This article is an on-site version of our Moral Money newsletter. Sign up here to get the newsletter sent straight to your inbox.
Visit our Moral Money hub for all the latest ESG news, opinion and analysis from around the FT
Microsoft is among the biggest fish in the environmental, social and governance (ESG) pond. The tech giant is the most widely held company among US ESG funds. And, as the second-best performer among Dow 30 companies this year, Microsoft has helped fuel ESG performance in 2021 and 2020.
But Microsoft’s lofty ESG reputation took a hit on Tuesday. At its annual meeting, a majority of shareholders defied Microsoft’s management and voted for a proposal calling on the company to reveal more about its handling of sexual harassment claims. This was the first time since at least 2000 that Microsoft has lost a vote on a shareholder proposal, according to ISS Corporate Solutions.
Microsoft revealed earlier this year that its board had hired an external company to look into a decades-old “intimate relationship” that co-founder Bill Gates had with an employee. Gates stepped down from the board before an investigation was completed, and the outcome of any inquiry has not been revealed.
If it were not readily apparent by now, the Microsoft vote underscores that the world’s giant investors are downright paranoid about what social risks might be lurking beneath the surface at well-performing companies.
Readers aspiring to higher standards in business may want to tune in to our full-day Investing for Good USA online event on Thursday. It features star guests ranging from Al Gore to Andre Agassi, in conversation with Moral Money writers and other FT journalists. If you’re a premium subscriber, you can get access for free through this link. — Patrick Temple-West
Does the world need a ‘Spotify of ESG?’
As interest in sustainable finance has exploded, so too have the number of data services from companies promising to help investors sort the green from the greenwash.
Today brings yet another product in this increasingly crowded space, one with a cute tagline: ESG Book from asset manager Arabesque is “the Spotify of ESG”, according to the company’s sustainability ratings head Daniel Klier.
The new product — launched in partnership with the International Finance Corporation, among others — offers scores on the environmental, social and governance performance of more than 9,000 companies. Basic access to the online database is free, in contrast with most similar offerings, but Arabesque will charge for additional analytics and other premium services.
The more high-quality data that is made available to investors, Klier said, the better the world’s chances of tackling the climate crisis in earnest. “Every industrial revolution, in my mind, needs fundamental reallocation of capital,” he said, adding that “financial markets are normally quite intelligent to reallocate capital if you give them good information”.
Yet that proposition is under increasingly heavy scrutiny from critics who warn that the mere proffering of data to investors will be far from enough to drive economic change at the scale required. Nadia Ameli, an academic at University College London, is among them.
The dramatic increase in ESG disclosures “is a solution proposed by the financial community, and it may protect the financial system from climate risks and instability”, Ameli told me. “But that doesn’t mean that this is going to support the low carbon transition.”
In a recent paper on this subject in Nature Climate Change, Ameli and two fellow UCL academics argue that while the rise of ESG ratings and disclosures might cause many investors to sell out of fossil fuel-related companies, “the tangible financial impact on fossil fuel finance and emissions reduction remains irrelevant”.
Meanwhile, they warn, there is no evidence that the transparency drive is doing much to redirect capital towards companies working to tackle the climate crisis.
The focus on transparency, they write, risks distracting from other policy areas that could prove vital — from new green factors in bank capital reserve requirements, to a serious integration of climate priorities into monetary policy.
Is Ameli correct to worry about an excessive focus on the power of disclosure? Or is Klier right to talk up the climate impact of market investors armed with better information? Let us know your thoughts at moralmoneyreply@ft.com. (Simon Mundy)
London Stock Exchange welcomes first B Corp
Over the past 14 years, the non-profit B Lab has awarded B Corp certificates to 4,000 companies that meet its exceptionally high standards of social and environmental performance. But only 29 of those companies are publicly listed, reflecting the tension between the demands of shareholders and those of B Lab.
And today, tech consultancy Kin + Carta will become the UK’s first listed B Corp as it joins the less than 1 per cent of B Corp certified businesses that are publicly traded.
“[B Corp] commitments have accelerated our performance,” J Schwan, chief executive at Kin + Carta, told Moral Money.
Schwan said the company’s performance, in terms of investor relations and employee recruitment, has improved since the shareholder vote to approve the B Corp status in September.
To secure B Corp certification, companies must submit to a months-long evaluation process, aimed at identifying companies with best-in-class standards of positive impact, public transparency and “legal accountability to balance profit and purpose”.
Some executives seeking to embrace the B Corp philosophy have run into trouble with investors. Emmanuel Faber was ousted this year as chief executive of Danone, the French food company that is B Corp certified in North America, amid shareholder unrest over a sustainability drive.
But momentum continues, with the number of certified B Corps steadily ticking up. In continental Europe, even the luxury fashion business is starting to show interest. Prada chief executive Patrizio Bertelli is planning to let his son, Lorenzo, take over the business sooner than expected. When the younger Bertelli set out his long-term strategy for the company, he unveiled the goal of achieving B Corp status.
Lorenzo, 33, may see B Corp certification as a way to keep luxury in the minds, and hands, of younger, sustainability driven consumers. If Prada, which is based in Italy but listed in Hong Kong, does receive B Corp certification, it would be the first Italian luxury brand — and only the second luxury brand in the world to do so. France’s Chloé was certified in October.
As more listed companies pursue B Corp status, they’ll need to carefully weigh the focus on “profit with purpose”. While the certification could provide a reputational boost among increasingly watchful consumers, it may spook some shareholders. (Kristen Talman)
Tips from Tamami
Nikkei’s Tamami Shimizuishi helps you stay up to date on stories you may have missed from the eastern hemisphere.
While India and China attracted many headlines during COP26, other big emitters, such as Iran, largely escaped the spotlight.
As the world’s eighth largest emitter, Iran is one of the few countries in the world that has yet to ratify the Paris Agreement — but the country did send a delegation to Glasgow.
At the summit, Iran backed India’s effort to “water down” an agreement to phase out coal and fossil fuel subsidies. Less global fossil fuel consumption means less oil and gas income, the backbone of the country’s economy, said Kaveh Madani, research professor at the City College of New York.
Iran also tried to use the climate meetings as an opportunity to call for lifting sanctions, arguing that the penalties restrict its ability to fight climate change. Ali Salajegheh, head of Iran’s Department of Environment, told the BBC that Iran would ratify the Paris Agreement if all sanctions were lifted.
Madani, who led the country’s delegation at COP23 in 2017, said he was surprised to hear such “a strong verbal commitment” from Salajegheh. But Madani pointed out that such a decision could not be made alone in Iran. Ratification would have to pass through a rightwing parliament that was generally suspicious of international agreements.
There was rising hope, however, that Iran would eventually ratify the agreement as nuclear talks with the US and its allies resumed earlier this week.
“A successful outcome of the negotiations would likely have some impact on climate policy,” said Mia Moisio, an analyst NewClimate Institute, a German think-tank.
Chart of the day

To encourage companies to reduce carbon emissions, most investment managers and asset owners prefer to use their influence rather than divest, but post-COP26 data show the tides are shifting, according to a new report from global investment manager Ninety One.
Ahead of the UN climate conference, 55 per cent of investors preferred to use influence over divestment. That figure is now down to 45 per cent, according to the report. The number of companies that would choose to divest has also increased — up 6 percentage points, from 30 per cent ahead of the Glasgow summit.
Smart Watch
-
At today’s Global Banking Summit, Moral Money’s Gillian Tett asked executives from Citi, Standard Chartered, Deutsche Bank and McKinsey how they are setting targets to eliminate carbon emissions from their portfolios. While McKinsey’s Daniel Mikkelsen likened the situation to “flying a plane while trying to build it”, banks are making progress on releasing disclosure guidelines. Tune in to hear how banks are setting goals leading up to 2050, and the growing debate around absolute emissions vs carbon intensity.
purchase levaquin pills buy levaquin 250mg online
avodart without prescription tamsulosin 0.2mg generic zofran sale
order aldactone 25mg without prescription buy propecia sale diflucan for sale
buy acillin sale buy cephalexin 125mg pill erythromycin online order
buy fildena buy careprost pills methocarbamol 500mg usa
purchase suhagra order generic aurogra 50mg purchase estrace sale
lamictal oral mebendazole 100mg cheap buy tretinoin gel for sale
tadalafil 20mg without prescription brand avana diclofenac cheap
order accutane 40mg online order isotretinoin 20mg online zithromax 250mg tablet
order indocin without prescription terbinafine 250mg over the counter order amoxicillin
order tadalafil 20mg pill Order viagra buy sildenafil 50mg for sale
buy anastrozole without prescription Pfizer viagra canada viagra usa
prednisone 10mg generic viagra order viagra next day delivery usa
provigil brand acetazolamide 250mg uk diamox buy online
buy doxycycline 200mg pills purchase clomiphene sale lasix us
buy ramipril 5mg sale buy avapro sale buy astelin sprayers
cost catapres 0.1 mg meclizine cheap spiriva pills
buspirone 10mg pill ditropan 2.5mg drug order ditropan pills
order hytrin generic buy leflunomide online buy sulfasalazine 500 mg online cheap
fosamax over the counter ibuprofen 400mg drug famotidine online
cost benicar 10mg buy depakote online diamox 250mg brand
buy tacrolimus pill order urso 150mg generic generic urso 150mg
imdur 20mg over the counter buy imuran sale purchase telmisartan generic
zyban 150 mg pills atomoxetine canada cheap seroquel 100mg
molnupiravir 200 mg generic buy molnupiravir generic lansoprazole 30mg us
order zoloft 100mg purchase kamagra generic viagra 50mg tablet
imuran 100mcg cost free shipping viagra sildenafil uk
buy tadalafil 10mg pill tadalafil 20mg oral buy viagra 50mg for sale
cialis mail order usa order pyridium 200 mg sale amantadine 100 mg over the counter
buy revia 50 mg for sale buy abilify pill cheap aripiprazole
dapsone 100 mg ca purchase dapsone generic aceon us
order provera 5mg for sale order praziquantel 600mg online cheap periactin canada
provigil online order modafinil sale cost of ivermectin 1% cream
fluvoxamine online buy glucotrol 5mg over the counter glucotrol for sale online
isotretinoin without prescription buy accutane 10mg sale cost prednisone 10mg
nootropil cost real viagra pharmacy prescription sildenafil pill
buy generic zithromax buy azithromycin 500mg online cheap order gabapentin 600mg generic
purchase tadalafil pill buying cialis cheap sildenafil 100mg england
furosemide online buy lasix 100mg without prescription order hydroxychloroquine 400mg generic
buy tadalafil 20mg online cheap clomipramine pills clomipramine cheap
chloroquine cost order cenforce 50mg pills order baricitinib pill
sporanox 100mg for sale buy generic prometrium purchase tinidazole sale
order glycomet for sale order tadalafil 40mg without prescription order tadalafil 10mg online cheap
olanzapine 10mg sale zyprexa order valsartan 80mg generic
cheap norvasc purchase norvasc sale order cialis 40mg generic
order clozaril 50mg sale ipratropium 100 mcg pill cost dexamethasone 0,5 mg
viagra 50mg cheap viagra pharmacy buy lisinopril 5mg generic
zyvox 600mg sale casino card games poker game
cheap prilosec 10mg professional letter writing services casino games online real money
brand levitra 10mg vardenafil 10mg without prescription medrol 16mg over counter
academicwriters cheap viagra for sale viagra overnight shipping usa
clomid 100mg sale buy clomid 100mg without prescription free online roulette
tadalafil tablet purchase cialis online cheap purchase viagra without prescription
triamcinolone online order desloratadine 5mg for sale buy clarinex
dapoxetine 30mg us brand synthroid 100mcg purchase levothyroxine pills
buy cialis 40mg online cheap order viagra pill viagra 50mg ca
cheap orlistat diltiazem 180mg without prescription acyclovir 800mg pills
tadalafil pills inderal generic order plavix pills
zyloprim 300mg us allopurinol for sale online purchase ezetimibe pills
methotrexate 5mg tablet buy warfarin generic order reglan 10mg generic
buy motilium 10mg pills motilium 10mg usa buy flexeril 15mg online cheap
purchase cozaar pills order topamax 100mg for sale topamax price
lioresal buy online buy baclofen online cheap buy ketorolac generic
sumatriptan canada buy sumatriptan 50mg without prescription order avodart 0.5mg sale
buy colchicine pill black jack card game free slots online
zantac 150mg price order meloxicam 7.5mg without prescription brand celecoxib 200mg
crazy poker games real casino slots online slot machine games
Hello bro!Click here!..
flomax 0.2mg drug order spironolactone 100mg sale order aldactone 100mg for sale
canadian cialis and healthcare cialis coupon cvs order cipro 500mg sale
order zocor 10mg generic order generic valacyclovir buy generic finasteride 1mg
flagyl 400mg price order bactrim buy sulfamethoxazole generic
fluconazole cost diflucan us sildenafil 50mg sale
buy tadalafil 20mg sale tadalafil 40mg tablet order sildenafil 50mg without prescription
sildenafil 50mg ca cheap viagra sale discount cialis
buy ceftin 500mg pill buy bimatoprost generic robaxin pills
real money spins online tadalafil 40mg pills cialis india