The writer is a professor at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business
Under the benign gaze of the Draghi government, the US private equity group KKR is bidding for Telecom Italia, one of the last large firms in Italian hands. Italy, the eighth largest economy in the world, has only six companies in the Fortune Global 500, three of which are controlled by the state. This compares with seven for Spain, whose economy is ranked 14th in the world by gross domestic product, and 26 for France, which is seventh.
Some blame successive Italian governments for not resisting foreign acquisitions. They point to outgoing German chancellor Angela Merkel blocking Fiat from buying Opel in 2009 and French president Emmanuel Macron delaying Fincantieri’s acquisition of STX in 2017.
Others regard this latest bid as a sign of the ultimate triumph of the European single market. But I see a failure of the Italian economy to move into the 21st century.
The problem is not that foreign companies acquire Italian ones. It is that Italy’s entrepreneurs seem incapable of building companies that are able to compete in the global economy.
Why is this? First, Italian entrepreneurs are obsessed with control. In order to retain majority control of the companies they found, they build fragile pyramid structures, burden them with debt and ultimately do not expand much beyond Italy’s borders, since doing so would require using equity to pay for acquisitions.
This obsession with control is not just a psychological matter. In Italy corporate control is highly valuable, because whoever has it can easily take advantage of minority shareholders without fear of legal retribution. Anticipating this risk, savers are reluctant to invest in the equity market and finance the expansion of Italian firms.
The second reason for underperformance is the parasitic relationship between domestic big business and the Italian state. For decades, Fiat was heavily protected from Japanese competition, while in the 1990s Olivetti was granted the second mobile phone licence by a sympathetic government.
This parasitic relationship reached its peak when Silvio Berlusconi was in power, first in the mid-1990s and then again in the early 2000s. The country’s telecommunications strategy was subordinated to the private interests of the billionaire prime minister. Used to making quick profits at home thanks to their political connections, Italian companies were unwilling to take the risks needed to succeed in the global marketplace.
A belief that “small is beautiful” also helped to prevent Italian firms from achieving the economies of scale necessary for global success. Italy invented the pizza, for example, but still does not have a large pizza chain. The concept of the coffee bar is Italian in origin, but the country is not home to a significant coffee chain. The country is one of the world’s biggest tourist destinations, but it does not boast a large chain of hotels. And while Italy is one of the global capitals of fashion, the biggest Italian-owned fashion company is ranked only 17th in the world by market value.
Finally, consider the failure to create world-class universities. The success of Montecatini and Olivetti in the 1960s was driven by technology developed in Italian universities. But who remembers the last Italian firm to have prospered on the back of technology developed by researchers at home? In the 2021 Shanghai ranking of world universities, there is no Italian institution in the top 150.
Many of these problems have been decades in the making. Yet efforts to address them have been limited. Reforms to speed up civil trials are welcome, but have the unfortunate defect of shortening the statute of limitation for criminal offences, helping corrupt entrepreneurs to escape punishment for their crimes.
Moreover, not only does the flood of money provided by the Next Generation EU recovery programme foster the parasitic relationship between business and government, the way that cash is disbursed entrenches the cycle of dependence. Some €11bn is earmarked for the promotion of university research, yet that is well under 1 per cent of GDP and does not even cover the annual gap in R&D between Italy and the rest of Europe. No serious attempt is being made, as far as I can see, to help Italian companies develop the economies of scale to compete in the global marketplace.
To win the challenge of global competition in the 21st century, Italy must not stand in the way of the process of creative destruction. It should instead foster the development of new giants capable of taking on the world. If the Next Generation EU recovery funds are not used to aid this process, a huge opportunity for the Italian economy will have been missed.
purchase levofloxacin for sale levofloxacin pills
purchase dutasteride online cheap cost zofran 4mg zofran 4mg over the counter
aldactone 100mg for sale valtrex uk purchase fluconazole generic
ampicillin 500mg canada order ampicillin 500mg online cheap erythromycin uk
fildena pills order bimatoprost without prescription buy methocarbamol 500mg online cheap
suhagra for sale online sildenafil canada cost estrace 1mg
lamictal 200mg us order lamictal 50mg pill buy tretinoin gel generic
tadalis 10mg cost cost diclofenac 100mg cheap diclofenac 100mg
order accutane online buy zithromax 250mg online order azithromycin
oral indomethacin buy trimox 500mg generic amoxicillin online
order tadalafil 10mg pill Real viagra online viagra on line
buy anastrozole 1 mg without prescription anastrozole pill viagra 100mg pills
tadalafil 20mg gГ©nГ©rique sildenafil 50mg sans ordonnance en pharmacie viagra sans ordonnance en france
oral deltasone 5mg order prednisone 20mg online order viagra 100mg online cheap
tadalafil 20mg kaufen ohne rezept cialis 5mg kaufen ohne rezept original sildenafil 50mg rezeptfrei sicher kaufen
order accutane 40mg online isotretinoin 40mg generic ivermectin 6
generic doxycycline 100mg clomid over the counter order furosemide 100mg pill
purchase altace generic avapro 150mg generic purchase astelin online
order catapres without prescription buy spiriva pill buy spiriva 9 mcg for sale
buspirone 10mg for sale order dilantin pill order oxybutynin 2.5mg for sale
order hytrin 1mg online leflunomide without prescription azulfidine 500mg generic
buy fosamax 70mg online cheap motrin 400mg cost pepcid pills
olmesartan cheap divalproex 250mg sale order acetazolamide 250 mg generic
isosorbide 40mg for sale purchase azathioprine for sale order micardis 20mg generic
generic zyban 150mg quetiapine us buy generic seroquel 100mg
purchase molnupiravir online purchase naproxen for sale cost prevacid 30mg
order zoloft 100mg online cheap order escitalopram 20mg sale order viagra 50mg without prescription
buy salbutamol online sildenafil 50mg canada buy viagra
tadalafil 20mg canada buy phenazopyridine 200 mg for sale symmetrel 100 mg canada
order naltrexone order abilify generic purchase aripiprazole pill
medroxyprogesterone buy online praziquantel order online cyproheptadine online
buy modafinil 100mg online pharmacy store where to buy ivermectin pills
buy fluvoxamine 100mg generic ketoconazole canada buy glucotrol 5mg online cheap
isotretinoin 10mg drug buy amoxicillin 500mg without prescription deltasone 40mg us
order nootropil 800 mg pill buy piracetam 800mg sale buy viagra 100mg
buy zithromax online cheap prednisolone 10mg for sale neurontin 100mg over the counter
buy tadalafil 20mg online buy generic tadalafil sildenafil online
purchase lasix pills doxycycline 100mg sale plaquenil order online
cialis 40mg pill clomipramine 25mg generic anafranil us
buy chloroquine pill chloroquine drug order olumiant without prescription
buy itraconazole 100 mg pills tindamax 500mg canada tinidazole without prescription
order glycomet glycomet 1000mg uk cialis 5 mg
zyprexa 10mg pill nebivolol usa valsartan over the counter
order norvasc 5mg generic order cialis for sale otc cialis
order clozapine sale ipratropium 100 mcg brand decadron generic
sildenafil 100mg pills for men real viagra 100mg lisinopril cheap
omeprazole 20mg drug blackjack games bonus poker online
linezolid 600mg cheap best no deposit free spins best online gambling sites
lopressor 50mg ca tenormin price buy levitra 10mg
need help writing a paper online slots real money usa free online blackjack no download
buy levitra 20mg without prescription lyrica 150mg canada methylprednisolone 4 mg without prescription
thesis writers cheap research paper writers sildenafil 100mg usa
buy clomid 100mg generic albuterol canada play online blackjack for real money
tadalafil 20mg usa buy cialis 20mg pill sildenafil on line
triamcinolone 10mg ca buy loratadine generic order desloratadine for sale
buy priligy 90mg online synthroid 100mcg tablet order levothyroxine online
cialis without a doctor prescription viagra 100mg pills for men sildenafil 100mg tablet
order xenical 120mg for sale diltiazem 180mg canada generic acyclovir 400mg
tadalafil brand name oral inderal oral clopidogrel 150mg
buy methotrexate 10mg generic warfarin 2mg without prescription buy reglan 20mg pill
order domperidone generic purchase cyclobenzaprine online cost cyclobenzaprine 15mg
order cozaar 25mg generic topamax online buy topamax pills
ozobax canada order generic ozobax order toradol 10mg sale
sumatriptan pills imitrex buy online buy avodart 0.5mg online
buy colchicine pills real money spins legitimate online slots for money
ranitidine 300mg usa order celebrex 200mg online cheap purchase celebrex pills
hollywood casino online real money free poker online games free online blackjack
buy flomax 0.2mg pill flomax 0.4mg for sale order spironolactone 25mg pills
cialis 5mg cost tadalafil 5mg generic cipro 1000mg sale
simvastatin us order finasteride 5mg propecia medication
buy flagyl 400mg generic buy bactrim 480mg for sale buy bactrim 960mg for sale
buy generic keflex cleocin order buy erythromycin 500mg without prescription
brand sildenafil real cialis sites cialis 20mg pills
ceftin 500mg for sale purchase robaxin without prescription cost methocarbamol 500mg
red dog casino poker online for real money cialis 5mg usa
order trazodone 100mg online cheap order generic sildenafil buy sildenafil without prescription
academic writers online edit letter stromectol pills canada
order generic deltasone 5mg order amoxicillin 250mg online order amoxicillin 1000mg
best online casino for real money cheap ed drugs buy cialis 10mg without prescription
buy zithromax azithromycin 250mg canada neurontin 100mg usa
buy furosemide buy hydroxychloroquine pill purchase hydroxychloroquine without prescription
deltasone 20mg sale deltasone 5mg cheap vermox order online
buy sildenafil 50mg sale budesonide over the counter buy rhinocort online
tretinoin us order avana online cheap purchase avana for sale
tadacip for sale online diclofenac 50mg for sale order indocin generic
biaxin 250mg cheap buy biaxin pills buy antivert sale