Sponsored by Voya Financial
Voya is releasing a new whitepaper from its Voya Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation: “Financial Wellness Meets Behavioral Economics: Helping Participants See the Big Picture and Act on It.” In the 21st century, American workers must prioritize both health and wealth when making financial decisions. As a result, they have to effectively allocate their savings across different financial products and accounts. Given the complexity of these alternatives, making the right choice requires workers to see the big picture.
Within the paper, written by Shlomo Benartzi, professor emeritus, UCLA Anderson School of Management, and senior academic advisor to the institute, Benartzi outlines opportunities and considerations for employers to help their workers allocate their savings to maximize health and wealth.
When it comes to saving for the future, many individuals look to their workplace for support, but the reality is that saving is often not enough. Today, workers are also tasked with distributing their funds across several different financial products and accounts, such as retirement accounts, emergency savings, health care and even education. Alongside these competing financial priorities, nearly three-quarters (73%) of Americans feel like their money does not go as far as it used to,1 according to new data from Voya.
In the new whitepaper, Benartzi examines a behavioral tendency known as “narrow framing” — an inability to see the “big picture.” When it comes to the allocation of savings, narrow framing can lead people to fund accounts that may not be as financially beneficial for one’s needs and long-term financial wellness. For example, not saving for emergencies can expose people to financial shocks and expensive debt, which can lead them to seek funds from their retirement savings.
“Because many individuals are susceptible to narrow framing in making financial decisions, it’s important to offer workers clear guidance on how to allocate their dollars across various financial categories, from savings accounts to health insurance plans,” added Benartzi. “Financial wellness is like physical wellness. If you want to be truly healthy, you have to develop a holistic plan involving diet, exercise and sleep. Financial wellness requires the same holistic commitment. However, thinking holistically about one’s finances often requires help, which is where employers have a unique opportunity to support their workforce.”
Using the tools and insights of behavioral economics, Benartzi suggests there are three primary actions that employers can take to improve the overall financial wellness of their workforce. Specifically, he suggests employers create a platform that:
- Shows the big picture. When offering employees saving options, it’s important to provide the opportunity to save for emergencies at the same time as retirement. Similarly, when offering employees health insurance options, consider combining the cost of premiums and deductibles to provide a greater understanding of the total potential cost.
- Makes it easy to act on the big picture. Once individuals are able to see the big picture, being able to act on it is just as important. For example, when it comes to emergency savings, consider utilizing the same autopilot tools that help workers save for retirement, including an escalator feature. For high-deductible health insurance plans, this could mean helping individuals redirect their savings from the lower premiums into a health savings account or supplemental insurance plan.
- Personalizes the big picture. When it comes to savings, no individuals are alike, which is why personalized guidance is becoming more and more important. The best health insurance option, for instance, will often depend on one’s expected medical usage; while the optimal allocation of savings will depend on how much they have saved and their retirement income goal.
“As household finances become more and more complex, narrow framing is becoming an increasingly costly mental tendency,” added Benartzi. “By minimizing the impact of narrow framing, we can truly help employees better allocate their scarce dollars. The goal is to make the optimal choice the easiest choice.”
Celebrating five years of behavioral science in action
Since its launch in 2016, the studies and collective insights conducted through Voya’s Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation have enhanced the digital experiences of more than 99% of Voya’s retirement plans and nearly 5,500,000 eligible retirement participants.2 This includes influencing more than 1 million eligible retirement participants with their retirement savings plans — and with more than 375,000 individuals taking action.3 Improvements in participants’ savings rates have also ranged from meaningful 8% increases to, in some cases, a significant doubling of one’s savings rate.4 By merging behavioral science with the speed and scale of the digital world, the institute continues to create large-scale solutions designed to help improve individual retirement outcomes.
As an industry leader focused on the delivery of health, wealth and investment solutions to and through the workplace, Voya Financial is committed to delivering on its mission to make a secure financial future possible for all Americans — one person, one family, one institution at a time.
1. Voya Financial survey conducted Aug. 27–30, 2021, on the Ipsos eNation omnibus online platform among 1,003 adults, featuring 475 working Americans and 291 eligible for benefits, aged 18+ in the U.S.
2. Includes Voya Enroll, Pweb screen changes and personalized video distribution.
3. Taking action defined as being influenced by a behaviorally modified digital intervention that increases participation or the rate of savings (e.g., smarter defaults, saved by design, rate escalate, save more and restart savings email campaigns, and personalized videos). This includes those accepting non-zero defaults.
4. Depending on where in the digital experience actions were taken by a participant. Based on Beshears, Mason and Benartzi. “How to Choose a Default” (coming in 2021); Bhargava, Conell-Price, Mason, and Benartzi. “Save(d) by Design” (Working Paper 2018).