Business is booming.

The three questions that dominate investment


The writer is a financial journalist and author of ‘More: The 10,000-Year Rise of the World Economy’

Three linked questions are at the heart of investment decisions today. What is the risk-free rate of return that investors can now secure? What future return is it reasonable to expect? And what is the prudent level to take or “draw down” from a pension fund or saving scheme? The answers to those questions affect everyone from charitable foundations through giant pension funds to ordinary 60-year-olds contemplating how best to use their pension pot.

None of these questions is easy to answer. Take the risk-free rate. This could be defined as the return on short-term bank deposits (virtually zero at the time of writing), the yield on two-year Treasury bonds (0.6 per cent) or 10-year bonds (1.44 per cent).

All of these are very low by historical standards and much lower than the current rate of inflation (6.8 per cent in the US). Investors seem bound to see the value of their money erode in real terms and if they sell the bonds before maturity, there is the risk that they will lose money in nominal terms as well.

Should investors try explicitly to hedge their portfolios against higher prices, then inflation-protected 10-year Treasury bonds yield minus 1 per cent, guaranteeing a real loss if held till maturity. As the joke goes, the risk-free return has turned into return-free risk.

The consequences of these very low yields are immense, because other assets are priced in relation to the risk-free return. For example, companies that borrow in the bond market pay a spread over the government bond yield to reflect the risk of default.

As government bond yields have fallen, so has the cost of corporate borrowing. Pension funds use the corporate bond yield when calculating the cost of paying retirement benefits; the lower yields fall, the greater the cost of meeting future liabilities.

The rise in the accounting cost of meeting pension liabilities explains why so many schemes are in deficit even though stock markets have been strong performers since the 2008 crisis. It also explains why many scheme sponsors try to match their liabilities by buying bonds. And in turn, this explains why there are still plenty of buyers of bonds at very low yields.

Given the unattractiveness of prospective bond returns, it is not surprising that many investors would prefer to rely on equities. But what return are equities likely to deliver? The standard formula is to add a risk premium to the government bond yield. Historically, this has been around 4 per cent globally, according to the work of Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh and Mike Staunton of the London Business School. Adding 4 percentage points to the yield on the inflation-linked bond of minus 1 per cent would give us an expected real return from equities of 3 per cent.

But are investors really expecting equity returns to be that low? It seems unlikely, given the way that they have piled into stocks even in the face of the pandemic. Instead, if investors believe future returns from equities to be high, that logically means they expect that a very high risk premium is needed from the asset class. In other words, they think equities are a lot riskier than normal. Again, that does not seem to be a mainstream view.

However, a rule-for-thumb for markets is that when current valuations are high, future returns will be low. In America, equity valuations are very high, as measured by the cyclically adjusted price-earnings (Cape) ratio developed by Robert Shiller of Yale University, which compares share prices with the average corporate earnings of the past 10 years. The current Cape ratio is 38, a level that was only higher during the peak of the dotcom bubble of 2000.

But if future returns are going to be low, investors face some very difficult decisions. Pension schemes will have to ask for more money from their corporate sponsors or, in the public sector, from taxpayers. Individual workers trying to assemble a pension pot need to save more now, and spend less; an approach that governments trying to boost their economies may not entirely welcome.

By the same token, if future returns are going to be low, then the pace of drawdowns must be reduced, too. Charitable foundations have often followed a 5 per cent rule when deciding how much income to take from their foundations. That looks too high. Similarly, retirees with pension pots may need to draw down less than 4 per cent a year to ensure their money does not run out. Investors are bombarded with information about which stocks or mutual funds to pick in the hope of beating the market. Too little time is devoted to discussing how much money they should set aside in the first place.

Source link

  1. Dnwzwm says
  2. Wpkcfb says

    buy dutasteride online cheap dutasteride for sale online order zofran 8mg for sale

  3. Tsoktf says

    buy generic aldactone buy valacyclovir purchase fluconazole pill

  4. Mczyhl says

    ampicillin over the counter erythromycin cheap purchase erythromycin generic

  5. Imxvtt says

    fildena 100mg brand bimatoprost sale robaxin 500mg uk

  6. Gajvia says

    buy sildenafil online estrace price generic estradiol

  7. Unomtg says

    lamictal for sale online buy generic tretinoin buy retin online

  8. Wuonlj says

    buy generic tadalafil oral tadalafil 10mg diclofenac 100mg over the counter

  9. Zfxhig says

    accutane 10mg pill cheap accutane 10mg azithromycin canada

  10. Bulcrs says

    cheap indocin 75mg trimox us purchase amoxicillin for sale

  11. Hmtijm says

    best cialis sites online natural herbs for ed viagra 100mg cost

  12. Sbckyv says

    order arimidex pill order arimidex generic cheap sildenafil pills

  13. Mfxgdl says

    vrai tadalafil 20mg prix viagra 50mg en france generique viagra 50mg

  14. Srkdun says

    buy deltasone without prescription brand viagra 100mg viagra 100mg

  15. Sglhwl says

    tadalafil für männer cialis 10mg kaufen für männer sildenafil 100mg für frauen

  16. Detrha says

    order accutane online cheap amoxicillin 250mg usa stromectol for head lice

  17. Wnzobk says

    doxycycline 200mg oral buy clomiphene 50mg without prescription order furosemide 100mg online cheap

  18. Pvynvk says

    clonidine 0.1 mg tablet buy catapres 0.1 mg pills buy spiriva 9 mcg sale

  19. Uudenx says

    buy buspirone pill dilantin order purchase ditropan without prescription

  20. Lubxdi says

    terazosin 5mg us terazosin drug buy sulfasalazine without prescription

  21. Thriog says

    order fosamax 70mg sale alendronate online order famotidine 40mg without prescription

  22. Idurdm says

    order benicar 10mg for sale acetazolamide 250 mg oral diamox generic

  23. Epqiry says

    tacrolimus 5mg price buy generic labetalol 100 mg order ursodiol 150mg

  24. Pyevfj says

    buy imdur 20mg telmisartan 80mg tablet buy telmisartan 20mg

  25. Vbjhrj says

    order bupropion 150 mg pills order strattera 10mg pills buy seroquel 50mg sale

  26. Dcnkkk says

    oral molnunat 200 mg cefdinir 300mg usa prevacid uk

  27. Ifzvvk says

    generic sertraline 50mg order lexapro 10mg for sale sildenafil 25 mg

  28. Qjuipo says

    buy imuran online cheap order generic imuran 100mcg viagra sildenafil

  29. Rqvuiy says

    us cialis sales fluoxetine 40mg cost buy sildenafil 50mg without prescription

  30. Nmoqda says

    cialis 40mg canada oral phenazopyridine 200mg symmetrel 100mg cheap

  31. Rpqjsa says

    revia 50 mg pill albendazole 400mg over the counter order generic aripiprazole

  32. Pniptu says

    avlosulfon 100mg cost avlosulfon 100mg oral perindopril over the counter

  33. Ayolxm says

    provera buy online cost microzide 25mg cyproheptadine order

  34. Rzohep says

    buy modafinil 200mg pill buy stromectol 12mg generic ivermectin 5 mg

  35. Wuydaw says

    buy fluvoxamine sale fluvoxamine uk order generic glipizide

  36. Jofsbv says

    buy accutane generic amoxil usa buy prednisone 20mg generic

  37. Gzsffh says

    order nootropil 800mg pills order piracetam sale buy sildenafil 100mg online

  38. Zzwccq says

    zithromax cheap prednisolone 5mg over the counter buy neurontin 100mg

  39. Pmcmyl says

    cialis pill tadalafil 5mg viagra overnight shipping usa

  40. Ybyzlc says

    brand lasix 100mg hydroxychloroquine cost plaquenil 200mg brand

  41. Cfmoyd says

    cialis pills 5mg cost clomipramine 25mg clomipramine tablet

  42. Eokxji says

    sporanox drug buy tinidazole 500mg purchase tindamax without prescription

  43. Icagcp says

    glucophage 500mg drug atorvastatin 80mg cost cialis next day

  44. Gprlmg says

    order zyprexa 10mg generic buy zyprexa 10mg without prescription valsartan over the counter

  45. Zuukgs says

    order amlodipine 10mg online cheap amlodipine over the counter buy cialis 5mg without prescription

  46. Upddcx says

    clozaril pills clozaril pills decadron 0,5 mg sale

  47. Xbnktb says

    cheap viagra without prescription cheap generic viagra lisinopril 10mg ca

  48. Ekhxcs says

    buy zyvox 600mg sale jackpot party casino gambling games

  49. Wrgsjr says

    order prilosec 10mg generic order prilosec 10mg pill play online blackjack for real money

  50. Xqynnu says

    metoprolol 50mg drug vardenafil us levitra 10mg over the counter

  51. Qhlluy says

    write college essays for money help writing a research paper online roulette free

  52. Ywnpot says

    buy vardenafil without prescription levitra online methylprednisolone 8mg for sale

  53. Tuzrnq says

    buy research papers online no plagiarism my future essay writing order viagra 50mg online cheap

  54. alanya escort says

    I truly appreciate your technique of writing a blog. I added it to my bookmark site list and will

  55. Rpwhyh says

    clomid pill clomiphene us free spins no deposit us

  56. Vwwpjc says

    aristocort 10mg for sale order loratadine 10mg online cheap clarinex buy online

  57. Gawgda says

    order priligy 90mg without prescription misoprostol 200mcg over the counter synthroid 75mcg pill

  58. Cwhnyz says

    buy tadalafil online buy viagra 100mg for sale buy viagra tablets

  59. Hjlybf says

    orlistat 120mg cheap acyclovir 400mg usa zovirax buy online

  60. Omxtfh says

    order cialis 40mg online order inderal 20mg pill clopidogrel 75mg canada

  61. Upqulv says

    zyloprim 300mg pills order ezetimibe sale oral zetia

  62. Vsjtjk says

    methotrexate tablet methotrexate for sale online reglan 10mg cost

  63. Fmfwct says

    order cozaar 25mg without prescription purchase topiramate pill oral topamax

  64. Rqzmzk says

    purchase baclofen for sale tizanidine price purchase toradol online cheap

  65. Nisdvi says

    sumatriptan online buy levofloxacin for sale dutasteride ca

  66. Wolguj says

    order colchicine 0.5mg pills slots real money roulette online free

  67. Vrutir says

    order generic zantac 300mg order meloxicam 7.5mg celecoxib uk

  68. Vwnqss says

    flomax cheap buy tamsulosin online cheap order aldactone 25mg without prescription

  69. Hvintm says

    cialis 5mg pill buy ampicillin 500mg pills ciprofloxacin 1000mg tablet

  70. Eklujj says

    zocor 10mg for sale valacyclovir 1000mg us buy finasteride 5mg for sale

  71. Yyzrzl says

    generic metronidazole 200mg metronidazole 400mg generic buy bactrim 480mg without prescription

  72. Gjrzuw says

    order diflucan 100mg online cheap buy viagra generic cheap sildenafil generic

  73. Nyvezw says

    keflex cheap order cephalexin 500mg erythromycin price

  74. Rvizks says

    tadalafil generic name buy cialis 40mg online buy sildenafil 100mg online cheap

  75. Fimqwl says

    cialis viagra sales order cialis 20mg pill cialis tadalafil 40mg

  76. Fjahdn says

    ceftin 500mg usa buy robaxin 500mg online cheap robaxin pills

  77. Zbmuhu says

    slots games free order tadalafil 10mg generic cialis 5mg pills

  78. Wglace says

    i need help with my research paper pay for assignments australia ivermectin 0.08 oral solution

  79. Otlsem says

    buy prednisone 10mg online order accutane 20mg for sale purchase amoxil generic

  80. Dfxhmb says

    viagra 100mg usa order sildenafil 100mg without prescription buy generic tadalafil 5mg

  81. majorsite says

    Your article has answered the question I was wondering about! I would like to write a thesis on this subject, but I would like you to give your opinion once 😀 majorsite

  82. Akhdsc says

    play poker online free buy ed pills sale cialis 10mg drug

  83. Oqftvx says

    azithromycin cheap azithromycin price gabapentin online buy

  84. Titegu says

    big fish casino online order stromectol 12mg generic order modafinil without prescription

  85. Mignml says

    cost furosemide 40mg order doxycycline online cost plaquenil 400mg

  86. Qfokxr says

    buy fildena 100mg without prescription nolvadex 10mg us purchase budesonide for sale

  87. Mxvgdn says

    oral prednisone 10mg buy mebendazole 100mg buy vermox 100mg pills

  88. Vytknt says

    retin cream for sale buy tadalis 10mg sale avana 100mg us

  89. Xutewz says

    tadacip 20mg cost diclofenac 50mg sale buy indocin 50mg generic

  90. casino online says

    I’m writing on this topic these days, casino online, but I have stopped writing because there is no reference material. Then I accidentally found your article. I can refer to a variety of materials, so I think the work I was preparing will work! Thank you for your efforts.

  91. Ismdfh says

    buy naprosyn 500mg generic prevacid 30mg generic buy generic prevacid

  92. Epjfqv says

    order clarithromycin 500mg generic order clonidine 0.1mg online cheap meclizine 25 mg without prescription

  93. Zqquyb says

    proventil 100 mcg canada cheap albuterol 100 mcg cipro tablet

  94. Viktbs says

    spiriva pill purchase hytrin pills terazosin 5mg drug

  95. Alraza says

    pioglitazone without prescription viagra online buy sildenafil citrate 50mg

  96. Lrnzjd says

    montelukast for sale online 50mg viagra over the counter viagra

  97. Mowpbx says

    tadalafil 20mg us online poker sites card games online

  98. Lwmlaq says

    cialis 5 mg Brand name cialis overnight tadalafil 20mg usa

  99. Igrhme says

    roulette online slots free free roulette games

  100. Kcwyay says

    free poker online online slots online roulette free

  101. Qcviyg says

    nifedipine pills buy allegra 120mg sale buy allegra 180mg

  102. Cpoqpi says

    play roulette online real money online canadian pharmacy legit write essay service

  103. Susoax says

    order ramipril 5mg online cheap order glimepiride 4mg online cheap brand etoricoxib 120mg

  104. Dmzynb says

    how to write a hiring letter buy arava generic purchase azulfidine for sale

  105. Sjnwyd says

    doxycycline 200mg price buy cleocin 150mg pills buy cleocin pill

  106. Objdhb says

    buy asacol 800mg irbesartan 300mg ca order avapro without prescription

  107. Umdrir says

    buy olmesartan 10mg for sale depakote 250mg over the counter divalproex 500mg for sale

  108. Tfrhrt says

    temovate usa buy amiodarone 200mg without prescription buy amiodarone 200mg online cheap

  109. Nfsxco says

    buy diamox 250 mg pills order imuran 25mg online cost azathioprine

  110. Dopzho says

    cost lanoxin buy molnupiravir 200 mg online cheap buy molnunat

  111. Pkhisk says

    coreg 25mg brand order generic coreg order amitriptyline

  112. Jbparj says

    buy alendronate 35mg order fosamax 70mg generic motrin 400mg price

  113. Jhznrk says

    order nortriptyline for sale order panadol order paroxetine 20mg without prescription

  114. Rauwad says

    buy famotidine 40mg online prograf 1mg uk remeron 15mg pills

  115. Elcffp says

    doxycycline 200mg oral buy chloroquine 250mg online methylprednisolone cheap

  116. Smngnp says

    buy requip 1mg for sale requip order online order labetalol pill

  117. canada drugs online pharmacy says
  118. Ambgzb says

    tricor 200mg for sale order sildenafil 50mg sale sildenafil 25mg for sale

  119. Uzzwou says

    buy tadalafil online cheap USA tadalafil buy sildenafil pill

  120. Xcwuvz says

    cialis tadalafil Cialis next day delivery pills for ed

  121. Tdkrxt says

    buy prednisone 5mg online cheap accutane 40mg generic order amoxil 250mg sale

  122. Guuixs says

    generic sildenafil 100mg buy proscar 1mg online purchase finasteride for sale

  123. Nqmkyy says

    buy generic ondansetron 8mg ondansetron 4mg over the counter buy trimethoprim online cheap

  124. Wgxkuo says

    order albuterol order generic albuterol augmentin 375mg ca

  125. Inpgsb says

    provigil 100mg oral order provigil 100mg generic order generic lopressor 100mg

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.