How to Know If Your Leadership Style Is More Elon Musk or Steve Jobs

• Christopher Myers is a professor of entrepreneurship and management at W. P. Carey School of Business at Arizona State University.
• He writes that Steve Jobs and Elon Musk represent the quintessential hedgehog and fox, respectively.
• Myers says the most optimal leaders strike a balance between the approaches. 

Isaiah Berlin, a prominent 20th-century philosopher and historian, popularized the foxes and hedgehogs metaphor in his 1953 essay “The Hedgehog and the Fox.” This metaphor, rooted in ancient Greek poet Archilochus’s fragment, “The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing,” categorizes thinkers and leaders into two distinct groups: foxes and hedgehogs.

Foxes possess a versatile set of strategies, adapting to various situations with ease. Hedgehogs, conversely, focus on a singular, overarching vision that drives their decision-making process.

By understanding this metaphor, modern business leaders can harness the strengths of both foxes and hedgehogs to navigate an increasingly complex and rapidly changing world.

The foxes and hedgehogs metaphor explained

Berlin’s metaphor offers a unique perspective on leadership styles, providing valuable insights into how different leaders approach decision-making, problem-solving and strategic planning.

Foxes are characterized by their ability to pursue multiple objectives simultaneously, adapting their strategies as circumstances change. They are pragmatic, flexible and responsive to new information, enabling them to thrive in complex and uncertain environments.

In contrast, hedgehogs are singularly focused on a central idea or vision that guides all their actions. This unwavering commitment to their core belief can result in remarkable achievements but can also lead to spectacular failures if they are unwilling or unable to adapt when circumstances change. Hedgehogs are often characterized by their tenacity, determination and uncompromising dedication to their vision.

Leadership lessons from history: Xerxes and Themistocles

Examining historical figures through the lens of the foxes and hedgehogs metaphor can provide valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of different leadership styles.

Two such figures are Xerxes, the King of Persia, and Themistocles, the Athenian general.

Xerxes exemplifies a hedgehog leader. With a singular goal of conquering Greece, Xerxes amassed a vast army and embarked on an ambitious campaign. However, his single-minded focus on conquest and inability to adapt to changing circumstances led to the disastrous Battle of Thermopylae. The small Greek force led by King Leonidas held off the Persian army for several days, ultimately exposing the limitations of Xerxes’s strategy. Inflexibility and overreliance on numerical superiority contributed to the failure of his invasion.

In contrast, Themistocles embodies the adaptable fox. Recognizing the importance of naval power, Themistocles guided the Greeks to victory in the Battle of Salamis, where the Persian fleet was defeated. Themistocles’s ability to adapt to changing circumstances and his diverse range of tactics highlight the characteristics of a fox. His strategic acumen played a crucial role in defending Greece against the Persian invasion, demonstrating the benefits of adaptability and diverse tactics in achieving success.

Modern business titans: Steve Jobs and Elon Musk

In the world of technology and entrepreneurship, Steve Jobs and Elon Musk represent the quintessential hedgehog and fox, respectively.

Jobs, driven by an unwavering commitment to innovation, revolutionized the tech industry with groundbreaking products like the iPhone and iPad. His passion for design and perfectionism played a significant role in shaping Apple’s distinctive brand identity and the company’s extraordinary success. However, his stubbornness and insistence on pursuing his vision led to conflicts and setbacks, including his temporary departure from Apple in 1985. Despite these challenges, Jobs returned to Apple and led the company to even greater heights, showcasing the power of a hedgehog’s conviction and focus.

Conversely, Musk demonstrates the fox’s adaptability and versatility, pursuing various ventures from electric vehicles to reusable rockets, and from solar energy to neural interfaces. Although he certainly has goals, such as making life multi-planetary and reducing humanity’s dependence on fossil fuels, his ability to pivot strategies, learn from failures and embrace diverse approaches contributes to his continued success. As the CEO of SpaceX and Tesla, Musk exemplifies the fox’s ability to navigate the complexities of multiple industries simultaneously.

Implementing the foxes and hedgehogs framework for modern leaders

By embracing the foxes and hedgehogs framework, modern leaders can strike a balance between adaptability and conviction. Here are five actionable insights for incorporating this metaphor into leadership styles:

• Embrace adaptability: In today’s fast-paced business landscape, change is inevitable. By remaining open to new ideas and embracing change, leaders can foster agility and responsiveness within their organizations. This adaptability enables organizations to capitalize on emerging opportunities and respond effectively to unforeseen challenges.
• Craft a compelling vision: A clear and captivating vision can guide leaders through uncertainty and change. By establishing an overarching goal, leaders can maintain focus and drive their organizations toward success. This vision serves as a north star, helping leaders and their teams to navigate the complexities of the modern business environment.
• Cultivate a diverse skill set: By developing a broad range of skills and experiences, leaders can ensure they possess a versatile toolkit for tackling new challenges. This diversity enables leaders to draw from a wealth of knowledge and expertise, empowering them to make well-informed decisions and implement effective strategies.
• Acknowledge the limits of conviction: Overcommitting to a single strategy can lead to catastrophic failures. Leaders should remain aware of potential pitfalls and remain prepared to pivot when necessary. By recognizing the limits of conviction and embracing flexibility, leaders can minimize the risk of failure and maximize the potential for success.
• Foster a learning culture: Encouraging continuous learning and growth within organizations can lead to ongoing evolution and improvement. By fostering a culture of curiosity, experimentation and learning from both successes and failures, leaders can ensure that their organizations remain at the forefront of innovation and progress.

Striking a balance for optimal leadership

Although the foxes and hedgehogs metaphor provides valuable insights into the characteristics of different leadership styles, leaders must recognize that adopting a purely fox-like or hedgehog-like approach may not be the most effective strategy.

Instead, striking a balance between the strengths of both foxes and hedgehogs can empower leaders to navigate the complexities of the modern business world with confidence and skill.

By embracing adaptability and cultivating a diverse skill set, leaders can effectively respond to new challenges and capitalize on emerging opportunities. At the same time, maintaining a clear and compelling vision can provide a guiding framework for decision-making, ensuring that leaders remain focused on their organization’s long-term success.

Isaiah Berlin’s foxes and hedgehogs metaphor provides modern business leaders with a valuable framework for understanding and implementing effective leadership styles. By harnessing the strengths of both foxes and hedgehogs, leaders can effectively navigate today’s complex business environment.

Ultimately, embracing adaptability, crafting a compelling vision and fostering a culture of continuous learning will drive organizations to new heights of success. By applying the lessons gleaned from historical figures like Xerxes and Themistocles, as well as modern business titans like Steve Jobs and Elon Musk, leaders can develop a balanced approach to leadership that maximizes their potential for lasting impact and achievement.