It was a classic example of the old David versus Goliath story. This past June, small hedge fund/activist investor Engine No. 1 went up against the big oil company Exxon Mobil, and won three board seats after a months-long proxy battle. Later that month, the firm took its activist approach to a broader swath of companies, with the launch of the Engine No. 1 Transform 500 ETF (VOTE).
The firm launched the fund in June with $100 million in early capital from a multi-family office as well as a partnership with Betterment to integrate VOTE into all of its socially responsible investing strategies. The fund charges 5 basis points, and now has a total $256 million in assets.
More ETFs are in the works. The firm has filed for an active climate change-focused ETF.
And last January, Engine No. 1 brought on Yasmin Bilger, a former head of U.S. product specialist teams at J.P. Morgan Asset Management, as head of ETFs. Bilger recently chatted with WealthManagement.com about what’s next for the ETF business, how her firm hopes to change impact investing, and what’s holding advisors back from sustainable investing.
WealthManagement.com: What is Engine No. 1, and what is the firm’s investment philosophy?
Yasmin Bilger: At the firm level, the way we describe ourselves is first and foremost an investment firm. Our focus is tying environmental and social issues to economic outcomes. We were founded on a shared belief that the investments that a company makes in its employees, in its customers, in the community that it operates in, and the environment and are actually directly linked to its ability to create long-term shareholder value. A lot of the conversation in this space is centered around the ideology and morality of sustainability. And we are very much focused instead on the economic argument for specific environment and social issues.
When we’re analyzing a company, we think not only about traditional financial metrics, but also think about the positive and negative impacts that a company is having on things like an environment and social issues. Quite literally, the carbon they emit and the value associated with that, or the wages they’re paying their employees. We use all of that to come up with what we think is a true value for a firm. And that really informs what companies we invest in, and where we do our engagements.
Our active ownership approach is more like a private equity business than it is from what we’ve seen from traditional asset managers. We’re really focused on much more deep and focused engagements where we’re trying to have specific impacts and specific recommendations.
WM: How is VOTE different from other ESG ETFs out there?
YB: Most of what’s out there in the market in sustainable ETFs are funds that either do one of two things: They either exclude certain sectors or companies, or they re-weight, so they use some sort of ranking mechanism to lean into the companies that rank highly on some set of ESG metrics, and lean away from companies that rank poorly. They’re ESG by what they own. We see ourselves as ESG by what we do. The VOTE ETF itself does not re-weight or exclude. It really is just the largest 500 companies as defined by Morningstar’s index. And really that is intentional. We wanted to design a product that fit the investing framework of how the majority of the market invests. If you look at the top three largest ETFs in the U.S. ETF market, they’re over $1 trillion in assets, and they’re all market-cap weighted ETFs.
On the investing side, VOTE should actually intentionally look very similar to what most people have in their portfolios. What’s different is the active ownership side. Our voting policy looks in effect very differently from what you’d see from other asset managers out there. What we’ve tended to see historically from some of the larger asset managers is that they’ve historically voted against environmental and social shareholder proposals.
We can actually backtest how we would’ve voted before we launched in June. And if you look at that backtest, it would have a much higher support for those type of issues, to the tune of 65% to 85%.
On top of it, our engagement strategy is very different than traditional asset managers. You tend to find that traditional asset managers put out an impact report at the end of the year that talks about the number of companies they were engaged with and all the topics that were talked about, almost like a quantity focused exercise
Our goal is very specifically not to engage with all 500 companies with our portfolio. It’s to find the areas where we can be focused, have the most impact, and tie it back to shareholder value. What we would do is deeper engagements and fewer engagements.
WM: What would be the value in investing in your ETF versus another ETF tracked to the same index? Don’t all the investors in the S&P 500 or any market-cap weighted index benefit from the work you’re doing?
YB: We actually hope to be the tip of the spear on many of these topics. We think our size—allows us to do things that larger managers can’t do. We hope to bring people along. The case of Exxon is the best example of that. We would have definitionally never been successful if we weren’t able to convince other shareholders to join us. So we don’t see a problem with the shared benefit.
WM: What’s next for the ETF group?
YB: We built the platform really with the principle of long-term and scale and plan to launch more than one ETF. What we have next is a climate fund, so active equity. Think alpha and impact. It’s based on the linkage between environmental and social issues and long-term shareholder value. We’re also conceptualizing a suite of more active equity thematic strategies.
VOTE is very simple on the investing side—it’s just a market-cap weighted index that we track. It’s Morningstar’s version of the largest 500 companies. And where we’re really different is the active ownership work that we’re doing—the way we vote our shares, and the campaigns and engagements that we run. I say all that because that whole product line could be extended to other exposures—to the extent we actually found investors who were interested in helping us catalyze another version of VOTE.
WM: How will your active thematic ESG funds differ from others out there?
YB: There are a lot of climate ETFs out there that have two flavors to me. The first category are low tracking error [ETFs], that own most of the index and tweak a little bit what they own. That to me is not at all what we’re doing. We’re not passive; we’re a much more concentrated portfolio. That is because we’re active in nature. There are also thematic climate funds, which are concentrated and in some cases, active. But what you tend to find is that most of them are focused on green [investments]—for example, solar energy. If I think of the brand of Engine No. 1, frankly it’s in our name—we are leaning into the problem, not running away from it. A lot of what we are focused on is this idea of moving companies from brown to green, and for us that is really where the investing opportunity lies and where we think you can have the greatest impact.
WM: What other market-cap exposures will you consider for applying the VOTE concept?
YB: VOTE is really about keeping the investment side the way investors normally invest—as similar as possible to what people have and adding value through our active ownership work. We started with the largest 500 companies in the U.S. because that’s where the majority of people’s assets are today. But as we all know, there are a lot of other market cap exposures that are out there. A natural extension of that product line would be to continue to fill out where the largest buckets are of market cap investments. For example, we could consider a small-cap, a mid-cap, a total market.
WM: How do you think Engine No. 1 will impact the ETF industry?
YB: The ETF industry is now over $7 trillion. It’s a large market. If you look at the sustainable ETFs out there, they are growing, but are still a very small percentage of the overall total market. And my hope is that we can be considered the go-to provider for impact-focused ETFs, and I think the fact that we’re small and purpose-built is actually a huge strength of ours in doing so.
I think VOTE is actually, more specifically, really quite innovative in the context of the ETF market. For the most part, a lot of what investors face when it comes to sustainable ETFs is this worry around a trade-off on performance. I think VOTE really solves that in many ways for investors.
WM: There’s a big gap in the market in terms of financial advisors’ use of and education on sustainable and impact investing strategies. Why do you think that is?
YB: I spent a lot of time talking to financial advisors across various channels, of different sizes. And there are a few interesting insights I feel I’ve learned around what may be holding back the sustainable investing space. The first is that performance trade-off. I think there is a worry or hesitation by the financial advisor that if they try to put into the client portfolios a product that introduces tracking error that it creates noise in their client conversations, particularly products that don’t have a strong thesis for why the sustainability angle should outperform over time. I think that’s one really big key gap that the market has to solve for; I hoping we’re solving for it with VOTE.
The second is around this confusion of the language itself. I think the ESG metrics space has become very confusing for many advisors and investors. If you look at the various ESG ratings agencies out there, what you find is that there’s very a lack in correlation in how they’re actually measuring companies. You can find cases where companies are ranked very highly in one scoring system and very poorly by another. I think that creates a lot of confusion.
Lastly, I think advisors are struggling right now to bring to life the “so-what” of investing in the sustainable space. We like to call it the “theory of change”—what’s different about the world if an investor were to move money from their current fund to a fund focused on sustainability. I think it’s incumbent on us as an industry to bring this to life to end investors through specific stories that can make it relatable.
WM: How have advisors reacted to the VOTE ETF?
YB: The growth we’ve seen since we launched in June has really been from a variety of retail investors, financial advisors and institutional asset allocators. Particularly with advisors though, in our conversations, I do think that given some of those challenges that exist for the sustainable investing space, VOTE has actually helped to solve a number of them. Because it’s a market-cap exposure, it has minimized the challenge around typical tracking error performance differentials. It’s priced at 5 basis points, so from a cost perspective, it’s very similar to a market-cap ETF that they already have in their portfolios. We’re really focused on how we’re voting our shares and the campaigns and engagements we’re running, which really helps to give advisors some specific examples around the work that Engine No. 1 is doing from an active ownership angle to drive change.
Editor’s note: The conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
order levofloxacin 500mg without prescription levaquin 500mg canada
Remarkable issues here. I’m very happy to look your post.
Thanks a lot and I’m looking ahead to contact you. Will you please drop
me a e-mail?
essays writing cash poker online online casinos for usa players
purchase motilium generic order tetracycline 500mg online cheap buy flexeril generic
order lamisil without prescription terbinafine cheap trimox 500mg ca
naproxen 500mg uk buy omnicef sale prevacid 30mg usa
buy clarithromycin 500mg generic antivert 25 mg for sale buy generic antivert 25mg
buy albuterol 100mcg online cheap cheap ciprofloxacin 1000mg order ciprofloxacin 500mg without prescription
order spiriva 9mcg pill tiotropium bromide 9mcg generic order terazosin 5mg without prescription
order singulair 5mg generic viagra pills 150mg order viagra for sale
purchase actos pills order sildenafil 100mg pills viagra 100mg price
cost tadalafil cialis 20mg pills buy cialis 40mg online cheap
order cialis for sale Buy cheap generic cialis casino play
online gambling world poker online real money casino
buy nifedipine 10mg for sale aceon 8mg pill allegra uk
sugarhouse casino online online blackjack with real money free spins
online gambling games online pharmacy non prescription drugs thesis writers
doxycycline 100mg pill buy generic albuterol buy cleocin 300mg sale
research paper editing order arava 20mg sale buy azulfidine 500mg online cheap
order mesalamine 800mg pills mesalamine sale order irbesartan 150mg pill
temovate over the counter buy temovate amiodarone uk
generic benicar calan 120mg for sale divalproex 250mg pill
buy diamox 250 mg online purchase imdur pills buy azathioprine online cheap
lanoxin 250 mg canada buy molnunat 200mg sale order molnunat 200mg sale
order amoxil pills buy stromectol 12mg pills stromectol covid
buy coreg 6.25mg for sale purchase ditropan generic buy elavil 10mg for sale
priligy 30mg ca order motilium 10mg online cheap purchase domperidone without prescription
indocin 75mg capsule purchase indocin for sale buy cenforce 100mg without prescription
pamelor 25 mg over the counter generic pamelor 25 mg paroxetine 10mg oral
cost doxycycline 100mg order aralen 250mg online methylprednisolone 16mg for sale
buy generic famotidine order prograf generic order mirtazapine 30mg generic
tadacip 10mg without prescription buy trimox 250mg generic order trimox 500mg online
ropinirole 1mg sale order requip 1mg sale labetalol over the counter
purchase nexium without prescription furosemide over the counter cost lasix
tricor 200mg over the counter cheap sildenafil tablets viagra overnight shipping usa
buy minocin generic brand minocin terazosin oral
cialis 10mg tablet brand viagra 50mg sildenafil brand
buy generic cialis 20mg Cialis canadian cost buy erectile dysfunction medications
buy generic glucophage order tamoxifen 20mg pill buy tamoxifen 10mg generic
provigil 100mg price promethazine 25mg us buy generic promethazine
order clomid clomid 50mg without prescription purchase prednisolone online
generic prednisone 5mg accutane 10mg cheap purchase amoxil generic
natural ed pills cheap fildena 100mg finasteride 5mg usa
ivermectin 6 mg tablets for humans buy deltasone 40mg online cost prednisone 40mg
buy zofran 8mg sale zofran ca buy sulfamethoxazole without prescription
accutane medication purchase zithromax online cheap azithromycin order
strongest over the counter asthma buy synthroid 100mcg without prescription order generic amoxiclav
oral prednisolone 10mg buy generic lasix 40mg lasix 40mg over the counter
provigil 200mg for sale modafinil us buy lopressor paypal
buy doxycycline 100mg online cheap purchase vibra-tabs cost zovirax
order avodart online order dutasteride pills buy xenical 60mg generic
buy imuran 50mg pill micardis pills naprosyn order online
ditropan 2.5mg canada trileptal 600mg cost oxcarbazepine 300mg over the counter
cefdinir 300 mg canada omnicef 300 mg sale pantoprazole buy online
simvastatin over the counter cheap simvastatin 20mg sildenafil for men over 50
dapsone over the counter order generic mesalamine buy tenormin generic
alfuzosin pills order desyrel 100mg pill diltiazem over the counter
levitra or viagra cialis now cialis 5mg pills
ezetimibe 10mg us order generic methotrexate methotrexate 5mg usa
generic phenergan phenergan medication cheap tadalafil 40mg
oral coumadin 5mg purchase reglan without prescription order generic allopurinol 100mg
buy levaquin 250mg online buy levofloxacin pills buy bupropion without prescription
order zyrtec 10mg pills brand strattera 10mg order zoloft 50mg pills
buy cenforce sale metformin buy online buy generic metformin 1000mg
lexapro oral oral escitalopram 20mg buy naltrexone generic
order generic atorvastatin 80mg viagra for sale viagra 25 mg
buy letrozole 2.5 mg online cheap viagra 100mg for sale buy viagra 100mg sale
buy tadalafil 10mg best price cialis causes of erectile dysfunction
order tadalafil 20mg online cheap purchase cialis free samples of ed pills
buy stromectol 12mg brand accutane 40mg isotretinoin 40mg cost
order amoxicillin sale buy amoxicillin 1000mg prednisolone 20mg ca
oral accutane 40mg brand accutane cheap zithromax 250mg
purchase neurontin for sale order monodox generic order doxycycline online cheap
prednisolone 5mg without prescription neurontin 100mg sale lasix 40mg drug
order clomid 100mg generic vardenafil medication purchase plaquenil online
doxycycline 200mg cost oral amoxiclav augmentin price
synthroid 75mcg canada levoxyl without prescription buy vardenafil 10mg for sale
albendazole oral provera 10mg over the counter order provera 5mg without prescription
order glucophage 500mg generic amlodipine online buy norvasc 10mg for sale
order generic praziquantel buy generic biltricide cyproheptadine 4 mg without prescription
cost prinivil buy prilosec 20mg online buy cheap generic lopressor
pregabalin where to buy buy claritin cheap order dapoxetine 30mg online cheap
buy methotrexate 10mg generic coumadin pill metoclopramide 20mg drug
buy cheap orlistat buy zovirax no prescription order zyloprim 300mg
cozaar 25mg canada order topiramate pills topiramate 100mg pills
crestor cost buy domperidone pill domperidone oral
buy imitrex sale oral avodart order dutasteride online
tetracycline 250mg cheap where to buy flexeril without a prescription how to buy baclofen
buy toradol generic buy cheap generic toradol inderal usa
buy clopidogrel 150mg for sale ketoconazole online buy buy ketoconazole 200 mg online cheap
flomax 0.4mg pills buy flomax online spironolactone 100mg drug
generic duloxetine 20mg duloxetine over the counter buy nootropil 800mg
betamethasone 20 gm without prescription itraconazole 100 mg without prescription buy itraconazole 100 mg generic
buy prometrium 100mg generic purchase olanzapine generic purchase olanzapine sale
order bystolic 5mg for sale buy valsartan 80mg generic buy clozaril 100mg generic
simvastatin 10mg sale simvastatin 10mg usa sildenafil 25mg
how to get carbamazepine without a prescription order lincocin online cheap order lincomycin 500 mg generic
cialis tablet order tadalafil generic sildenafil pills 50mg
estrace 2mg brand order lamictal 200mg generic prazosin online
vermox 100mg without prescription tretinoin ca tadalafil 20mg price
Системы охлаждения и вентиляции. официальный дилер ballu, настенно-потолочные кондицонеры.
purchase trimox where can i buy clarithromycin order biaxin 500mg online
suhagra generic order aurogra 100mg generic sildenafil 50mg
buy clonidine 0.1 mg sale order clonidine 0.1 mg sale tiotropium bromide ca
minocin 50mg uk minocin 100mg generic buy actos 30mg generic
buy arava 20mg online order arava generic buy azulfidine cheap
buy absorica pills cost azithromycin 500mg order zithromax 500mg without prescription
oral tadalafil 5mg order cialis 20mg online us pharmacy cialis
buy azipro 250mg online omnacortil 5mg for sale buy gabapentin 800mg without prescription
ivermectin 3mg tabs order stromectol 3mg generic deltasone 10mg sale
buy furosemide generic asthma pills over the counter buy generic albuterol 4mg
order levitra pill generic vardenafil 20mg buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg online
order altace 5mg sale buy etoricoxib for sale etoricoxib 120mg pills
buy cheap vardenafil buy plaquenil pills cost plaquenil 400mg
cheap asacol 400mg brand astelin buy generic avapro 300mg
olmesartan pills buy calan 120mg pills order depakote 500mg pills
purchase clobetasol online cheap how to buy amiodarone purchase cordarone sale