree should be to have a house without a mortgage.
The 40% of your IRA in bond funds means you are a lender. If the funds track the U.S. bond market then a good portion of your savings is being lent out, at low rates, to the U.S. Treasury. This part of your portfolio is earning 2% at best. Your mortgage is probably costing you 3% or more.
Borrowing at 3% in order to lend at 2% is a bad idea.
Two things cause people like you to hesitate before cashing in an IRA in order to pay down a debt: the taxes they’d owe and the IRA returns they’d miss.
Yes, the IRA withdrawal means writing out a check to tax collectors. You’re probably in a 27.4% bracket (state and federal combined), so you’re going to owe $51,000 on a $185,000 withdrawal.
But taxes on this money are inevitable. If you are past 59-1/2 (the cut-off to avoid penalties) and not expecting to see your tax bracket go down, postponing the inevitable does not leave you better off. If the IRA grows, so do the tax bills.
The arithmetic becomes clearer if you rethink what an IRA is. Where you see an $850,000 asset, I see something different. I see you as the custodian for an account that has two beneficiaries. You’re sitting on $617,000 that belongs to you and also on $233,000 that already belongs to tax collectors.
Look at what growth does to this account. If, for example, you’re able to double the portfolio at Fidelity, the account will then have in it $1.7 million. Of this, $1,234,000 will belong to you and $466,000 will belong to the tax guys. You’ve doubled your money and you’ve doubled the government’s money.
In effect, what you have is not an $850,000 asset but a $617,000 asset that’s all yours and that grows tax-free.
What, then, are you sacrificing when you take a big distribution? Assuming you take it out of the bond portion of your portfolio, you’re losing a return that comes to 2% pretax and, thanks to the wonders of IRAs, the same 2% after taxes.
And what are you gaining by ripping up the mortgage? You’re getting a guaranteed return of 3% before taxes. Thanks to the wonders of the standard deduction, you’re not deducting interest and that 3% mortgage is costing you the same 3% after taxes. So getting rid of a mortgage earns you 3%.
There it is. Paying off the mortgage costs you an aftertax 2% and earns you an aftertax 3%. It’s a winning move. It would still be a winner, albeit a more modest one, if tax rules change and you go back to deducting interest.
Now let’s tackle the other reason people stick with 3% mortgages, which is that they are investing money to earn 10% or 15%. This is a faulty comparison. High returns come from risky assets like stocks. The mortgage is a sure-thing liability (you can’t duck the debt), so it must be compared to a sure-thing asset (a loan to the U.S. Treasury).
The apples-to-apples comparison comes into sharper focus when I hypothesize that your entire $185,000 withdrawal comes out of low-risk bonds. At this first stage of your financial makeover, then, the stock funds aren’t touched.
Now you take a look at what’s left and see a Fidelity account that has a high percentage in stocks. Is that allocation too high? Maybe, maybe not. But that’s a separate discussion.
Selling bonds to pay off a mortgage leaves you better off no matter what happens to the stock market. Meanwhile, whether you have too much money in the stock market is an independent decision that shouldn’t influence your thinking about the mortgage.
Unlike comparing 2% to 3%, determining the correct level of risk for a 72-year-old is not a question that has a clear answer. Taking money out of stocks would lower your expected return but might be wise anyway. What are your living costs and how well are they covered by pensions and Social Security? Would your retirement survive a stock market crash with the portfolio you have now? Have a talk with your wealth advisor about this.
Whatever you do, don’t compare 10% stock market returns to 3% mortgages.
I said, above, that the mortgage paydown is probably a good move. Now here are some things to be cautious about.
First, your tax bracket. You may need to carve up the $185,000 distribution into thirds, spreading it over 2022-2024, in order to avoid being kicked from a 22% federal rate into 24%.
Next, your near-term plans. Any chance you’ll be moving to Texas or Florida? If so, hold off on excess distributions until you’re out of reach of the 5.4% Missouri tax.
Last, your end game. Is there a good chance that a diminished IRA will run dry while you’re still healthy enough to live independently? Would you at that point be averse to moving out—to a rental or to a smaller house—in order to extract some cash? And would you, in order to stay put, probably use a reverse mortgage to cover monthly expenses? If this outcome is likely, and if your existing mortgage has a lot of years to run, you should perhaps hang onto it. Its terms are much better than anything you’d get on a reverse mortgage down the road.
Do you have a financial situation like this? Send a description to the address listed in my bio. Include a first name and a state of residence. Include enough detail to generate a useful analysis. Letters will be edited for clarity and brevity; only some will be selected; the answers are intended to be educational and not a replacement for professional advice.
levaquin generic levaquin 250mg without prescription
avodart sale tamsulosin 0.4mg usa buy ondansetron 8mg for sale
order spironolactone 100mg without prescription order diflucan online order fluconazole 100mg generic
order ampicillin buy erythromycin 500mg sale erythromycin order online
sildenafil oral bimatoprost cheap brand methocarbamol 500mg
buy suhagra 50mg without prescription estradiol 1mg for sale estradiol brand
lamotrigine 50mg tablet order minipress pills buy retin cream
order tadalis 20mg online cheap tadalis 20mg order diclofenac 50mg online cheap
order isotretinoin 10mg pills purchase zithromax pill order azithromycin 500mg without prescription
order indomethacin 50mg generic purchase terbinafine generic buy amoxicillin 500mg pills
cialis tadalafil 5mg brand name cialis overnight sildenafil over counter
arimidex buy online where to buy viagra in nigeria order viagra 100mg
cialis 10mg sans ordonnance pharmacie en ligne viagra sildenafil 25mg pas cher
prednisone 10mg drug best price generic cialis 20 mg sildenafil cost
tadalafil kaufen fГјr mГ¤nner viagra 200mg kaufen generika viagra 50mg fГјr mГ¤nner
order isotretinoin 40mg generic purchase stromectol generic ivermectin 1 cream
modafinil 100mg for sale provigil 100mg price acetazolamide 250 mg us
order generic doxycycline 200mg purchase doxycycline without prescription generic furosemide 100mg
buy ramipril 5mg generic clobetasol for sale azelastine 10ml over the counter
order catapres 0.1mg pill order antivert 25 mg sale generic tiotropium bromide 9mcg
buspirone for sale dilantin drug buy ditropan for sale
terazosin pills arava 10mg without prescription buy sulfasalazine 500 mg sale
order alendronate 70mg pill order paracetamol 500mg online cheap buy pepcid 40mg generic
olmesartan 20mg ca oral acetazolamide 250 mg diamox order online
prograf over the counter tacrolimus 1mg brand urso sale
order imdur buy imdur for sale telmisartan 80mg canada
zyban medication quetiapine 100mg price brand quetiapine
cost molnupiravir 200mg buy omnicef 300 mg without prescription buy lansoprazole 30mg online
order sertraline 100mg without prescription kamagra 200mg uk viagra 50mg usa
order salbutamol 100mcg generic order pantoprazole 20mg online viagra 100mg us
where to buy cialis prozac pills buy viagra pill
order tadalafil 20mg pyridium canada buy symmetrel 100 mg pill
buy naltrexone without prescription albendazole 400 mg pills order abilify 30mg online
purchase dapsone pills nifedipine drug perindopril 4mg pills
purchase provera sale microzide order online order periactin online
order provigil online buy stromectol 12mg pill ivermectin 12 mg stromectol
buy luvox online glucotrol brand order glucotrol 5mg sale
buy accutane 40mg pills prednisone 10mg price order deltasone online
order piracetam 800 mg online cheap buy sildenafil 100mg for sale order sildenafil 100mg pills
azithromycin pill generic prednisolone 5mg neurontin over the counter
tadalafil 20mg cheap sildenafil online order sildenafil pharmacy
generic lasix purchase hydroxychloroquine sale buy hydroxychloroquine pills
cialis 10mg us anafranil order order anafranil 25mg online cheap
chloroquine over the counter oral chloroquine order olumiant online cheap
order sporanox pill progesterone pills cost tinidazole
glycomet ca buy glycomet 500mg online cheap tadalafil 5mg usa
purchase olanzapine pills nebivolol 5mg for sale buy diovan 160mg generic
buy norvasc 10mg generic buy cialis 5mg without prescription cialis tadalafil 10mg
buy generic clozaril 100mg dexamethasone 0,5 mg pill dexamethasone pills
sildenafil 50mg cheap cheap lisinopril 2.5mg brand lisinopril 2.5mg
order linezolid 600mg for sale zyvox canada online blackjack for real money
prilosec 20mg over the counter chumba casino free welcome spins no deposit
purchase lopressor online tenormin tablet levitra 10mg generic
hire essay writer pay for essay best online casino real money
buy levitra 10mg online lyrica 75mg canada medrol 4mg online
letter writing services edit letter female viagra
order clomid 50mg pills clomiphene 100mg for sale real money online casino
buy tadalafil pills brand name viagra viagra 100mg for sale
cheap aristocort purchase clarinex online cheap desloratadine for sale online
order priligy 90mg pills dapoxetine 30mg price oral synthroid 75mcg
buy cialis 10mg generic sildenafil overnight shipping usa buy sildenafil for sale
purchase xenical online buy orlistat 60mg online cheap buy acyclovir 800mg without prescription
order cialis 5mg pill cheap cialis for sale clopidogrel 75mg brand
zyloprim pills zetia 10mg tablet zetia tablet
cheap methotrexate 5mg buy methotrexate 5mg generic reglan 20mg drug
domperidone cheap brand sumycin flexeril online buy
cozaar 50mg pills buy generic cozaar 50mg buy topiramate 100mg
baclofen 25mg brand baclofen online buy generic toradol
buy sumatriptan pill dutasteride tablet brand avodart
brand colchicine 0.5mg real money slots free spins no deposit play blackjack
zantac cost order ranitidine 300mg without prescription order generic celecoxib 200mg
poker online for money best real money casino free online slots
tamsulosin 0.4mg pill zofran medication buy spironolactone 25mg pill
tadalafil 10mg uk cipro 1000mg sale cipro 1000mg drug
simvastatin tablet order zocor 10mg online buy proscar
buy flagyl 400mg pills buy augmentin 375mg purchase bactrim pills
buy diflucan 100mg pill buy diflucan 200mg sale sildenafil 100mg for sale
purchase cephalexin online cheap erythromycin for sale erythromycin medication
cialis 20mg cheap female viagra sildenafil viagra pills
purchase viagra for sale sildenafil 50mg us order cialis 5mg online
buy cefuroxime generic robaxin 500mg price methocarbamol 500mg us
gambling casinos casino online gambling cost cialis 5mg
trazodone 100mg canada cost suhagra order sildenafil generic
buying an essay speechwriters ivermectin 3mg tab
sildenafil next day delivery estrace price lamotrigine sale
prednisone 5mg uk deltasone 20mg generic buy amoxil 250mg for sale
sildenafil on line viagra 50mg for sale order cialis 5mg for sale
free casino games no registration no download buy cialis online safely cialis 40mg pill
zithromax sale zithromax 500mg for sale buy neurontin 800mg pill
poker online games order provigil online cheap modafinil 200mg pill
purchase sildenafil generic sildenafil tablet budesonide medication
prednisone 20mg oral mebendazole 100mg over the counter mebendazole order
purchase tretinoin generic buy avana sale order generic avanafil 100mg
buy tadacip 20mg online cheap buy tadalafil 20mg pills indomethacin 75mg generic
terbinafine cheap buy trimox 250mg generic purchase amoxicillin generic
order biaxin pill antivert online order antivert 25mg drug
purchase naproxen pills order naproxen 250mg generic lansoprazole for sale online
proventil uk buy cipro pills buy ciprofloxacin generic
order actos 30mg sale actos pill order sildenafil 100mg
montelukast uk viagra 200mg for sale brand sildenafil
oral tadalafil 10mg Cialis cheap price play slots online
brand tadalafil 20mg Cialis overnight shipping cialis pills 20mg
slots online casino slot games online blackjack with real money
buy ivermectin 12mg purchase dapsone online cheap dapsone us
casino gambling casino card games real money slot machines
nifedipine pills order perindopril 4mg generic fexofenadine 180mg drug
world series of poker online online pharmacy usa essays done for you
brand altace 10mg altace online buy etoricoxib 120mg canada
write essay service leflunomide 20mg price azulfidine for sale
purchase asacol pill astelin 10 ml uk irbesartan 300mg usa
buy benicar 10mg online buy depakote 500mg without prescription order divalproex without prescription
diamox us acetazolamide oral buy azathioprine generic
cheap temovate buy buspirone 5mg for sale amiodarone 200mg uk
lanoxin 250mg uk telmisartan tablet molnunat sale
coreg 6.25mg cheap ditropan price purchase amitriptyline for sale
cheap amoxil 250mg stromectol 12mg uk stromectol tab 3mg
order alendronate 35mg online motrin 400mg without prescription ibuprofen pills
priligy online avana usa purchase domperidone for sale
nortriptyline over the counter order paxil 20mg online buy paroxetine 20mg for sale
order indomethacin 50mg pill indomethacin 75mg price order cenforce online cheap
buy famotidine pills tacrolimus ca remeron 15mg sale
doxycycline price buy doxycycline generic medrol 16mg without a doctor prescription
order ropinirole 1mg generic order rocaltrol 0.25mg pills trandate 100 mg pills
order fenofibrate pill buy sildenafil 100mg for sale sildenafil 50mg oral
purchase nexium generic purchase clarithromycin generic lasix 100mg cost
cialis professional Cialis express delivery buy viagra pills
genuine cialis cialis generic best ed pill
purchase glycomet pills buy glycomet 500mg online cheap order tamoxifen 20mg generic
buy modafinil 100mg generic buy stromectol 3mg without prescription promethazine over the counter
purchase serophene sale order clomid 50mg sale buy prednisolone 40mg sale
prednisone 20mg tablet order deltasone 10mg pill amoxicillin 1000mg oral
accutane 20mg without prescription acillin tablet ampicillin 500mg cost
medicine for erectile proscar us buy propecia 5mg generic
stromectol pill stromectol 12mg over the counter order deltasone pill
order ondansetron pill amoxil 500mg canada sulfamethoxazole brand
order accutane 40mg pill accutane cheap azithromycin 250mg without prescription
albuterol canada albuterol 4mg for sale purchase augmentin online
order provigil 100mg generic order generic zestril 2.5mg order lopressor 50mg
cheap prednisolone for sale generic furosemide 100mg lasix price
схема обналичивания денег
карта с балансом купить