This article is an on-site version of our Moral Money newsletter. Sign up here to get the newsletter sent straight to your inbox.
Visit our Moral Money hub for all the latest ESG news, opinion and analysis from around the FT
Do the Monday blues get you down? We have something to jazz up the start of your week and keep you informed too. Starting on January 24, we will be publishing on Mondays, complementing our award-winning coverage on Wednesdays and Fridays. Since our launch in June 2019, Moral Money has endeavoured to deliver the fullest possible range of news and analysis on sustainable business and finance, as that agenda has taken the business world by storm. So, from next week, join us for Moral Mondays, as we take you deeper inside the push for a more sustainable world economy.
As for today, Simon Monday — no, too much, sorry, Mundy — digs into the debate over whether companies can thrive by pursuing sustainability and profits at the same time. And Kristen Talman and I have a report on the US labour movement, which has found new energy thanks to investor interest in the Amazon and Starbucks fights. Patrick Temple-West
Amazon and Starbucks face new ESG headache: unions
Unionisation efforts in the US are coming to a head. Amazon warehouse workers in Alabama will be voting by mail starting on February 4, kicking off the second unionisation effort at the retail giant. On Monday, tech workers at The New York Times will start voting to organise after a heated campaign over the past few months.
After decades of union-busting, companies have almost pounded organised labour into oblivion. Just 6 per cent of private-sector workers are in a union, according to the labour department. But now, union efforts at Amazon and Starbucks have rejuvenated the labour movement, and ESG-minded investors are putting new pressure on companies concerning their union practices.
Starbucks has already started warning investors of the risks presented by this increasingly controversial situation.
“Our responses to any union organising efforts could negatively impact how our brand is perceived and have adverse effects on our business,” it said in a November regulatory filing.
“Businesses cannot ignore the fact that they cannot treat their workers as a commodity,” said Jonas Kron, chief advocacy officer at Trillium Asset Management. The ESG community had been happy for some time to discuss environmental issues, but “there has been a slow-building of awareness about the ‘S’,” he added.
During the first unionisation attempt at Amazon last year, a group of 70 investors asked the company to not interfere with the process, claiming it went against its own human rights principles. Separately, Trillium and other investors urged Starbucks to respect the decision of workers at an outlet in Buffalo, New York, who last month voted to unionise — the first time the company had faced such a move.
Amazon and Starbucks offer a cautionary tale — even employers with relatively decent benefits can have employees launching unionisation drives. This year, Amazon raised the average pay for 125,000 warehouse workers to $18 per hour in the US, almost double the federal minimum wage, while pledging $700m to retrain 100,000 employees for advanced roles over the next five years. Starbucks offers healthcare benefits and tuition reimbursement for baristas, a rarity in the service industry.
Corporate union efforts appear likely to be one of the biggest business stories of the year. Just as some companies were caught off-guard by surging investor concern about climate change, neglecting labour issues could prove costly for slow-footed businesses; particularly since restive employees seem increasingly willing to vote with their feet, and the Biden administration is pledging to boost workers’ bargaining power. Kristen Talman and Patrick Temple-West
Does stakeholder capitalism pay its way?
The debate over corporate sustainability strategies had a couple of punchy new contributions in recent days. In his annual January missive, Larry Fink hit out at claims that stakeholder capitalism is a “woke” agenda, arguing that companies rely on mutually beneficial relationships with employees, communities and others if they are to prosper. That contrasted with a characteristically sharp intervention from the high-profile British investor Terry Smith, who accused consumer goods producer Unilever of having “lost the plot” with its vaunted purpose-driven agenda.
Both comments added fresh fuel to the argument over whether companies’ pursuit of sustainability goals helps or hinders their profitability and returns to shareholders. But what do the data show?
Two reports out this week provide some new food for thought. One comes from Corporate Knights, which runs the sustainability-focused Global 100 index. The index scores all listed global companies with more than $1bn in revenue on 23 metrics, ranging from racial diversity to the percentage of revenue derived from low-carbon activities. Since the index was set up in 2005, it has returned 331 per cent, against 279 per cent for the All-Country World index.
But a look at the long-run chart, above, makes clear that this outperformance is a recent development, accompanying a surge of green investment plans in response to pandemic-driven economic turmoil. And it’s far from clear that it will be sustained for long, as share prices in some of the most highly regarded sustainability performers come under pressure.
When I spoke this week to Henrik Andersen, chief executive of Danish wind turbine maker Vestas — which secured the top spot in Corporate Knights’ latest sustainability ranking — he highlighted the company’s efforts to tackle the environmental effects of its entire supply chain, and to build a focus on sustainability in each of its 29,000 employees. Yet Vestas’ share price has fallen almost a third over the past year, as investors switched their focus from its impact on carbon emissions to its surging input costs. It’s far from an outlier: as Patrick and Kristen noted recently, valuations in the clean energy companies dramatically underperformed the oil and gas sector last year.
Still, another new report this week offered new ammunition to those who argue that companies with a “multi-stakeholder” approach have healthier prospects over the long term. Published by think-tank FCLT and the Wharton School, it assessed companies on both “talk” — mentions of sustainability-related issues in their annual reports — and “walk” — environmental, social and governance performance, as assessed by MSCI and others.
Using data from 2010-2020, the study assessed more than 3,000 big global companies’ performance over one-, two- and three-year time spans. Those that scored highly on both “walk” and “talk” generated 4 per cent higher investor returns and 1.5 per cent greater revenue growth than the average over a three-year period, with lower volatility. Interestingly, they also showed a much more long-term approach to strategy: they invested twice as much in research and development as peers, relative to sales, and were 50 per cent more likely to issue long-term guidance.
Due caution is needed when considering reports such as these. For one thing, there is still no sort of consensus about what truly constitutes a sustainable company (for more on this, watch the informative Davos Agenda panel that Gillian moderated yesterday). Standards of disclosure vary wildly between countries, industries and individual companies, making comprehensive apples-to-apples comparisons impossible.
With the push for a common global set of sustainability standards, and tightening regulations around climate-related disclosures in the US, Europe and beyond, far more robust data sets may emerge to shed more conclusive light on the relationship between sustainability strategies and financial performance. For the foreseeable future, the likes of Fink and Smith will have ample scope for argument. Simon Mundy
Chart of the day
The ESG analysis team at JPMorgan has just published a useful dive into the hydrogen sector, widely seen as a crucial pillar of the emerging green economy. While hydrogen-related stocks had a rough year in 2021, they note, government strategies took some big steps forward. That’s set to drive huge growth over the next decade in “green hydrogen” capacity — produced through electrolysis using renewable energy.
While corporate leaders are enthusiastically talking up their embrace of enlightened capitalism, investors see their statements as “shallow and flimsy, lacking substance and any mechanisms for accountability”, write Bob Eccles and two fellow Oxford academics in this interesting piece for Fortune, based on interviews with dozens of big global asset managers, asset owners and company leaders.
The global tech sector has been raking in huge sums from earbuds and other increasingly tiny electronic items. But what happens when they are discarded — and what does that mean for the global pollution crisis? Don’t miss this excellent, graphic-rich report from the FT’s Alexandra Heal.
levofloxacin pills buy levaquin pill
avodart 0.5mg generic flomax for sale online order zofran 4mg generic
cheap aldactone aldactone 100mg tablet buy fluconazole 200mg generic
ampicillin uk bactrim 960mg sale cost erythromycin 250mg
cheap sildenafil 100mg fildena 100mg without prescription robaxin 500mg pill
suhagra 100mg canada buy aurogra 50mg generic estradiol 1mg over the counter
cost lamotrigine 50mg order retin online retin cream us
order tadalis 10mg online voltaren 100mg brand buy generic voltaren 50mg
buy indomethacin 75mg without prescription amoxicillin price amoxicillin 500mg uk
usa pharmacy cialis foods for ed order viagra 100mg pills
buy arimidex 1 mg pills Levitra or viagra sildenafil 100mg tablets
vrai tadalafil prix tadalafil 5mg prix sildenafil 50mg sans ordonnance en pharmacie
prednisone 5mg price tadalafil dosage generic viagra 100mg
cialis generika rezeptfrei kaufen viagra fГјr mГ¤nner viagra 50mg fГјr mГ¤nner
isotretinoin 10mg uk purchase isotretinoin for sale ivermectin cream 1%
doxycycline 200mg ca order doxycycline generic buy lasix 40mg generic
order ramipril generic generic avapro order azelastine sprayer
catapres 0.1 mg oral buy minocin 100mg pill tiotropium bromide 9mcg pills
buspirone pills oxybutynin usa oxybutynin 5mg pill
purchase terazosin pills buy leflunomide 20mg sale sulfasalazine buy online
fosamax 35mg us ibuprofen pills purchase famotidine
olmesartan 20mg us calan us cost diamox 250 mg
isosorbide 40mg tablet micardis usa buy micardis 80mg online cheap
zyban 150mg drug quetiapine 50mg pills cost seroquel 100mg
molnunat 200mg usa cheap naproxen buy lansoprazole pill
sertraline tablet escitalopram drug viagra pills 100mg
salbutamol 100 mcg uk viagra for men over 50 order viagra 100mg pill
buy cialis 20mg without prescription order prozac 20mg pills sildenafil generic
order generic naltrexone 50mg buy albendazole generic buy abilify 30mg sale
provera price purchase microzide online cheap cyproheptadine price
modafinil 100mg tablet buy stromectol generic stromectol us
buy accutane 20mg for sale accutane 10mg uk order deltasone 20mg generic
azithromycin 500mg drug order azithromycin online cheap buy generic gabapentin 100mg
furosemide generic hydroxychloroquine online order hydroxychloroquine 400mg pill
order tadalafil 5mg for sale cialis 5mg drug buy anafranil 25mg
chloroquine drug chloroquine us olumiant uk
sporanox medication buy tinidazole 300mg pills tindamax 300mg us
order generic glucophage buy metformin pill cialis on line
olanzapine 10mg ca zyprexa without prescription valsartan 160mg tablet
clozapine 100mg over the counter buy combivent order decadron 0,0,5 mg without prescription
sildenafil 200 mg buy viagra generic generic lisinopril 5mg
order linezolid 600mg online casino online slots global poker online
order prilosec online cheap buy prilosec pills free roulette
order lopressor 100mg generic metoprolol 50mg canada buy levitra pill
cheap essay writing that roulette best online casinos
order vardenafil without prescription buy levitra 20mg generic medrol 4mg online
custom research paper writing custom written papers viagra 100mg pills
clomid 50mg oral clomiphene 50mg tablet online slots
tadalafil max dose cialis tablets sildenafil 100mg us
buy triamcinolone online cost desloratadine buy clarinex 5mg
dapoxetine 30mg tablet brand synthroid buy levothyroxine tablets
cialis 5mg cheap real viagra pills viagra 100mg without prescription
order xenical 60mg online buy xenical generic acyclovir pills
tadalafil 40mg generic buy plavix 75mg for sale buy plavix 75mg pill
buy zyloprim 100mg pill zetia 10mg tablet zetia buy online
methotrexate 5mg canada buy metoclopramide 20mg sale metoclopramide 20mg oral
losartan without prescription order topiramate 100mg for sale order generic topiramate 100mg
purchase lioresal online order tizanidine cost ketorolac
buy sumatriptan online cheap avodart 0.5mg uk avodart over the counter
colchicine 0.5mg without prescription order generic colchicine 0.5mg online blackjack with friends
zantac 150mg oral order meloxicam 15mg pill buy celebrex 100mg without prescription
blackjack free online empire casino online slots casino games
buy flomax 0.4mg pills buy ondansetron pills buy generic aldactone 100mg
buy tadalafil 40mg sale ciprofloxacin without prescription brand ciprofloxacin 1000mg
buy simvastatin 10mg pill zocor 20mg over the counter finasteride ca
order flagyl without prescription buy bactrim 960mg online cheap order bactrim 480mg generic
buy fluconazole buy viagra 100mg for sale overnight delivery for viagra
buy generic tadalafil 40mg cialis 10mg ca buy viagra 50mg
buy viagra 50mg pill viagra pills 100mg order tadalafil 40mg pill
order ceftin online cheap order careprost pills methocarbamol 500mg brand
play roulette free for fun online roulette game real money generic cialis canada
desyrel cost desyrel 50mg brand aurogra 50mg without prescription
college essay writing help academicwriters ivermectin 0.5% brand name
sildenafil over the counter buy estrace 2mg generic order lamotrigine 50mg
prednisone over the counter amoxil 500mg uk purchase amoxil online
sildenafil 100mg cheap viagra 100mg england tadalafil 10mg generic
azithromycin 250mg us zithromax 500mg pills order generic gabapentin 100mg
play casino slots tadalafil 40 mg tadalafil 40mg us
online gambling real money cost stromectol 12mg buy provigil 200mg
furosemide 100mg without prescription buy lasix 100mg online cheap plaquenil usa
order prednisone pills prazosin price vermox without prescription
sildenafil online order fildena 50mg for sale budesonide for sale online
order tretinoin gel generic purchase avana sale avana over the counter
order tadacip sale buy indocin for sale purchase indomethacin pills
buy lamisil for sale terbinafine 250mg brand brand trimox 250mg
purchase biaxin without prescription clarithromycin usa meclizine price
order naprosyn 500mg sale buy cefdinir 300 mg without prescription lansoprazole oral
spiriva 9 mcg cost hytrin 1mg ca cheap terazosin
albuterol cost cheap ciprofloxacin 500mg order cipro 500mg without prescription
pioglitazone 30mg brand sildenafil for sale sildenafil 50mg ca
order montelukast 10mg pill sildenafil 100mg price sildenafil 100mg tablets
order cialis Approved cialis pharmacy no deposit bonus codes
tadalafil brand name cheap ed pills order cialis online cheap
poker online game best online casinos real money online gambling for real money
ivermectin 6mg tablet order amantadine 100 mg generic order dapsone sale
play roulette for free online slot games best online gambling sites
slot machine best online pharmacy in canada essay writing assistance
nifedipine 30mg uk buy fexofenadine pill fexofenadine 120mg without prescription
altace 5mg brand etoricoxib cheap purchase etoricoxib online
assignment company buy arava 20mg sale azulfidine for sale
order generic doxycycline ventolin uk buy clindamycin generic
benicar 20mg usa order generic calan 240mg order divalproex 250mg generic
order asacol generic order astelin 10 ml without prescription irbesartan 150mg pills
diamox without prescription buy diamox 250 mg sale imuran tablet
clobetasol order online buy generic temovate purchase cordarone for sale
digoxin medication order lanoxin pill order molnunat 200mg without prescription
Read here. Read here.
buying real viagra online
Everything information about medication. Definitive journal of drugs and therapeutics.
coreg pills order carvedilol 6.25mg pills buy elavil 10mg pill
amoxil oral order amoxicillin 500mg sale cost of ivermectin lotion
fosamax 70mg generic order nitrofurantoin 100mg pill purchase motrin generic
priligy 60mg price order avana for sale order motilium 10mg generic
order pamelor 25 mg generic nortriptyline over the counter buy paxil 20mg sale
indomethacin 50mg sale buy cenforce generic cenforce order
order famotidine 20mg sale order prograf 5mg generic order mirtazapine 30mg online cheap
doxycycline ca methylprednisolone 4mg pills medrol 8mg oral
tricor price viagra 50mg for sale sildenafil 150 mg
order nexium without prescription order lasix 40mg for sale lasix us
buy tadalafil 10mg Sales cialis purchase viagra for sale
minocycline order online buy minocycline 100mg pill oral hytrin
cialis 5mg tablet Buy cialis cheap medications for ed
metformin sale order metformin 500mg online buy nolvadex online cheap
buy provigil 100mg generic modafinil us order generic promethazine
order clomiphene 50mg generic prednisolone cost prednisolone pills
deltasone 5mg us buy deltasone 5mg for sale amoxicillin order
isotretinoin cheap oral ampicillin 250mg buy generic ampicillin 250mg
ed pills proscar 1mg without prescription buy proscar
ivermectin brand name ed pills that work generic deltasone 40mg
order zofran pill buy amoxil 500mg pills buy sulfamethoxazole
accutane 40mg drug buy zithromax 500mg sale order azithromycin 250mg without prescription
buy ventolin 4mg buy clavulanate buy augmentin 625mg
purchase provigil generic lopressor 100mg pills order lopressor 100mg generic
generic prednisolone 10mg gabapentin 100mg tablet furosemide 100mg canada
avodart 0.5mg sale xenical online buy buy xenical 120mg pill
vibra-tabs oral zovirax cost acyclovir 400mg cost
buy omnicef generic purchase lansoprazole generic protonix 20mg price
buy zocor 20mg generic order zocor 10mg pill sildenafil india
dapsone 100 mg for sale cost avlosulfon 100 mg buy generic tenormin over the counter
viagra 50mg cheap generic cialis tadalafil 20mg over the counter