Business is booming.

Is Supporting Family Caregivers Good For The Economy?


The congressional proposal to increase federal funding for Medicaid’s home and community-based (HCBS) long-term care program likely would benefit the US economy, although it could increase costs for those not receiving Medicaid.  

The HCBS expansion is included in the current House version of President Biden’s Build Back Better (BBB) social spending, climate, and tax plan. Sen Joe Manchin (D-WV) and nearly all Hill Republicans claim the roughly $2 trillion proposal would damage the US economy. But independent analysis suggests the home care provisions would produce an overall benefit.

Several elements of BBB—including paid family leave, the Medicaid HCBS expansion, and related provisions—are aimed at helping those receiving long-term services and supports and their families.  

Short and long run benefits

In September, the economic research firm Moody’s Analytics projected the Medicaid home care provision alone would benefit the economy in the short run by increasing pay for direct care workers. In the longer term, it would make it possible for more women who now stay home to care for family members to re-enter the paid workforce.

It concluded, “The elderly and disabled population will receive higher-quality care from better trained and more highly paid direct care workers. Meanwhile, more of those people who now informally care for the elderly and disabled will be able to take other jobs. The economy will receive an immediate boost from this increased government spending along with a lift in long-term growth from higher labor force participation, particularly by lower-income females who are currently most likely to provide home care.”

Other studies have found that a substantial number of working age women either quit jobs or scale back hours to care for parents, spouses, or other family members with care needs.   

Moody’s analyzed a $250 billion boost in federal HCBS spending, lower than Biden’s proposed $400 billion increase but higher than the $150 billion hike currently included in the House’s Build Back Better bill.   

300,000 new jobs

It estimated a $250 billion expansion of Medicaid home care would create up to 300,000 new jobs by 2031 and increase real (inflation-adjusted) Gross Domestic Product (GDP) by about 0.2 percent. Moody’s has not updated its estimate to reflect the $150 billion increase.

When economists look at federal programs—either spending or tax cuts, they think in terms of multipliers. In other words, how much would a dollar of new spending or tax cuts boost GDP. Moody’s concluded that every additional dollar of federal spending on Medicaid HCBS would boost the economy by $1.17.

That return would be comparable to programs such as universal pre-K education and child care. It would be only slightly less beneficial than an expansion of the Child Tax Credit and more beneficial than the multiple rounds of the economic impact checks the government distributed as pandemic relief in 2020 and early 2021. It would be far better for the economy corporate or individual income tax rate cuts.

One downside

While the Moody’s study looked at the overall inflationary effects of more HCBS spending, it did not address one complicating issue: If Medicaid increases pay for home care workers, their wages are also likely to rise for families that are not eligible for Medicaid and must pay out of their own pockets.

Because Medicaid is the primary payer of long-term care, it effectively sets the wage rate in many communities. In other words, private pay home care agencies would have to raise their wages to compete with Medicaid agencies for workers.

That could be especially true today when there are severe shortages of direct care workers. Moody’s analyst Bernard Yaros Jr. told me, “With or without the expansion, private home care costs will rise meaningfully in the near term.”

The burden on non-Medicaid families

Those wage increases benefit underpaid aides but add to the burden of millions of families that pay for care out of pocket.

In August, 2020, the Genworth Cost of Care survey found the average hourly cost of a home care aid was $24 and the average monthly cost was almost $4,600. Aides hired through agencies generally receive about half that amount as wages. Those expenses likely have risen substantially due to the pandemic.

Overall, increasing the federal contribution to Medicaid HCBS would be good for those families who rely on Medicaid to help support frail older adults living at home, good for the workers who help provide that care, and good for the economy. But it may have the unintended consequence of adding to an already challenging burden for middle-income households not on Medicaid.

Source link

  1. Dflhoz says

    levofloxacin 250mg pills oral levofloxacin

  2. Xzfcgo says

    avodart 0.5mg cost purchase zofran pill buy generic ondansetron 4mg

  3. Hszwvk says

    brand aldactone 100mg buy generic aldactone fluconazole 100mg pills

  4. Bajovl says

    ampicillin 500mg tablet cephalexin 250mg pills order generic erythromycin 250mg

  5. Nlrpuu says

    sildenafil 50mg without prescription buy methocarbamol online order robaxin for sale

  6. Pstcfz says

    sildenafil brand estradiol online order buy estrace 1mg generic

  7. Scltmv says

    lamictal ca tretinoin cream over the counter buy retin online

  8. Bednwd says

    tadalis 20mg tablet buy avana 200mg generic order voltaren online

  9. Ncnhhl says

    order isotretinoin 40mg without prescription buy zithromax 250mg zithromax price

  10. Axmxvn says

    buy indomethacin 50mg without prescription lamisil 250mg sale order amoxicillin 500mg generic

  11. Oltzgz says

    buy generic tadalafil 20mg Buy viagra on internet buy sildenafil 50mg generic

  12. Xyfefe says

    tadalafil 10mg pour homme sildenafil 50mg gГ©nГ©rique sildenafil 25mg en ligne

  13. Osenih says

    order deltasone 40mg pill order viagra 100mg viagra mail order usa

  14. Rubjtq says

    tadalafil ohne rezept sildenafil 200mg fГјr frauen sildenafil 200mg kaufen ohne rezept

  15. Sdhdwx says

    doxycycline ca order lasix 40mg generic order furosemide 100mg for sale

  16. Mxiwyp says

    order altace pill buy altace 5mg pill astelin 10ml without prescription

  17. Wzkvic says

    clonidine pill antivert tablet cheap spiriva

  18. Thbfom says

    order buspar pill buy cordarone 100mg ditropan 5mg us

  19. Hbvvbb says

    terazosin 1mg brand order generic sulfasalazine 500 mg buy azulfidine for sale

  20. Uvdvdn says

    order fosamax 70mg generic order pepcid online cheap pepcid 40mg sale

  21. Fchxtm says

    order olmesartan generic divalproex 500mg uk purchase acetazolamide generic

  22. Kmvhth says

    prograf 1mg pills prograf 1mg generic buy ursodiol 150mg pills

  23. Jmfxst says

    purchase imdur generic order azathioprine 25mg pill buy micardis online cheap

  24. Lgbzke says

    purchase bupropion generic order strattera 25mg pill purchase seroquel without prescription

  25. Dodnpm says

    molnunat over the counter buy prevacid 30mg online generic lansoprazole 15mg

  26. Evjtif says

    brand sertraline 100mg sertraline over the counter sildenafil mail order usa

  27. Nshxqi says

    buy salbutamol 100mcg online imuran 100 mcg over the counter order viagra 100mg online cheap

  28. Cjgazv says

    tadalafil online purchase fluoxetine online cheap order generic viagra

  29. Otfqzg says

    buy tadalafil 10mg phenazopyridine online order order amantadine online cheap

  30. Ywwark says

    buy revia order albenza generic purchase abilify

  31. Vjetvh says

    dapsone 100 mg uk buy avlosulfon 100 mg pill aceon 4mg sale

  32. Kkaomu says

    purchase provigil generic buy provigil for sale ivermectin iv

  33. Lsybwi says

    fluvoxamine 50mg generic ketoconazole 200mg price buy glucotrol generic

  34. Wenkua says

    purchase accutane without prescription order generic accutane buy prednisone online cheap

  35. Dhzdae says

    buy nootropil 800mg for sale piracetam for sale viagra 50mg drug

  36. Ypeoai says

    azithromycin pill buy prednisolone 20mg sale generic neurontin 100mg

  37. Ijlhnx says

    cheap tadalafil generic tadalafil cialis us viagra sales

  38. Qqptaj says

    lasix 40mg without prescription oral doxycycline 100mg buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg pill

  39. Qoezdj says

    tadalafil 5mg order betamethasone 20gm online order anafranil 25mg pills

  40. Katilt says

    buy chloroquine pills baricitinib price baricitinib buy online

  41. Etlyit says

    sporanox cost purchase prometrium for sale tindamax price

  42. Bfuesx says

    glycomet over the counter brand lipitor 40mg tadalafil 10mg for sale

  43. Ievkbm says

    olanzapine 10mg pills buy bystolic without prescription valsartan 80mg pill

  44. Qyreuv says

    norvasc 10mg brand amlodipine buy online cialis 10mg us

  45. Lhohwf says

    order clozaril generic buy combivent 100mcg for sale order dexamethasone

  46. Xatasr says

    buy viagra 100mg pill lisinopril 10mg pills lisinopril 10mg pill

  47. Xlaefo says

    zyvox 600mg canada order zyvox 600mg without prescription free casino

  48. Crgllc says

    omeprazole 10mg ca real casino casino card games

  49. Oxewxw says

    order metoprolol for sale buy generic metoprolol order levitra 20mg

  50. Vwsbxd says

    academic writing services uk poker online game real money casino games

  51. Uvvoxd says

    buy vardenafil 20mg online buy pregabalin generic medrol 8mg over counter

  52. mahmutlar escort says

    I’m often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your web site and maintain checking for brand spanking new information.

  53. Ttfzuu says

    help writing papers buy an essay paper sildenafil 100mg usa

  54. Qdwwsd says

    generic cialis 40mg cost cialis 20mg cheap viagra sale

  55. Dblqaa says

    order triamcinolone pills purchase loratadine order clarinex 5mg generic

  56. Anubon says

    dapoxetine price buy levothyroxine generic synthroid 100mcg pill

  57. Yigkau says

    tadalafil oral buy viagra 50mg pills brand viagra

  58. Sdvtzh says

    brand xenical 60mg buy xenical 120mg generic order acyclovir sale

  59. Latrtg says

    buy tadalafil online cheap order plavix sale clopidogrel 150mg usa

  60. Ckqflc says

    allopurinol ca crestor 20mg price buy zetia generic

  61. Xaghis says

    methotrexate 5mg tablet order warfarin online cheap buy metoclopramide 20mg

  62. Qrzucl says

    purchase motilium for sale buy motilium pill order generic flexeril

  63. Nnslzh says

    order generic losartan 25mg order topiramate sale purchase topiramate pills

  64. Pugqcc says

    ozobax buy online order tizanidine 2mg generic buy ketorolac without prescription

  65. Fzapqc says

    buy sumatriptan pill order levaquin 250mg without prescription avodart ca

  66. Isiwmu says

    buy gloperba without prescription buy colchicine sale play poker online real money

  67. Fchgad says

    ranitidine 300mg usa order meloxicam 15mg celecoxib uk

  68. Tzjkbv says

    slot games free slots online free spins no deposit uk

  69. Fkaqgk says

    buy generic flomax purchase spironolactone without prescription buy aldactone sale

  70. Wukdet says

    brand cialis 10mg brand tadalafil 40mg ciprofloxacin usa

  71. Rbozpr says

    zocor 20mg oral simvastatin 20mg ca propecia 1mg generic

  72. Eavgux says

    brand metronidazole 400mg purchase metronidazole pills buy bactrim 480mg generic

  73. Zyieqh says

    brand diflucan 200mg diflucan 200mg us buy viagra generic

  74. Zpeiqy says

    cephalexin 125mg without prescription buy cleocin 300mg online cheap buy erythromycin pill

  75. Yljlds says

    cialis canada tadalafil 20mg pill sildenafil cost

  76. Xqhfxe says

    real viagra pharmacy prescription cheap tadalafil 40mg cialis 10mg pills

  77. Ombrio says

    buy ceftin 250mg robaxin online robaxin 500mg ca

  78. Yxiqwf says

    online slots real money usa order cialis 5mg sale cialis 10mg oral

  79. Wiwojf says

    desyrel for sale buy sildenafil 50mg pill aurogra 100mg brand

  80. Oorzpa says

    buy custom research papers buy a essay online stromectol where to buy

  81. Opzubm says

    sildenafil 100mg usa order lamotrigine 50mg order lamotrigine sale

  82. Kkyayq says

    viagra 100 mg purchase sildenafil online cheap buy cialis 20mg generic

  83. Gphpdx says

    brand zithromax oral azithromycin oral gabapentin

  84. Pvpvvv says

    online casino bonus online slot games cialis mail order usa

  85. Zxfqmq says

    free casino games no registration no download casinos buy provigil 100mg without prescription

  86. Yzjvbv says

    buy furosemide 100mg plaquenil 400mg us hydroxychloroquine 200mg drug

  87. Inouwp says

    order deltasone 5mg online prednisone pills mebendazole order

  88. Nfvqqk says

    sildenafil 100mg for sale generic fildena 100mg buy rhinocort generic

  89. Xfkmuz says

    oral tretinoin gel buy avanafil order avanafil 100mg sale

  90. Bmlvxc says

    tadacip 20mg cost order indocin 50mg without prescription cheap indocin 50mg

  91. Vdibur says

    terbinafine generic cheap terbinafine 250mg order generic trimox 250mg

  92. Roneuk says

    buy biaxin 500mg pills buy clonidine 0.1 mg generic meclizine 25mg for sale

  93. Crxbkj says

    naprosyn pills omnicef drug prevacid 15mg for sale

  94. Igjtde says

    cost proventil 100mcg protonix brand buy ciprofloxacin 1000mg sale

  95. Ekcwrt says

    buy pioglitazone 15mg without prescription sildenafil 50mg cheap sildenafil 50mg

  96. Hltctf says

    singulair pills sildenafil overnight buy viagra 100mg pill

  97. Nrpoli says

    how much is cialis Cialis for sale free roulette online

  98. Mhbgxp says

    cialis otc Cialis pharmacy online cialis coupon

  99. Dbwwkb says

    ivermectin side effects stromectol cost avlosulfon 100 mg usa

  100. Krwagj says

    playing poker online for money online money poker gambling games

  101. Byjbqw says

    free blackjack online play roulette my favorite writer essay

  102. Ndoulp says

    generic nifedipine 10mg nifedipine canada order fexofenadine 120mg without prescription

  103. Svvwau says

    altace without prescription glimepiride 1mg price arcoxia oral

  104. Sdfgli says

    essays done for you pay to do my assignment sulfasalazine order online

  105. Qmiobe says

    doxycycline us albuterol 2mg canada buy cleocin online cheap

  106. Jjgxmu says

    olmesartan over the counter order calan 120mg pill order depakote 250mg pills

  107. Gywrzs says

    order asacol generic asacol 800mg brand generic irbesartan 300mg

  108. Uokzhl says

    purchase diamox isosorbide medication imuran 50mg without prescription

  109. Iikabr says

    order generic lanoxin 250mg generic telmisartan molnunat uk

  110. Quesbc says

    order amoxil 1000mg generic order generic stromectol 6mg ivermectin for sale

  111. Zdpufi says

    buy priligy 60mg sale order avanafil 200mg generic oral domperidone

  112. Mxgmqf says

    alendronate 70mg for sale order motrin generic order ibuprofen 400mg generic

  113. Vyluiy says

    indocin for sale indomethacin 50mg generic buy cenforce 50mg without prescription

  114. Wquozh says

    order pamelor sale order paracetamol 500 mg generic paxil 20mg us

  115. Maotyg says

    buy doxycycline 200mg online cheap doxycycline medication medrol otc

  116. Nkgvmn says

    brand tadalafil 20mg clopidogrel pills purchase trimox sale

  117. Qbdhuh says

    order generic ropinirole 2mg order trandate 100mg without prescription trandate us

  118. Ohabqu says

    nexium 20mg canada buy clarithromycin 500mg online cheap lasix canada

  119. Lhdfem says

    order tricor online order tricor 200mg online cheap oral viagra 50mg

  120. Wivcio says

    buy minocin 50mg purchase neurontin pill buy hytrin 5mg generic

  121. Xhbbhm says

    buy tadalafil online cheap sildenafil dosage sildenafil 100mg usa

  122. Pdlzma says

    order cialis 40mg sale Cialis store ed remedies

  123. Ywcqlu says

    glucophage price purchase nolvadex for sale cost tamoxifen 20mg

  124. Fywdps says

    cost clomid 100mg order generic clomid 50mg buy generic prednisolone 40mg

  125. Egxxan says

    deltasone 5mg us amoxicillin 250mg generic amoxicillin 250mg ca

  126. Matjix says

    brand sildenafil 50mg finasteride price propecia oral

  127. Lqujxj says

    ivermectin 12 mg stromectol for humans brand prednisone 20mg

  128. Jakcfv says

    buy ondansetron 8mg bactrim 960mg ca sulfamethoxazole pills

  129. Cszowv says

    generic accutane order isotretinoin generic buy azithromycin 250mg generic

  130. Brxjbn says

    ventolin 2mg sale buy levothyroxine tablets cost augmentin 375mg

  131. Jgehfa says

    generic prednisolone 5mg furosemide tablet furosemide 100mg sale

  132. Rhhgod says

    modafinil cheap order modafinil online how to get lopressor without a prescription

  133. Mbrcvu says

    doxycycline online order purchase doxycycline pill buy acyclovir 800mg online

  134. Klgbil says

    purchase dutasteride order keflex 125mg pills buy orlistat generic

  135. Brsupy says

    buy imuran 25mg generic telmisartan online order order naproxen 500mg online cheap

  136. Tieenf says

    oxybutynin sale purchase oxcarbazepine pill buy trileptal 600mg online

  137. Bddofz says

    order cefdinir 300 mg pill buy omnicef for sale buy protonix 40mg for sale

  138. Eqapga says

    zocor 20mg usa sildenafil without a doctor’s prescription purchase sildalis

  139. Ufrsrd says

    order dapsone generic buy dapsone 100 mg generic order generic tenormin

  140. Iqehxr says

    order uroxatral 10mg generic order diltiazem for sale order diltiazem for sale

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.