Business is booming.

High hopes for private credit

86


This article is an on-site version of our Unhedged newsletter. Sign up here to get the newsletter sent straight to your inbox every weekday

Good morning. I guess we’re just killing time and waiting for the Federal Reserve at this point? Well, while you wait for Wednesday to come, here are some thoughts on private credit and cryptocurrencies. Email us your thoughts on either: robert.armstrong@ft.com and ethan.wu@ft.com

How does private credit beat the bond market?

Often I write headlines or section headings that end with question marks, even though I know the answer. This is not one of those times. I do not know how private credit beats the bond market, or even if it does, in risk-adjusted terms. It is pretty evident, though, that a lot of other people believe that it does, and that it will continue to do so.

We can see this belief in the fact that money is absolutely pouring into the asset class, with the explicit expectation that it will beat the dreary performance of the public debt market. Stories about this appear with thudding regularity in the Financial Times and elsewhere. The most recent was in Monday’s Wall Street Journal, which described how Ares Management has raised $8bn for a new private debt fund that will invest primarily in loans that back leveraged buyouts. It had set out to raise just $4.5bn, but what the hell. Where does all the demand come from? It ain’t complicated:

“More than anything, it’s about low interest rates,” said Kipp deVeer, head of Ares Credit Group. “A lot of investors are frustrated by the low yield in fixed income they’ve traditionally allocated to, whether it’s loans or government bonds or high-grade corporates.”

The frustrated investors include California Public Employees’ Retirement System, which announced last month it was so frustrated it was adding 5 per cent more leverage to its portfolio and changing its asset allocations as follows:

Calpers’ return target is 6.8 per cent. Junk bond indices are yielding 4.5 per cent. Triple-C bond indices (featuring bonds that are “currently vulnerable and dependent on favourable . . . conditions to meet financial commitments” in S&P Ratings’ words) yield only 115 basis points more than Calpers target. Frustrating! So here we come private markets, with a big chunk going to private credit. The Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan is doing the same thing, for the same reason.

With private equity, we have a pretty good idea where the returns in excess of public markets once came from. They came from high leverage and from managing that leverage skilfully so it did not cause a meltdown during recessions. I used the past tense here because private equity as an industry has not outperformed public markets in the past decade (something of an achievement while using high leverage during a stonking, continuous bull market, but with the right fee structure the sky’s the limit).

Both private equity and private debt funds say that part of their excess return comes from an illiquidity discount. I’m not certain, but I suspect this is false. The primary customers for the private equity and debt funds — pension managers — actually prefer the illiquidity, because it comes with apparently stable returns uncorrelated with other asset classes, which is flattering to the pension managers’ portfolios. In other words, I believe managers pay more than they otherwise would for private markets’ illiquidity, because it brings with it returns that are not marked to market. My work has made me cynical.

If not illiquidity, then what is the source of extra returns? Executives at Apollo Global Management have something to say about this. Here is Marc Rowan, Apollo’s chief executive, on the company’s credit business, talking during an investor call:

“This is a fixed income replacement business. This is not an opportunistic credit business. Our goal in our [private debt] segment is to produce 150 to 200 basis points of excess return over the equivalent [publicly traded bonds] across the capital structure. We want to get paid . . . for illiquidity and complexity and origination, not for taking additional credit risk or assuming other risks.”

So higher return, less risk, because finding high quality private loans to make or buy is tricky, and Apollo is very good at it. Here is another Apollo executive, Christopher Edson, at a conference:

“There is no excess spread left in liquid [public] markets, so we believe that we need to originate [these loans] directly. This is basically manufacturing and creating the factory to generate these assets on an ongoing and recurring basis to drive excess spread and to effectively create these assets at wholesale prices . . . What are these origination platforms? They’re living and breathing companies. They have management teams. They have dozens or hundreds of employees.”

These Apollo-owned companies lend money to small companies, and lend against planes or rental car companies, houses and other assets. Apollo can earn 200 basis points more off these loans for the same risk level because, apparently, it’s just too hard for anyone else to supply the same customers with credit at the lower rates available in the bond market.

There are plenty of examples of tricky, niche markets rewarding enterprising investors with excess returns, but it is often argued that this is a reward for risk, not brains. The idea that there is a market inefficiency big enough to stuff hundreds of billions of dollars into is not naturally appealing to me, but at this point I’m not sure if I buy the private credit story or not. I’d be very interested to hear from readers with experience in the industry, or investing in it.

Revolution as crypto use case

What is crypto good for? A question with many answers, most of them unsatisfactory. On Sunday a new one was added to the list. From Bloomberg:

“A parallel government led by the supporters of Myanmar’s ousted leader Aung San Suu Kyi recognised tether as an official currency for local use after the group began fundraising for a campaign that seeks to topple the military regime.

“The National Unity Government officially accepts tether, a cryptocurrency meant to be a dollar proxy, for ‘domestic use to make it easy and speed up the current trade, services and payment systems’, NUG finance minister Tin Tun Naing said Sunday in a Facebook post. No other details were given.”

Tether, you’ll recall, is a stablecoin, meaning it’s ostensibly pegged one-to-one to the dollar. Some people have raised doubts about tether’s peg, but it has held so far. And that makes it useful, potentially, if you are an anti-government rebel group without access to a formal financial system which is itself in disarray.

Crypto diehards have long boasted that bitcoin and its brethren are independent of established systems, which is hyperbole. Crypto depends, to various degrees, on centralised exchanges, fiat-currency convertibility, internet infrastructure and so on. But the Myanmar episode hints that crypto does have a degree of systemic independence. Tether, or another stablecoin, might be just independent enough to help a resistance movement defy a disorganised junta.

Eswar Prasad, a Cornell professor and author of a new book on digital currencies (disclosure: I was a researcher on the book project), told us he thinks a broader shift is under way:

“I suppose the key angle [on the Myanmar story] is easy access to a dollar-equivalent payment instrument that has the benefits of not being in physical form, not being traceable in principle, and allowing for transactions without physical proximity of transacting parties. All for a good cause for a change.

“This development is along the lines of one prediction I have in the book — that currencies of small countries and those with non-credible central banks or currencies will face existential threats from digital versions of major currencies and from stablecoins.”

That is to say: while crypto is no dollar disrupter, the right one might cause serious trouble for the Burmese kyat, especially if the currency is debased by the government. If a stablecoin is stable enough, easy to deal in and resistant to state blacklisting, it could start looking better than the piddling official currency. Emerging markets with fragile currencies should watch out. (Ethan Wu)

One good read

A terrific Bloomberg piece about the fundamentally deceptive nature of environmental, social and governance ratings from MSCI and others. The ESG-industrial complex is just awful.

FT Asset Management — The inside story on the movers and shakers behind a multitrillion-dollar industry. Sign up here

Free Lunch — Your guide to the global economic policy debate. Sign up here



Source link

86 Comments
  1. Xxpmbh says

    levaquin 250mg us purchase levaquin online

  2. Womayz says

    generic avodart 0.5mg order generic dutasteride buy ondansetron online cheap

  3. Ykkedc says

    order aldactone 25mg pill order aldactone 100mg sale buy fluconazole pills

  4. Wkdrul says

    ampicillin 500mg brand ampicillin 250mg canada erythromycin 250mg tablet

  5. Qzbhjg says

    buy fildena 50mg pills order bimatoprost pills robaxin 500mg ca

  6. Lbvley says

    buy sildenafil 50mg for sale sildenafil pills 25mg estradiol 2mg canada

  7. Kskrgf says

    buy lamotrigine 50mg pill prazosin 2mg brand tretinoin price

  8. Hjgmpg says

    purchase tadalafil without prescription cheap diclofenac 100mg order diclofenac 100mg for sale

  9. Ekctco says

    isotretinoin online order isotretinoin 40mg cheap zithromax for sale online

  10. Drwbgj says

    indocin 75mg for sale buy suprax 200mg order trimox 250mg online

  11. Zcrsrp says

    cialis 20mg brand cialis professional order viagra 50mg generic

  12. Vcdkuc says

    brand arimidex order anastrozole 1mg generic cheap sildenafil for sale

  13. Fcrabq says

    tadalafil 20mg generique cialis 5mg en ligne sildenafil 100mg generique

  14. Hzhjho says

    deltasone 40mg ca cialis 20 price viagra 50mg generic

  15. Yhodam says

    original tadalafil rezeptfrei sicher kaufen cialis 10mg generika rezeptfrei kaufen sildenafil 50mg ohne rezept

  16. Rlgnit says

    provigil 200mg generic acetazolamide usa oral diamox

  17. Qjmtgr says

    order doxycycline 100mg pills buy doxycycline 200mg online cheap buy lasix 100mg for sale

  18. Wcgyug says

    order ramipril 10mg generic temovate order online purchase azelastine sale

  19. Quhyds says

    cheap clonidine 0.1 mg catapres usa tiotropium bromide medication

  20. Atpxel says

    cost buspirone buy buspirone 5mg generic oxybutynin for sale online

  21. Zezdpl says

    hytrin 1mg without prescription order arava 20mg sale order generic sulfasalazine

  22. Igmfec says

    buy olmesartan pills oral olmesartan acetazolamide 250 mg tablet

  23. Sklvjd says

    prograf online urso 300mg ca urso 150mg uk

  24. Cohsun says

    imdur generic digoxin 250 mg oral order telmisartan 80mg pill

  25. Bnbkbj says

    order zyban sale purchase seroquel without prescription seroquel 50mg cost

  26. Bgbztb says

    molnunat 200 mg tablet buy naprosyn for sale buy lansoprazole 30mg without prescription

  27. Bxibxa says

    zoloft online buy order sertraline sildenafil medication

  28. Hhkrmm says

    buy imuran 100mcg sale cheap sildenafil pills sildenafil without prescription

  29. Grmyqt says

    buy cialis 20mg online Cialis buy overnight buy sildenafil online

  30. Uahaon says

    purchase tadalafil pills cialis 20mg price order amantadine 100 mg generic

  31. Czpsap says

    revia 50mg generic buy albenza without prescription abilify order online

  32. Wxygfu says

    brand dapsone order avlosulfon 100 mg pills order perindopril online

  33. Nnyneq says

    order provera 10mg order generic hydrochlorothiazide 25mg periactin 4mg drug

  34. Gyujxr says

    luvox 100mg generic order fluvoxamine 100mg pill glipizide 5mg ca

  35. Hczwql says

    accutane sale order amoxil 500mg pills prednisone oral

  36. Hfznqs says

    nootropil 800mg uk order viagra 50mg sildenafil 100mg drug

  37. Xncguz says

    order azithromycin sale order prednisolone 20mg pill order neurontin 800mg online cheap

  38. Oiarmc says

    overnight cialis delivery tadalafil 40mg tablet oral viagra 50mg

  39. Klputd says

    furosemide 40mg tablet lasix 40mg drug plaquenil 200mg pills

  40. Rsqsmn says

    aralen pills buy generic aralen generic olumiant

  41. Kkiink says

    itraconazole brand progesterone 200mg without prescription tinidazole 500mg brand

  42. Jmexiy says

    glucophage uk cost atorvastatin 20mg cialis 5mg us

  43. Kgoepg says

    olanzapine 10mg cheap purchase zyprexa without prescription valsartan 80mg oral

  44. Seiesy says

    norvasc generic buy tadalafil 40mg online cheap tadalafil 20mg us

  45. Scwafn says

    order clozaril pills buy combivent for sale purchase dexamethasone generic

  46. Jzqced says

    buy sildenafil 50mg for sale sildenafil 50mg brand lisinopril 5mg cheap

  47. Pqyskf says

    linezolid for sale online linezolid order online playing poker online

  48. Vcqahl says

    omeprazole 20mg for sale casino free spin play casino online

  49. Adbcsa says

    brand lopressor 100mg levitra 20mg oral vardenafil price

  50. Dooeya says

    academic writing blog betfair casino online online casino real money no deposit

  51. Nvkonc says

    order vardenafil 10mg pills medrol 16mg over the counter methylprednisolone us

  52. Ksegce says

    writing assignments cheap thesis binding sildenafil overnight shipping

  53. Dcazao says

    clomiphene for sale online generic clomiphene 50mg poker online free

  54. Omausg says

    order cialis pill buy cialis 5mg generic viagra pills

  55. Snlrft says

    order aristocort generic order claritin pills oral clarinex 5mg

  56. Cnxzfp says

    order dapoxetine 30mg online cheap synthroid 75mcg generic synthroid generic

  57. Lirnvw says

    order xenical 120mg generic order generic diltiazem 180mg buy zovirax 800mg generic

  58. Pdyzzg says

    order allopurinol 100mg generic zyloprim 300mg drug zetia online

  59. Bvymaj says

    methotrexate 10mg us oral methotrexate 5mg metoclopramide generic

  60. Ormtqb says

    cozaar 25mg usa cozaar 50mg price generic topiramate 200mg

  61. Skmitq says

    order lioresal generic toradol tablet oral toradol 10mg

  62. Zmjmmv says

    imitrex online buy levofloxacin 250mg oral avodart 0.5mg without prescription

  63. Eohtxb says

    order colchicine without prescription colchicine generic play poker online free no sign up

  64. Wtbrjb says

    purchase zantac without prescription cheap meloxicam 15mg buy celebrex 200mg pill

  65. Yjrigh says

    real casino slots casino online usa us blackjack online

  66. Axtujr says

    cialis australia ampicillin 500mg pills buy ciprofloxacin online cheap

  67. Wblspx says

    cheap metronidazole 200mg bactrim 480mg pill purchase bactrim generic

  68. Agbsvx says

    fluconazole 200mg for sale brand fluconazole 100mg cheap sildenafil 50mg

  69. Yerxdn says

    keflex 125mg brand erythromycin 500mg uk buy erythromycin 500mg pill

  70. Jwflcq says

    buy tadalafil 5mg for sale order viagra 100mg online generic viagra

  71. Wdirmf says

    cheap viagra generic cialis 20mg tablet cialis sale

  72. Xmmhiv says

    order ceftin pill ceftin 500mg price cheap methocarbamol

  73. Uhxzna says

    online casino slots no download poker online free buy tadalafil 10mg for sale

  74. Ktwvjc says

    desyrel uk buy sildenafil 50mg sale buy aurogra 100mg

  75. Lcmnkp says

    professional research paper writers help with my assignment ivermectin 1 topical cream

  76. Qhpxmm says

    sildenafil 200mg for sale order lamotrigine cheap lamotrigine 200mg

  77. Jloqkr says

    deltasone brand order deltasone 10mg sale amoxil cost

  78. Lzvcuv says

    purchase viagra without prescription buy sildenafil online cialis mail order usa

  79. Xtkspq says

    casino world erection pills cialis pill

  80. Eprosq says

    buy zithromax 500mg online cheap order azithromycin for sale order gabapentin 100mg for sale

  81. Tistxx says

    online roulette wheel order stromectol pills buy generic provigil

  82. Annahe says

    lasix 40mg generic oral doxycycline 100mg order hydroxychloroquine generic

  83. Ivedul says

    order fildena online cheap fildena 100mg ca rhinocort price

  84. Gcbhzf says

    prednisone 10mg drug order mebendazole 100mg generic vermox cheap

  85. Rsblgq says

    order tretinoin cream online cheap order tadalis 10mg online generic avana 200mg

  86. Kqujas says

    buy tadalafil 10mg pills buy diclofenac 100mg for sale indomethacin 50mg us

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.