Earlier this year, Germany’s Bayerische Landesbank quietly decided it did not want to do business with defence companies any more.
“BayernLB has not announced it to the public yet,” a bank spokesman told me this week. “We are fading out business relationships with companies . . . [having] above 20 per cent turnover in defence.”
The decision has sent shivers through Europe’s defence industry. Bavaria is, after all, home to some of Germany’s biggest defence companies such as Airbus Defence and Space and Hensoldt. If Bavaria’s state-controlled bank believes defence is too controversial to deal with, why should private sector banks step in?
Now a bigger threat is coming, this time from Brussels where a discussion is under way about what constitutes socially sustainable finance.
Europe’s classification system for green investment — known as the environmental taxonomy — will soon be published. But officials are already working on a “social taxonomy” to define which activities contribute positively to society, those that do no significant harm, and those that are harmful.
In draft proposals presented this year, the defence industry was grouped with gambling and tobacco as harmful and, so, potentially not socially sustainable. The draft moots limiting the label “harmful” to activities banned by international treaties, such as chemical or biological weapons. But the language remains unclear.
Another proposal suggests barring companies from qualifying for an eco-kitemark to be used for retail financial products, if more than five per cent of turnover comes “from the production or trade of conventional weapons and/or military products used for combat”. This time there is no qualification about controversial activities.
Not surprisingly, Europe’s defence industry is raising the alarm. ASD, the European defence industry’s trade association, has written to the commission to warn that these proposals could undermine the bloc’s security by restricting defence companies’ ability to secure finance and so to invest.
“It is a problem if we are defined as not socially viable,” said ASD president Alessandro Profumo, who is also chief executive of Italy’s defence champion Leonardo. “Without security we cannot have a sustainable society.”
Already the proposals are having an impact. Jan Pie, ASD secretary-general, cites examples of banks cutting ties with defence companies in Germany, Finland, Belgium, the Netherlands and Sweden. One Belgian group has even had to pay employees from non-EU bank accounts, he says.
Germany’s defence industry trade body has found that more than a third of members face urgent issues with banks, such as refusal to provide standard services or export insurance.
The pain is being felt most acutely by smaller companies, crucial to the supply chain and innovation, says Profumo. But the proposal also risks deterring civil companies, which provide increasingly important technology to defence projects.
There are good reasons to be critical of the defence industry. Transparency International has found that just 12 per cent of the world’s top 134 defence companies show a high level of commitment to fighting corruption. But there are many international treaties defining legitimate trade in conventional weapons and Europe’s defence industry is still crucial to the bloc’s security.
European politicians including Commission president Ursula von der Leyen have recently stressed the need for a strong defence industry in the face of growing global threats.
There is an incoherence in defining defence companies as “socially harmful” if they are at the same time vital to the EU’s peace and stability. Defence is not the same as tobacco and gambling, where it is difficult to see any wider social good.
Some may not like defence, according to consultant Francis Tusa of Defence Analysis, “but then they have to do a better job of explaining how we would work without it”.
The commission should think carefully about the consequences of indiscriminately labelling the sector as unsustainable. Making it more difficult for law-abiding companies to raise finance will either force governments to shoulder more expense, or buy more from abroad — where Europe will have even less control over behaviour.
Of course weapons are harmful. But they are even more harmful if those who threaten you have them and you do not.
peggy.hollinger@ft.com
levaquin tablet order levofloxacin 500mg generic
order avodart flomax 0.4mg pills buy ondansetron for sale
spironolactone 100mg brand valacyclovir over the counter order fluconazole pills
acillin brand acillin without prescription erythromycin 250mg uk
sildenafil 100mg oral purchase bimatoprost pill buy methocarbamol online cheap
sildenafil pill sildenafil fast shipping estrace over the counter
lamictal 50mg tablet mebendazole 100mg usa retin usa
tadalafil 20mg drug tadacip 10mg sale order diclofenac generic
isotretinoin oral isotretinoin 40mg us purchase zithromax pill
buy indocin generic amoxicillin 500mg brand trimox 250mg pill
cheap cialis without prescription Viagra mail order usa purchase viagra online
order arimidex 1mg online cheap buy anastrozole pills generic viagra 100mg
tadalafil 10mg comprimГ© sildenafil 100mg generique pas cher viagra generique pas cher
deltasone 20mg drug order prednisone 10mg generic brand viagra 50mg
cialis 20mg generika sildenafil 200mg kaufen ohne rezept viagra 50mg generika rezeptfrei kaufen
buy isotretinoin generic order stromectol 12mg sale ivermectin 6
cost altace 10mg purchase astelin order generic azelastine 10 ml
order buspar 5mg online buspirone 10mg tablet oxybutynin 2.5mg ca
buy generic terazosin buy arava 20mg online azulfidine 500mg usa
order fosamax sale buy paracetamol pill order famotidine 40mg pill
olmesartan sale purchase divalproex generic buy diamox 250 mg pill
buy generic tacrolimus 5mg labetalol 100mg uk urso oral
generic imdur 40mg micardis 80mg us telmisartan cheap
zyban 150mg usa oral seroquel 100mg seroquel 100mg generic
order molnunat without prescription molnupiravir over the counter buy prevacid 15mg online cheap
sertraline oral sildenafil pills viagra generic
purchase imuran pantoprazole 40mg usa order sildenafil 50mg generic
order cialis 40mg for sale brand cialis 10mg oral viagra 100mg
cheap cialis generic order symmetrel online amantadine pill
buy naltrexone pills albenza pills abilify price
dapsone 100 mg drug cheap perindopril order aceon 4mg online cheap
order medroxyprogesterone 10mg online purchase hydrochlorothiazide generic cyproheptadine online buy
purchase modafinil pill legitimate canadian pharmacy online buy ivermectin canada
purchase luvox pill ketoconazole 200mg over the counter glucotrol 5mg us
isotretinoin pill order accutane without prescription order prednisone 10mg without prescription
buy nootropil 800mg online cheap cost nootropil 800mg viagra 100mg drug
buy azithromycin 500mg order generic neurontin gabapentin oral
cialis tadalafil 40mg usa cialis sales order generic viagra 100mg
furosemide 100mg ca hydroxychloroquine sale hydroxychloroquine 400mg cheap
cheap cialis 5mg betnovate 20 gm cost buy anafranil 25mg pills
buy chloroquine 250mg generic chloroquine uk olumiant 2mg drug
buy glycomet 500mg without prescription purchase cialis sale tadalafil 5mg us
olanzapine 10mg tablet nebivolol oral order diovan 160mg online
purchase norvasc generic cialis canada brand tadalafil 5mg
clozaril 100mg brand purchase clozapine generic order dexamethasone 0,0,5 mg sale
buy sildenafil 100mg sale viagra overnight shipping usa lisinopril 5mg tablet
linezolid over the counter slot machines blackjack card game
order prilosec online brand prilosec 20mg blackjack game
oral metoprolol 100mg levitra 10mg for sale order levitra generic
pay for research papers doubleu casino online casino free slot play
levitra 20mg brand levitra for sale methylprednisolone 4 mg pills
purchase clomiphene without prescription real money casino games online slots
tadalafil 40mg cost buy viagra 100mg sale order sildenafil 100mg without prescription
triamcinolone 10mg oral order aristocort online buy desloratadine generic
dapoxetine online buy generic levothyroxine purchase levothyroxine generic
usa pharmacy cialis sildenafil cheap order sildenafil 100mg for sale
order orlistat without prescription purchase diltiazem pills buy zovirax 800mg generic
order tadalafil 5mg for sale buy tadalafil 40mg pill plavix brand
order zyloprim 100mg pill generic zyloprim order ezetimibe 10mg for sale
order methotrexate 5mg for sale order reglan online reglan 10mg us
domperidone for sale online order flexeril 15mg pills purchase cyclobenzaprine without prescription
baclofen 10mg pills toradol sale purchase toradol online
imitrex 50mg cheap buy generic sumatriptan order generic dutasteride
order colchicine 0.5mg pill slot online best real casino online
ranitidine 150mg pills order ranitidine 300mg order celecoxib pills
blackjack poker online big fish casino online online slots for real money
flomax oral flomax canada generic aldactone
buy generic cialis 10mg cialis 5mg pills cipro 500mg drug
purchase zocor sale propecia 1mg us finasteride 5mg tablet
order generic flagyl augmentin over the counter order bactrim 960mg generic
diflucan price sildenafil overnight shipping usa sildenafil 100mg usa
buy cephalexin 250mg sale buy cleocin 300mg pills erythromycin 500mg uk
cialis online buy order tadalafil 40mg generic purchase viagra pills
order sildenafil 50mg online cheap buy cialis 20mg cheap cialis 5mg
ceftin 500mg generic buy bimatoprost for sale order robaxin generic
online casino games real money planning poker online tadalafil 5mg pill
writing a paper how to write a letter to a hiring manager buy ivermectin uk
purchase sildalis pills buy lamotrigine pills lamotrigine for sale
purchase deltasone generic purchase accutane sale buy amoxil online cheap
viagra australia order sildenafil 50mg online cheap canadian cialis online pharmacy
order azithromycin for sale order neurontin 600mg sale brand gabapentin 100mg
real casino slots online casino games generic cialis online
free slot games for fun stromectol 6mg generic provigil 100mg ca
furosemide 40mg uk buy lasix 100mg generic order plaquenil 400mg
purchase deltasone generic prazosin 2mg sale order vermox 100mg generic
generic sildenafil 50mg buy fildena without prescription rhinocort online order
order tretinoin gel for sale order generic avanafil cheap avanafil
tadalafil 10mg drug diclofenac 100mg pill order indocin for sale
order lamisil 250mg without prescription order amoxicillin 250mg generic amoxicillin tablet
order naproxen without prescription buy generic omnicef order lansoprazole 15mg for sale
order clarithromycin 250mg generic cost biaxin antivert 25mg sale
generic albuterol 100mcg pantoprazole buy online buy ciprofloxacin 500mg without prescription
buy tiotropium bromide for sale order terazosin sale order terazosin pill
singulair 10mg over the counter sildenafil cost oral viagra
purchase actos sildenafil australia viagra cost
order cialis 5mg Cialis once daily buy cialis 5mg online cheap
order tadalafil 5mg Buy cialis without rx free casino
ivermectin 24 mg symmetrel over the counter dapsone 100mg without prescription
online roulette game real money crazy poker games gambling games
order adalat 10mg generic buy generic nifedipine 30mg order fexofenadine 180mg for sale
casino real money san manuel casino online roulette free play for fun
free slot play online canadian pharmacy legit buy my essay
altace sale buy etoricoxib 60mg generic cheap etoricoxib
Do you wanna that your router covers wide areas with an internet connection. Then, you have to make a connection with the asus repeater. Get the detailed information from here.
“성인웹툰”Thanks for sharing
doxycycline 200mg for sale order cleocin 300mg cleocin over the counter
buy essay now order sulfasalazine 500mg sale order sulfasalazine 500mg online cheap
asacol usa purchase astelin irbesartan 300mg cheap
I simply want to say I am just newbie to blogging and site-building and definitely savored this website. Very likely I’m planning to bookmark your site .
You surely come with outstanding well written articles.“밤부” Thanks a bunch for revealing your website page.
I really enjoy reading through on this site, it has got fantastic articles .
Literature is the orchestration of platitudes
olmesartan 20mg drug calan 240mg for sale divalproex online
purchase clobetasol cordarone 200mg canada order cordarone 200mg generic
acetazolamide 250mg oral imdur pills cost azathioprine 50mg
digoxin canada molnunat 200mg pills order molnupiravir 200mg
buy amoxicillin 250mg online order stromectol 3mg sale ivermectin 50mg/ml
coreg pills coreg 25mg sale amitriptyline 50mg sale
cost priligy 90mg avana 200mg without prescription motilium buy online
order fosamax 70mg online motrin 600mg ca buy motrin 600mg online
order indocin 50mg capsule buy tamsulosin 0.4mg pills cenforce 100mg cheap
order nortriptyline 25mg pills pamelor 25mg ca purchase paroxetine pills
doxycycline 200mg cost buy aralen 250mg online medrol 16mg without prescription
pepcid order buy generic mirtazapine 15mg remeron 15mg oral
ropinirole 1mg ca brand labetalol trandate 100 mg pills
order tadacip for sale tadalafil generic order generic amoxicillin 250mg
order tricor 160mg pills tricor over the counter sildenafil pills 150mg
nexium 20mg price furosemide price furosemide 100mg pill
cialis tablet tadalafil on sale buy generic sildenafil 100mg
cost minocin 50mg neurontin 600mg us hytrin 1mg drug
cheap tadalafil generic medicine for impotence home remedies for ed erectile dysfunction
buy metformin 1000mg pills order nolvadex 10mg generic tamoxifen 10mg pill
serophene tablet buy prednisolone 20mg pill order prednisolone 5mg online
generic prednisone 20mg order deltasone 40mg for sale order amoxil 250mg for sale
isotretinoin 40mg brand buy accutane 40mg for sale order ampicillin 250mg without prescription
fildena 50mg pill cheap proscar 1mg buy proscar 5mg for sale
ivermectin 3mg pills for humans buy stromectol 6mg pills order deltasone 5mg generic
buy ondansetron for sale amoxil over the counter trimethoprim uk
order accutane 20mg generic zithromax 500mg brand purchase azithromycin generic
albuterol 4mg inhaler synthroid for sale online augmentin generic
buy prednisolone 10mg sale buy prednisolone 10mg pill oral lasix 40mg
buy modafinil 200mg generic brand zestril 2.5mg metoprolol order
purchase doxycycline pill buy doxycycline pill purchase zovirax online
buy imuran 50mg pills order naprosyn pills brand naproxen 500mg
order ditropan 2.5mg sale trileptal 600mg generic oral oxcarbazepine 300mg
I simply want to say I am just newbie to blogging and site-building and definitely savored this website. Very likely I’m planning to bookmark your site .
You surely come with outstanding well written articles.“부산펀초이스” Thanks a bunch for revealing your website page.
I really enjoy reading through on this site, it has got fantastic articles .
Literature is the orchestration of platitudes
order generic omnicef 300mg buy generic prevacid buy protonix 20mg online cheap
zocor 10mg over the counter purchase zocor online sildalis for sale