Founders and senior managers of companies held by Ark Invest’s flagship exchange traded fund have sold shares at a swift clip in recent months, highlighting the rising market angst about speculative tech companies.
Company insiders sold $13.5bn of stock — and bought just $11m — in the six months to December, far higher than in any previous period, according to calculations by StoneX, a brokerage. The figure is distorted by about $10.7bn of sales of Tesla stock by chief executive Elon Musk that occurred before the data’s mid-December cut-off point.
However, even stripping out Tesla, insider sales in these companies have been at levels well above historic norms, having averaged nearer $500m per six-month period between 2015 and 2020.
The sales come during a tense moment for Cathie Wood’s Ark Innovation ETF (ARKK), which has lost almost half its value since its February 2021 peak. Its gain of more than 150 per cent in 2020 made it the poster child for Wall Street’s technology-fuelled boom, earning Wood, its founder, chief executive and portfolio manager, the nickname “Queen of the bull market”.
Many of the fast-growing, but highly speculative tech companies that have been core to ARKK’s rise have stumbled in recent months. A Goldman Sachs index of unprofitable US-listed tech groups, for example, is down by a third over the past 12 months, although it is still up more than 100 per cent over the past two years.
While ARKK takes a long-term view on its holdings, the rise in sales by insiders is something that is monitored by some analysts and investors.
“The spike in insider sales and the lack of buying interest is worrying,” said Vincent Deluard, global macro strategist at StoneX. “The median ARKK holding has lost 55 per cent since its 52-week high: if insiders are not buying now, why should investors?”
Deluard said it was not unexpected that insider selling should outweigh buying as cash-poor founders diversify their portfolios and early employees receive stock options.
A similar trend has unfolded in the wider US stock market, with insiders selling a record $32bn of stock in S&P 500 companies in the past six months, while purchases fell to a six-year low of $95m.
However, Deluard said the sheer scale of the gulf between insider buying and selling for ARKK’s investee companies was surprising given the sharp sell-off many of these stocks suffered in the final two months of 2021 — a period during which the S&P 500 continued to rise.
“Company insiders tend to be quite contrarian in their actions. They buy after a big drop. We have had a big drop and we have seen a lot of selling and not much buying,” Deluard added.
“If the smart people are not buying, why should anyone else? Bubbles are always and everywhere a transfer of wealth from the public to insiders.”
Ben Johnson, director of global ETF research at Morningstar, said the insider transactions data “would seem to indicate that Cathie and team have more conviction in these firms than the people running them”.
The data come as ARKK’s sell-off means the fund has destroyed shareholder value since its launch in 2014, despite reporting returns of 328 per cent over this period.
ARKK has had cumulative net inflows of $15.5bn since launch, yet as of Thursday’s close, its net assets were just $14.4bn, meaning it has not created any value for the average investor, most of whom only bought in after the fund had generated the bulk of its returns.
“No shareholder value has been created because most investors piled in at inflated prices in 2020 and 2021,” said Deluard.
“Cathie Wood has no control over her investors’ [poor] timing and the true measure of her talent comes from time-weighted returns, which remain stunning despite last year’s losses. Nonetheless, the reality of investors’ flows cannot be ignored.”
This trend is far from unique to ARKK. Investors’ tendency to pile into a fund after it has made its biggest gains is so strong that investors’ dollar-weighted returns lagged behind funds’ total returns by 1.7 percentage points a year across the entire US market in the decade to 2020, according to Morningstar.
But there is room to question Wood’s declaration of Ark Invest’s higher purpose.
Wood, a devout Christian, has said Ark’s mission is not just to make money for investors, “it’s about allocating capital to God’s creation in the most innovative and creative way possible”.
ARKK attracted net inflows of $17bn between January 2019 to June 2021, money that was invested in companies which generated combined earnings of $23bn during this period, Deluard found.
These companies spent $47bn on research and development over the 30 months, as well as issuing $14bn in new stock.
Deluard argued this investment and fundraising was “doubtlessly facilitated by ARKK’s massive purchases”, which “allowed a lot of young companies with unproven technology to raise a lot of equity at much higher valuations” than would otherwise have been the case.
“The claim that ARKK funds research and increases the pace of innovation is credible. Newly issued shares sold to ARKK helped bridge the gap between high-growth companies’ small or negative profits and their large R&D expenses,” he added.
However, Deluard said ARKK’s investee companies issued $23bn in stock-based pay over the same period.
“A less optimistic narrative is equally credible. Flows in Ark ETFs may have spurred research and innovation, but they also allowed insiders and founders to cash out at absurd valuations,” he said.
“Time will tell whether Ark Investment Management funded the next industrial revolution or organised a historical transfer of wealth from the public to insiders and early investors,” concluded Deluard, a hypothesis he believed was strengthened by the current bout of insider selling.
Johnson at Morningstar believed that, during its lifetime, ARKK may potentially have improved society, “but if so, by an imperceptibly small amount and in a very roundabout manner”.
*This story has been updated since original publication to include figures for Elon Musk’s Tesla sales*
order levofloxacin pills order levofloxacin 250mg generic
avodart over the counter dutasteride drug buy zofran 4mg without prescription
order spironolactone 25mg generic purchase aldactone generic cost diflucan 100mg
generic ampicillin 250mg erythromycin 500mg oral order erythromycin pills
sildenafil 100mg brand brand fildena 50mg methocarbamol generic
order generic suhagra 100mg aurogra 100mg without prescription order generic estrace 1mg
lamictal 50mg us buy tretinoin sale oral tretinoin cream
tadalis pills tadacip 20mg cost diclofenac 100mg price
brand accutane amoxicillin 500mg cheap order azithromycin 250mg
buy indocin online cheap suprax 100mg over the counter amoxicillin 500mg ca
cialis coupon Best price for viagra viagra online buy
buy arimidex 1 mg without prescription clarithromycin 250mg over the counter female viagra pill
cialis 20mg pour homme tadalafil 10mg gГ©nГ©rique sildenafil generique
prednisone 5mg drug order prednisone 40mg without prescription sildenafil pills
tadalafil 20mg kaufen fГјr mГ¤nner original tadalafil rezeptfrei sicher kaufen original sildenafil 200mg rezeptfrei sicher kaufen
order accutane 40mg online cheap order accutane 20mg without prescription stromectol 3mg tablets
order provigil 100mg pills purchase diamox generic diamox sale
doxycycline 200mg ca furosemide medication generic furosemide
altace 5mg for sale ramipril pills astelin 10ml us
order generic catapres purchase clonidine sale spiriva pill
cost hytrin actos 30mg oral generic azulfidine
alendronate generic panadol drug pepcid uk
order olmesartan online verapamil 240mg for sale purchase acetazolamide online
order tacrolimus 1mg sale trandate cheap buy urso 300mg pills
isosorbide usa digoxin 2250 mg cheap order micardis without prescription
bupropion ca oral strattera 10mg buy seroquel 100mg for sale
buy molnupiravir online omnicef usa lansoprazole pills
zoloft 100mg cheap cost zoloft 50mg sildenafil for sale
buy imuran 100 mcg order sildenafil 50mg pill viagra professional
tadalafil 20mg without prescription fluoxetine ca purchase sildenafil online
brand tadalafil 10mg buy pyridium 200 mg generic buy symmetrel
order naltrexone 50 mg pill buy revia 50 mg online aripiprazole generic
oral avlosulfon buy fexofenadine pill perindopril ca
provera 5mg brand cyproheptadine 4 mg tablet order periactin 4 mg online cheap
modafinil for sale purchase stromectol online is ivermectin a prescription drug
buy luvox pill cymbalta brand glucotrol price
order accutane 40mg for sale accutane buy online buy deltasone 5mg pills
buy nootropil 800mg pill viagra oral buy sildenafil 50mg
buy azithromycin 250mg generic neurontin 800mg without prescription order neurontin online cheap
buy cialis 40mg online cheap buy generic sildenafil 100mg cheap sildenafil 50mg
purchase chloroquine pill olumiant online buy baricitinib 4mg generic
order itraconazole 100 mg buy tindamax 500mg online tinidazole 500mg pill
metformin 500mg usa lipitor ca cialis 5mg oral
order generic zyprexa 10mg buy olanzapine pills valsartan 160mg us
clozapine 100mg generic buy generic combivent dexamethasone order online
buy sildenafil 100mg online viagra 50mg ca lisinopril 2.5mg pill
order zyvox sale play great poker online blackjack online betting
order generic omeprazole 10mg custom dissertation casino game
buy lopressor generic order metoprolol 100mg pill purchase vardenafil online
cheap custom research papers write papers for me casino slots
vardenafil 10mg oral medrol 8mg oral buy methylprednisolone 16mg online
cheap essay online best essay service order viagra without prescription
clomiphene pills online black jack slots real money
cost tadalafil 5mg order cialis 10mg without prescription sildenafil order online
aristocort canada order desloratadine 5mg generic order clarinex for sale
generic priligy 60mg cytotec 200mcg tablet synthroid 75mcg pill
tadalafil 5mg sale sildenafil 50mg without prescription viagra 100mg for sale
xenical 120mg sale diltiazem pills zovirax buy online
buy zyloprim 100mg for sale zetia brand ezetimibe 10mg cost
methotrexate 5mg sale reglan 10mg pills order reglan 20mg without prescription
purchase motilium without prescription buy motilium 10mg sale cyclobenzaprine 15mg uk
cozaar 25mg sale order cozaar 50mg pills topamax 200mg cost
order ozobax online purchase toradol online buy toradol online
buy sumatriptan sale order generic levaquin order generic dutasteride
order colchicine for sale play online blackjack real money gambling online
buy zantac 300mg without prescription order generic ranitidine buy celecoxib 200mg generic
no deposit free spins online casino for real cash online casino slots
tamsulosin brand spironolactone brand order aldactone 100mg generic
cialis 10mg over the counter order cialis cipro 1000mg ca
simvastatin without prescription order valtrex 1000mg purchase propecia sale
order fluconazole 200mg online order viagra 100mg without prescription viagra 50mg oral
order generic keflex cleocin online order erythromycin pills
buy sildenafil 50mg without prescription order sildenafil for sale tadalafil 40mg cost
cefuroxime pills buy bimatoprost online purchase robaxin online
free spins no deposit casino cialis cost cialis 40mg
desyrel online suhagra brand sildenafil oral
cheap paper writing services cheap custom essays ivermectin 3 mg tablets for humans
cost sildalis lamictal medication order lamotrigine generic
prednisone 40mg for sale order isotretinoin for sale buy amoxicillin 500mg pill
buy generic sildenafil buy viagra 50mg pills real cialis pharmacy prescription
gamble poker online tadalafil 20mg uk tadalafil 40mg tablet
zithromax online azithromycin uk cheap gabapentin sale
free online slots stromectol 12mg brand buy modafinil 100mg sale
lasix tablet lasix 100mg price plaquenil 400mg price
purchase fildena pills tamoxifen 20mg without prescription purchase rhinocort generic
order prednisone for sale deltasone 10mg canada order mebendazole pills
retin over the counter order avana 200mg online cheap order avanafil 100mg online cheap
generic tadalafil diclofenac 100mg cheap cost indomethacin 50mg
purchase lamisil generic terbinafine 250mg pills order trimox 250mg
buy biaxin 250mg pill clonidine 0.1mg ca order antivert 25mg online cheap
naproxen 250mg over the counter omnicef pill prevacid 15mg oral
oral tiotropium bromide tiotropium bromide 9mcg pills order hytrin online cheap
purchase albuterol sale proventil 100mcg oral buy cipro 1000mg for sale
buy actos pills cost viagra 50mg viagra over the counter
singulair 10mg brand buy viagra 100mg online cheap purchase viagra online cheap
buy cialis for sale Discount cialis no rx slots online
real cialis pharmacy prescription best place to buy ed pills online buy cialis 5mg pills
online casino no deposit bonus free online blackjack no download online poker real money
ivermectin 6 mg for humans avlosulfon oral dapsone 100 mg tablet
hollywood casino gambling casino online real money games
nifedipine buy online perindopril for sale fexofenadine online buy
slot games academic writing article essays help
buy assignments buying an essay azulfidine oral
doxycycline 100mg pills buy doxycycline online cleocin 300mg uk
order benicar without prescription buy benicar online buy depakote sale
asacol 400mg pills avapro 300mg cheap purchase avapro
temovate uk order clobetasol without prescription order generic amiodarone 100mg
acetazolamide 250mg tablet buy isosorbide 20mg online azathioprine 50mg over the counter
cost digoxin 250mg micardis without prescription molnunat 200mg for sale
buy generic carvedilol 25mg elavil 10mg cheap amitriptyline buy online
cheap amoxicillin pills order generic stromectol 12mg ivermectin usa price
buy fosamax 70mg generic ibuprofen 400mg pills ibuprofen 600mg ca
order priligy 60mg generic avana uk buy motilium pill
buy generic pamelor buy panadol online cheap paroxetine drug
order indomethacin 50mg online cheap order cenforce generic order generic cenforce 50mg
pepcid pill order pepcid 40mg pills buy mirtazapine 30mg online
order doxycycline 200mg online aralen 250mg canada buy methylprednisolone online
requip online buy requip 2mg us labetalol 100mg drug
order tadalafil 20mg online cheap clopidogrel usa buy amoxicillin 250mg generic
tricor 200mg without prescription generic fenofibrate 200mg order viagra 50mg online cheap
nexium tablet lasix pills buy furosemide pills
buy generic cialis 40mg Cialis canadian cost overnight delivery viagra
cost minocycline 100mg buy gabapentin 100mg sale terazosin 1mg tablet
tadalafil cheap cialis delivered non prescription ed drugs
glucophage buy online nolvadex usa tamoxifen brand
provigil order online generic provigil order phenergan pills
buy clomiphene generic clomiphene buy online order prednisolone generic
deltasone 20mg sale amoxil for sale buy amoxicillin 250mg generic
isotretinoin 20mg generic buy prednisone 5mg online cheap ampicillin uk
buying ed pills online buy generic pregabalin 75mg proscar 1mg brand
ivermectin price canada buy stromectol online cheap cost prednisone 5mg
buy generic ondansetron 8mg order amoxicillin generic trimethoprim ca
buy isotretinoin without prescription buy amoxicillin 500mg without prescription buy azithromycin 250mg for sale
albuterol price albuterol canada order augmentin 375mg pill
order prednisolone 10mg generic order neurontin 600mg for sale oral lasix 100mg
modafinil 200mg canada metoprolol online order buy lopressor 100mg without prescription
mba application essay writing service cheap custom essay papers essay correction service
buy dutasteride avodart 0.5mg drug purchase orlistat online cheap
online essay writing help help write essay online essay writing service canada
vibra-tabs ca levitra buy online order zovirax 400mg pills
essay writing service discount essay homework help online where to buy essays
3.5 arcane thesis working thesis examples writing a thesis
order azathioprine 25mg pill buy imuran 50mg pills buy naprosyn 250mg online
what is a thesis statement definition explanatory thesis cruel angel’s thesis english lyrics
thesis statement definition thesis outline template thesis statement for literary analysis
oxybutynin usa tacrolimus tablet order oxcarbazepine 600mg generic
a well worded thesis statement is both __________ and __________ cruel angel’s thesis piano sheet music writing a good thesis
purchase cefdinir pills brand pantoprazole brand protonix 40mg
order simvastatin 20mg online cheap buy zocor 10mg generic sildenafil next day delivery
cost avlosulfon 100mg asacol 400mg oral atenolol order