The US government significantly underestimated the number of jobs created this year as it struggled to analyse data distorted by the effects of the pandemic, creating fresh challenges for policymakers navigating a highly volatile economic environment.
Over the course of 2021, the government agency that releases the monthly US jobs statistics has revised its initial estimates of payroll growth upwards by a total of 976,000 jobs, the highest such adjustment in a single year.
Revising past estimates to account for new data is a routine exercise: the initial estimate that the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) calculates is updated twice, with the second estimate published in the next month’s jobs report and the third estimate published the month after that.
It is during major economic inflection points, however, that these numbers are not only hardest to measure, but also monitored most closely. That means data revisions, typically published without fanfare, suddenly have the potential to substantially alter conceptions of labour market health and in turn, how exactly policy should be fine-tuned.
“The economic fundamentals have been shifting at unprecedented speed. Not in my lifetime and not in the lifetime of most people alive today have we seen . . . an economic recovery that has been as rapid as it has been since the spring of 2020,” said David Wilcox, who used to lead the research and statistics division at the Federal Reserve. “The challenges of economic measurement in a pandemic environment are enormous.”
The pandemic has proved uniquely thorny for economists looking at the US labour market, because it has not only created lags in the reporting of data but also distorted the seasonal rhythms that are typically factored into estimates. The sheer size of payroll growth during the economic recovery has also created challenges.
“You’re taking an already difficult task and making it absolutely Herculean,” said Ernie Tedeschi, a senior economic adviser to the Biden administration as a member of the Council of Economic Advisers.
That difficulty was once again on display in the latest jobs report published on December 3, which showed just 210,000 new positions created in November. The unemployment rate tumbled further to 4.2 per cent, a far cry from the nearly 15 per cent level reached last year.
The numbers confounded economists, not least because of a sizeable gap between the two surveys that comprise the monthly report. The “establishment” survey of businesses, from which the headline jobs figure that is subject to revisions is derived, suggested a sharp slowdown in recruitment. The “household” survey of individuals, used to calculate the unemployment rate, showed a gain of 1.1m.
Further complicating the picture, the BLS updated its September and October numbers extensively, bringing September’s job gains to 379,000 and October’s to 546,000. Taken together, roughly 6m jobs have been recovered in 2021.
“Everything has been so much larger than it used to be,” said Stephen Crestol, an economist who has spent more than three decades at the BLS. “A big drop and large increases, we are not used to that.”
The task of estimating the payroll numbers during the pandemic has been complicated by two primary factors. First, an increasing share of businesses are turning in their survey responses late.
The agency has had trouble getting businesses to opt into the establishment survey during the pandemic, said Crestol. Participation, which is voluntary in all but three states, has halved since last February.
Even if businesses agree to fill out the survey, their responses may come in after the deadline for the initial estimate in the jobs report, which is released on the first Friday of the month.
For the November report, 65.3 per cent of businesses responded in time, the lowest rate for a November report in more than a decade.
To produce the first figure, the BLS calculates an expected payroll number for businesses that have not yet replied. Late responses are incorporated in subsequent revisions.
“In a normal month, you don’t get that much change in the bottom line,” said Erica Groshen of Cornell University and a former BLS commissioner. But in a year like 2021, marked by an intensely rapid economic recovery, the businesses that are slowest to respond could be recruiting most rapidly, she said, leading to larger upward revisions.
Seasonal adjustment factors have also made gauging job growth an arduous task.
Economists look closely at the “seasonally adjusted” figures, because they are thought to offer the most direct view of ongoing trends once regularly occurring fluctuations in the data tied to events like the start of the school year are stripped out.
Retail businesses in November, for example, reported 331,600 more people on payroll compared with October. But the BLS adjusted that number downward because recruitment in the retail sector tends to pick up just before the start of the holiday season. The agency reported that the sector had “lost” 20,400 jobs after taking into account seasonal adjustment.
In total, the raw numbers showed payroll growth of 778,000 in November, which the BLS adjusted downward by 568,000, a record revision.
“The seasonal patterns are not some kind of law, they are just patterns,” said Betsey Stevenson, a professor of economics at Michigan university and a member of the CEA during the Obama administration. “Covid has done more to disrupt our patterns than anything I could have imagined.”
Seasonal factors are based on the past 10 years of data, with more weight given to recent years. In 2020, many movements were deemed outliers and not included in the adjustment model.
The model is continually tweaked as new data come in, leading to more revisions. “You get more data, then that affects your understanding of past seasonal trends,” said Nick Bunker of Indeed, the jobs website.
How the new coronavirus variant unfolds will determine if the recent waves of revision are set to crest or grow larger from here.
The implications are enormous for the US Federal Reserve, which is closely watching the employment situation for the green light to tighten monetary policy next year.
Christopher Waller, a Fed governor, said the central bank had already supplemented its models with high-frequency data and other sources, including the weekly ADP employment report.
“The more what we see going ahead is just recovering from a recession, then the better the statistical techniques are going to work,” said Groshen. “The more that it’s being driven by a new variant and a different policy response to it . . . the more the models may fail because they’re based on the past.”
buy levaquin 500mg pills levaquin medication
avodart price buy ondansetron 4mg for sale ondansetron online buy
spironolactone 25mg us finasteride 5mg pill order diflucan pills
order generic ampicillin 500mg erythromycin 500mg price order erythromycin generic
order sildenafil without prescription bimatoprost allergy spray purchase methocarbamol generic
suhagra 100mg sale sildenafil overnight delivery purchase estradiol pill
order generic lamotrigine 200mg buy tretinoin generic retin cream tablet
tadalafil 10mg us avanafil for sale cheap voltaren
buy accutane 20mg without prescription amoxicillin 1000mg sale buy azithromycin online cheap
indocin 50mg generic buy amoxicillin online trimox 250mg ca
order cialis 10mg pill Best viagra alternative sildenafil 50mg cheap
order arimidex 1mg online cheap biaxin over the counter buy generic viagra 50mg
prednisone 40mg usa cheapest tadalafil sildenafil 200 mg
tadalafil kaufen ohne rezept tadalafil 20mg kaufen generika viagra 50mg kaufen ohne rezept
oral doxycycline cost furosemide 100mg buy furosemide pill
catapres pill order generic tiotropium bromide 9mcg spiriva cheap
brand buspar 10mg ditropan cost order ditropan 5mg pill
hytrin online order hytrin 1mg without prescription sulfasalazine us
buy fosamax 35mg generic order famotidine 20mg online order generic pepcid 40mg
purchase olmesartan oral calan 240mg buy generic acetazolamide 250mg
order tacrolimus 5mg generic ursodiol 300mg pills order ursodiol 300mg sale
isosorbide over the counter buy lanoxin generic order micardis generic
order zyban 150 mg generic atomoxetine oral quetiapine 50mg pill
molnupiravir 200mg for sale buy omnicef 300mg online cheap cheap lansoprazole
zoloft 100mg usa buy sildenafil online cheap buy viagra without prescription
order salbutamol 100 mcg online order viagra 50mg without prescription oral sildenafil 50mg
how much is cialis how much are viagra pills viagra 100mg brand
tadalafil generic name purchase pyridium pill amantadine pills
naltrexone order online femara 2.5 mg for sale oral abilify 30mg
buy dapsone 100mg for sale dapsone price cost perindopril
cost provera purchase hydrochlorothiazide for sale buy cyproheptadine generic
provigil us order stromectol stromectol nz
fluvoxamine canada cymbalta 40mg usa generic glipizide 5mg
order accutane 20mg pills isotretinoin 20mg cost prednisone 5mg brand
nootropil usa viagra next day delivery viagra price
cost azithromycin zithromax pill buy gabapentin 800mg sale
tadalafil 10mg pill tadalafil 20mg tablet sildenafil pills 200mg
buy lasix 40mg without prescription order lasix for sale hydroxychloroquine drug
order cialis 5mg online cheap buy betnovate 20 gm without prescription buy anafranil 50mg without prescription
cost chloroquine 250mg oral cenforce 100mg buy baricitinib pills
sporanox 100 mg drug order prometrium 200mg for sale tinidazole online
glycomet 500mg oral atorvastatin 20mg drug tadalafil without prescription
order amlodipine 5mg sale sildenafil buy online cialis 5mg without prescription
purchase clozapine for sale dexamethasone 0,5 mg generic decadron oral
female viagra pill sildenafil on line lisinopril generic
buy prilosec 10mg generic free slots casino games real casino games
order zyvox 600 mg online cheap real casino slot machine games roulette online
lopressor 50mg uk levitra online order order levitra 20mg generic
help with term paper online casino for real money free spins no deposit usa
cheap vardenafil medrol 16mg over counter medrol 16mg pills
buy a custom essay my mother essay writing cheap sildenafil 100mg
order clomiphene sale albuterol without prescription real money spins
buy tadalafil 40mg generic buy cialis online buy viagra without prescription
triamcinolone pills clarinex 5mg over the counter order clarinex 5mg generic
buy dapoxetine 30mg online order misoprostol without prescription order levothyroxine without prescription
tadalafil ca buy viagra 100mg order sildenafil 50mg
order orlistat 120mg online purchase zovirax online cheap zovirax 800mg over the counter
generic cialis cost plavix 75mg over the counter order clopidogrel sale
allopurinol 300mg uk order zyloprim 100mg pill buy ezetimibe pill
purchase domperidone for sale tetracycline 500mg generic flexeril 15mg over the counter
buy cozaar 50mg without prescription topiramate 200mg for sale order topamax online
ozobax generic ketorolac over the counter cheap toradol
order sumatriptan without prescription buy levaquin 250mg buy dutasteride sale
buy colchicine 0.5mg online free blackjack games play online roulette for fun
ranitidine cost meloxicam pills order celebrex sale
online gambling games real money casino online best gambling sites
flomax 0.2mg canada order aldactone online order aldactone 25mg online cheap
buy cialis 20mg for sale ampicillin 500mg cost purchase ciprofloxacin sale
buy zocor 20mg generic buy zocor 10mg online proscar canada
purchase metronidazole pill bactrim for sale online trimethoprim pills
brand diflucan 200mg buy viagra 50mg online sildenafil for women
cephalexin 125mg cost cleocin over the counter buy erythromycin 500mg for sale
order cialis 20mg online cheap purchase sildenafil generic purchase viagra sale
viagra usa buy sildenafil for sale tadalafil order
ceftin pills order careprost pill order robaxin 500mg generic
slots free online tadalafil 20mg cost tadalafil 5mg sale
trazodone for sale online buy generic sildenafil buy sildenafil 100mg pill
dissertation assistance letter editing stromectol
sildenafil pills 50mg sildalis medication lamotrigine 50mg canada
prednisone online buy amoxil 500mg canada buy amoxicillin generic
online slots gambling sites order tadalafil online
purchase azithromycin online buy prednisolone 20mg for sale neurontin ca
texas poker online no deposit casino order provigil 200mg
order lasix furosemide 100mg for sale generic plaquenil 200mg
buy fildena 50mg generic order fildena sale order budesonide generic
order retin gel generic retin cream ca order avana 100mg
tadacip 20mg usa order tadalafil pills order indomethacin 75mg pill
terbinafine pills trimox medication order amoxicillin 500mg generic
buy generic clarithromycin 250mg biaxin order online buy meclizine sale
tiotropium bromide oral hytrin drug buy terazosin pill
pioglitazone 15mg brand brand sildenafil 100mg female viagra pill
buy tadalafil 10mg sale casino moons online casino best online casino
The assignment submission period was over and I was nervous, baccarat online and I am very happy to see your post just in time and it was a great help. Thank you ! Leave your blog address below. Please visit me anytime.
blackjack game win real money online casino for free free welcome spins no deposit
poker online game play live poker online casino slots
online casino real money usa do my research paper buy a essay online
purchase doxycycline online albuterol pills cleocin 150mg oral
mesalamine for sale buy astelin sprayers avapro us
order benicar online cheap olmesartan 20mg price buy depakote 250mg pill
order acetazolamide 250 mg sale order imdur 40mg without prescription buy azathioprine 50mg
digoxin 250 mg generic cheap molnunat buy molnupiravir 200 mg generic
order carvedilol 25mg sale buy carvedilol 6.25mg pills buy amitriptyline online cheap
cheap amoxicillin sale amoxil usa stromectole online
buy fosamax generic generic furadantin 100 mg buy motrin 400mg pills
buy priligy pills buy dapoxetine 90mg sale domperidone 10mg pill
purchase nortriptyline online paracetamol 500 mg ca paroxetine us
buy indomethacin sale order tamsulosin 0.2mg pill purchase cenforce generic
famotidine order order pepcid online buy remeron 30mg pills
order doxycycline 200mg generic chloroquine 250mg generic methylprednisolone 16mg over the counter
purchase ropinirole online cheap order requip 2mg online order labetalol generic
buy tadacip 20mg sale amoxicillin 250mg drug order trimox 500mg generic
cost tricor 200mg order viagra online cheap sildenafil 100mg
nexium cheap order generic biaxin 250mg buy generic lasix 40mg
tadalafil 5mg oral Buy real cialis usa pharmacy viagra
order minocycline 50mg online order neurontin online order terazosin online
tadalafil 10mg us Cialis usa buy erectile dysfunction meds
order metformin without prescription verapamil 120mg us cost tamoxifen
order provigil 200mg pill buy promethazine online purchase phenergan pills
order clomiphene generic buy prednisolone 20mg pill prednisolone 10mg us
deltasone cheap buy prednisone 40mg sale amoxil 1000mg brand
cheap isotretinoin 20mg buy accutane 20mg sale ampicillin 250mg us
buy sildenafil 100mg sale order pregabalin without prescription propecia ca
ivermectin 12 mg oral free ed pills deltasone 5mg sale
order zofran 4mg order amoxicillin 1000mg for sale buy bactrim 480mg for sale
isotretinoin 10mg uk absorica pills zithromax over the counter
order ventolin inhalator sale order ventolin pills amoxiclav price
buy prednisolone pill prednisolone 40mg tablet lasix 100mg canada
order modafinil 200mg for sale order metoprolol generic metoprolol 100mg oral