Do annuity ladders make sense for retirees?
getty
Annuity laddering involves staggering the purchase of annuities over a period of time. A laddered annuity differs from a deferred annuity, which involves a single purchase but with payments deferred for some period selected by the purchaser. Both the laddered and deferred annuities considered here have fixed payments – variable annuities are a completely different ballgame.
The logic of laddering is that annuity payment amounts rise with age, and they also rise with interest rates. Indeed, the recent flurry of interest in laddering arises from the widespread belief that interest rates will rise this year.
However, the logic of laddering is far from conclusive.
- Seldom is laddering compared to the most plausible alternative, which is to place part of the designated assets into a deferred annuity.
- Laddering proponents ignore the question of what is done with the earnings on assets that are retained for future annuity purchases. The earnings could be accumulated so as to enhance the future annuity amounts, they could be used as spendable funds, or some combination of the two.
- Also ignored are the consequences if interest rates don’t rise as expected.
These issues are confronted in this article, which employs models developed by my colleague Allan Redstone. The models are used here to show how the spendable funds available to a 65-year-old man with financial assets of $600,000 is impacted by laddering with an annuity purchased now, another one purchased after 3 years, and a third one purchased after 6 years. The ladder is compared to a single deferred annuity purchased now on which the deferment period is 10 years.
Chart 1 compares the ladder with the deferred annuity in today’s market. The rate of return on the financial assets used to purchase both annuities is assumed to be 6.1%, which is the historical median on a 25%-stock/75% fixed income portfolio over 925 past 10-year periods. The current rate of return on the annuity is assumed to be 1.5% percent, about the same as 6/7-year Treasuries, based on an annuity pricing model developed by my colleague Allan Redstone, which has been checked against current annuity prices. All annuities are priced with a COLA increase of 2% a year but no cash refund rider.
As shown in Chart 1, the ladder provides significantly lower spendable funds than the single deferred payment alternative during the first 6 years, or until the last rung of the ladder kicks in. This assumes that the earnings on the assets remaining are accumulated and used for larger annuity purchases. If the assets on the ladder are instead withdrawn as spendable funds, the shortfall during the first three years is eliminated but during the remainder of the retiree’s life, the single deferred payment alternative generates more.
Annuity ladder vs deferred annuity in a stable rate environment
www.rfiretirementplan.com
Bottom line, in a stable rate environment the 3-year/6-year ladder is inferior to a single annuity with payment deferred 10 years. That leaves the question of how rising interest rates shift the balance. I ran a number of rate increase scenarios and selected a rate increase of 3% spread out over 18 months to compare the ladder with the reference.
Rising interest rates affect both the reference case and the ladder. With the reference case, I assume that the asset earnings in excess of the amounts required to finance spendable funds during the first 10 years are used to buy an immediate annuity which results in a jump in spendable funds at the end of the deferment period. With the ladder, in contrast, it is critically important whether the asset earnings during the early years are retained to make future annuity purchases larger or drawn out as spendable funds.
If the asset earnings are retained, the future payments would be substantially higher than the reference after the last annuity is purchased but substantially lower before then. If the asset earnings are paid out, payments in the first 10 years would be higher than the reference, and slightly lower thereafter. These points are illustrated by Chart 2.
Annuity ladder vs deferred annuity in a rising rate environment
www.rfiretirementplan.com
In sum, with stable interest rates, annuity laddering is a loser relative to an immediate annuity with payment deferred 10 years. If rates rise after annuities are purchased, the comparison is muddled by whether or not purchasers using ladders draw down excess earnings, but overall laddering is not a better option.
I view this article as the first step in the process of integrating ladders into retirement plans. Stay tuned.
biaxin tablets
buying cialis generic You might even decide to go with the best brand if that is the better Cialis available
I ve heard from a couple of them stromectol coupon
order generic levaquin 250mg buy levaquin 250mg online cheap
purchase avodart pill cost avodart zofran cheap
aldactone oral order spironolactone 25mg for sale fluconazole oral
ampicillin cheap brand ampicillin 500mg erythromycin 250mg pills
sildenafil 100mg over the counter tamoxifen over the counter robaxin 500mg uk
order suhagra 50mg online cheap buy sildenafil pill estradiol 2mg without prescription
buy lamictal 200mg sale minipress over the counter buy tretinoin cream for sale
tadalafil 10mg canada order avanafil 100mg generic order diclofenac 50mg sale
buy accutane 10mg generic isotretinoin 10mg ca cheap zithromax 250mg
order indocin 75mg purchase lamisil online trimox 500mg cost
purchase anastrozole without prescription arimidex 1mg oral pfizer viagra 50mg
acheter 40mg tadalafil en ligne acheter 10mg du tadalafil acheter 50mg du sildenafil
buy deltasone tadalafil citrate order sildenafil 50mg without prescription
tadalafil 20mg fГјr frauen original tadalafil 20mg rezeptfrei sicher kaufen sildenafil 200mg kaufen generika
CONSORT diagram for NCIC Clinical Trials Group MA tamoxifen and weight gain More sophisticated TEG algorithms haven t been validated in prospective RCTs in the context of ICU patients with cirrhosis
doxycycline 200mg pills levitra without prescription lasix 100mg us
clonidine 0.1 mg cheap cost clonidine 0.1 mg buy spiriva 9mcg without prescription
order buspar 5mg generic purchase phenytoin pills ditropan usa
terazosin 1mg price cheap terazosin 5mg buy azulfidine sale
purchase fosamax without prescription order alendronate 35mg generic order pepcid
order benicar pills depakote 500mg without prescription order diamox 250 mg online cheap
prograf for sale online buy requip 1mg pill order generic ursodiol 300mg
purchase imdur for sale digoxin us purchase micardis for sale
zyban 150 mg for sale purchase zyrtec pill order seroquel for sale
order molnupiravir prevacid us buy generic prevacid 15mg
order sertraline 50mg Lowest price for viagra order sildenafil 50mg generic
imuran order generic salbutamol 100 mcg sildenafil pill
tadalafil 40mg cheap pfizer viagra 100mg price order generic sildenafil 50mg
order cialis 40mg pills order generic tadalafil generic symmetrel 100 mg
generic naltrexone 50mg aripiprazole 30mg tablet abilify us
buy avlosulfon 100mg generic nifedipine 30mg oral buy aceon 4mg generic
buy provera 5mg pill praziquantel 600mg pills cyproheptadine 4 mg us
modafinil sale stromectol order online buy ivermectin 3 mg for humans
order fluvoxamine ketoconazole 200 mg sale glipizide online order
order accutane 20mg for sale purchase prednisone pill order prednisone 5mg generic
buy nootropil 800mg generic sildenafil 100mg generic canadian viagra
azithromycin ca buy neurontin 100mg sale gabapentin 600mg cost
best cialis sites online generic tadalafil viagra medication
lasix price buy doxycycline pills plaquenil 400mg pill
buy cialis betnovate 20 gm drug buy anafranil 50mg online
purchase chloroquine without prescription purchase cenforce online cheap cost baricitinib 2mg
buy glycomet 500mg pills order glycomet 500mg without prescription buy generic cialis 20mg
purchase zyprexa generic generic zyprexa buy diovan 160mg generic
order clozaril 50mg for sale clozapine us buy generic dexamethasone
order omeprazole 20mg for sale pre written essays for sale playing poker online
zyvox generic blackjack free online quick hits free online slots
metoprolol over the counter metoprolol 50mg cheap levitra 20mg brand
essay helpers best casino slot games poker online sites
thesis website cost sildenafil 50mg buy sildenafil without prescription
order clomiphene 50mg clomid drug best online casino
brand aristocort purchase claritin pill desloratadine without prescription
buy dapoxetine for sale buy cytotec 200mcg online order synthroid 150mcg pills
buy generic tadalafil 40mg sildenafil 100mg usa order sildenafil 50mg online
order orlistat 120mg sale xenical medication order zovirax 800mg pills
cialis pills 20mg clopidogrel 150mg usa buy plavix 150mg pills
methotrexate 5mg sale buy methotrexate 5mg sale brand metoclopramide 10mg
buy generic domperidone 10mg order domperidone 10mg online flexeril medication
generic cozaar topiramate uk order topamax sale
purchase lioresal without prescription ozobax brand toradol 10mg canada
buy generic imitrex imitrex tablet purchase avodart generic
buy zantac 300mg buy celecoxib 200mg buy celebrex 100mg
free slot machine games free online roulette casino free spins no deposit
tamsulosin 0.4mg without prescription buy flomax 0.2mg sale spironolactone 25mg pills
order cialis 10mg online cheap order cialis 40mg without prescription generic ciprofloxacin
cost flagyl 200mg generic metronidazole 200mg buy bactrim 480mg pill
fluconazole 100mg cost order sildenafil 100mg online viagra price
order cialis 20mg for sale tadalafil 20mg uk canadian viagra
buy viagra 50mg pills brand name cialis us cialis sales
36 mmol in anhydrous Methanol, was added dropwise to a solution of 116 3 lasix and potassium levels
cost cefuroxime 500mg order cefuroxime 500mg generic order robaxin 500mg online cheap
online blackjack for real money usa order tadalafil 20mg sale cialis 40mg oral
desyrel sale buy sildenafil 50mg generic sildenafil 50mg drug
sildenafil fast shipping purchase estrace generic buy lamotrigine 200mg sale
does daily viagra lower blood pressure nilotinib will increase the level or effect of ketoconazole by affecting hepatic intestinal enzyme CYP3A4 metabolism
sildenafil 100 mg cialis viagra sales buy tadalafil 20mg online cheap
play poker online for real money crazy poker games tadalafil canada
azithromycin 500mg without prescription zithromax online order neurontin 800mg usa
real money casino hard rock casino online brand modafinil 100mg
order furosemide for sale lasix us oral hydroxychloroquine
order prednisone 40mg pills mebendazole order online mebendazole generic
buy generic fildena fildena brand cheap budesonide
brand tretinoin cream tretinoin gel tablet avanafil cheap
tadalafil 20mg ca voltaren 50mg tablet buy indocin 50mg pills
buy terbinafine amoxicillin 500mg oral buy trimox 250mg generic
biaxin 500mg canada buy meclizine 25mg buy antivert 25 mg sale
spiriva 9 mcg pills buy minocycline 50mg online terazosin cheap
actos 15mg usa sildenafil citrate 50mg viagra brand
order cialis sale Us cialis sales casino real money
casino games real money free online poker games online blackjack for real money
real money online casino real money poker online blackjack online betting
online casino gambling buy my essay professional paper writers
order ramipril 10mg pills etoricoxib generic generic etoricoxib 120mg
write research papers arava 10mg uk order sulfasalazine for sale
benicar generic purchase calan for sale divalproex 500mg pill
diamox 250 mg over the counter order acetazolamide 250mg without prescription cost imuran
buy digoxin 250 mg sale lanoxin usa molnunat oral
amoxil 250mg canada amoxil sale ivermectin 12
brand coreg coreg 25mg uk amitriptyline 10mg pills
buy dapoxetine 30mg generic dapoxetine 90mg for sale motilium 10mg sale
buy fosamax online cheap cost nitrofurantoin 100mg motrin 600mg tablet
indomethacin 50mg uk buy cenforce 50mg for sale order cenforce 50mg sale
buy nortriptyline 25 mg online nortriptyline 25 mg sale paxil usa
order generic doxycycline 100mg generic doxycycline 200mg medrol 16 mg without a doctor prescription
buy pepcid 40mg without prescription pepcid 40mg sale remeron 30mg cheap
paying large amounts of money for unproven treatment options best site to buy cialis online Examples of radiation include X rays, gamma rays, and charged particles
buy tadacip 20mg pills order clopidogrel 150mg generic order amoxicillin 250mg sale
cost ropinirole 1mg requip 1mg brand buy labetalol sale
purchase tricor pills viagra 50mg cheap buy sildenafil online cheap
order esomeprazole 20mg for sale clarithromycin uk furosemide online buy
buy cialis 40mg without prescription Generic cialis sale viagra 25mg price
buy minocycline online minocycline pill buy hytrin online
cialis coupons levitra dosage where to buy otc ed pills
glycomet online order metformin generic nolvadex 20mg generic
buy modafinil 200mg stromectol 12mg uk promethazine 25mg oral
buy prednisone 20mg buy isotretinoin without prescription amoxicillin 1000mg cheap
accutane 20mg oral cheap deltasone 20mg cost acillin
low cost ed pills pregabalin drug purchase finasteride for sale
ivermectin 3mg without prescription deltasone cheap order deltasone 5mg generic
buy zofran 8mg online cheap order amoxicillin 1000mg for sale bactrim pill
isotretinoin buy online zithromax pills zithromax for sale
best antihistamine for allergic rhinitis order synthroid amoxiclav oral
prednisolone 10mg usa generic prednisolone 5mg lasix ca
provigil over the counter lopressor 50mg price lopressor 50mg uk
buy doxycycline 100mg online cheap buy levitra 10mg for sale order acyclovir pill
avodart 0.5mg us buy cephalexin 250mg pill order orlistat 120mg online
propranolol brand order carvedilol 25mg without prescription order coreg 6.25mg generic
buy imuran 50mg order naprosyn 500mg sale brand naproxen 500mg
buy oxybutynin sale buy tacrolimus sale order oxcarbazepine generic
buy cefdinir 300 mg online buy protonix 40mg sale pantoprazole 20mg brand
simvastatin order order promethazine 25mg online cheap sildalis pills