SEATTLE, WASHINGTON – MARCH 11: Washington State Governor Jay Inslee at a press conference on March … [+]
Getty Images
Washington State’s first-in-the-nation public long-term care insurance program is headed to court. A group of employers and workers has sued the state with the goal of getting the law overturned.
The lawsuit, filed on behalf of three employers and six workers, argues that the insurance program violates a long list of federal and state laws including the Employee Income Security Act (ERISA), the US Constitution, and state insurance regulations. The plaintiffs are represented by the Seattle-based law firm Davis Wright Tremaine.
Even before the suit, filed against Gov. Jay Inslee and others, the state commission that was created to operate the program was looking at revisions. The litigation is likely to accelerate changes when the Washington legislature meets in January, though some issues raised by the suit will be very difficult to address in a way that maintains the program.
Does the program violate ERISA?
The lawsuit’s major argument appears to be that the law violates ERISA’s guaranties against non-forfeiture—the idea that workers cannot be denied benefits after paying into a benefit program.
The state insurance program, known as the Washington Cares Act, requires most employees to pay a 0.58 percent annual payroll tax in return for a long-term care insurance benefit of up to $36,500. However, the law effectively requires workers to make contributions for 10 years before they can become eligible for benefits. It also would pay benefits only to Washington State residents.
Thus, the suit argues, the law prohibits older workers who pay the premiums for only nine years from receiving benefits despite their ongoing contributions. Similarly, it would not pay benefits to workers who are employed by a Washington company but who live in another state. For example, many residents of Portland, Oregon work just across the river in Vancouver, Washington. In addition, a Washington worker who retires to a different state would be ineligible for benefits.
Age discrimination?
Finally, the program charges higher-income workers higher premiums even though, the plaintiffs say, “there is no compelling state interest for the difference in rate.” Since older workers tend to make more than younger ones, the suit says this violates multiple laws aimed at protecting older workers from discrimination.
The suit alleges that all these limitations also violate the Equal Protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the US Constitution.
The Washington legislature could address these issues, though at a cost. For example, paying benefits to non-residents would increase premiums for all participants. Similarly, reducing or eliminating the 10-year vesting period also would increase premiums.
Employer program or public benefit?
The public insurance program also has another problem. The state legislature exempted people from paying the tax (or receiving a benefit) if they owned a private long-term care insurance policy as of Nov 1. The state reports it has received more than 344,000 applications for exemptions and approved about 140,000.
The suit raises a number of important questions:
Is the program an employee benefit subject to ERISA or is it a public benefit? ERISA generally protects employees who participate in benefit plans voluntarily created by their employers.
Are employers merely acting as agents of the state by collecting and remitting the tax/premium? Or is this an employee benefit similar to health or life insurance?
Is the payment a premium or a tax?
Closely watched
The district court is highly unlikely to block the law before the state begins collecting premiums in January. However, the lawsuit asks the court to order the state to return any premiums that workers do pay before the litigation is resolved. That could leave the program in a high state of uncertainty for years.
Some of the issues raised by the lawsuit are specific to Washington State. But others, such as the ERISA and federal constitutional issues, would apply to any mandatory state public long-term care insurance program. Other states considering their own programs will be watching this case closely.
levofloxacin brand buy generic levaquin
avodart canada ondansetron pill order generic zofran 4mg
order spironolactone 100mg generic purchase aldactone generic diflucan 100mg drug
acillin generic trimethoprim cost order erythromycin online
buy fildena 50mg generic order nolvadex generic order methocarbamol without prescription
suhagra generic sildalis ca estradiol 2mg cost
lamotrigine 50mg oral generic retin cream generic retin cream
tadalis 20mg pills cost diclofenac order generic diclofenac 50mg
isotretinoin medication order amoxicillin 500mg generic buy zithromax online cheap
indomethacin 50mg without prescription buy generic lamisil 250mg cost trimox 500mg
cialis pills 5mg Us discount viagra overnight delivery order viagra 100mg sale
arimidex 1 mg cheap buy clarithromycin 500mg sildenafil pills
tadalafil 40mg comprimГ© viagra 25mg pour homme viagra 25mg pour homme
buy prednisone 20mg generic about cialis buy sildenafil 50mg without prescription
tadalafil kaufen original tadalafil 10mg rezeptfrei sicher kaufen sildenafil 50mg kaufen
doxycycline 100mg usa purchase clomid pills order furosemide 100mg pill
ramipril online order clobetasol over the counter order astelin sale
buy catapres generic buy meclizine 25 mg order spiriva 9mcg online
purchase buspar online cheap order generic phenytoin 100 mg buy ditropan online
hytrin 1mg uk azulfidine 500mg us order azulfidine 500mg online cheap
order fosamax 70mg without prescription ibuprofen 600mg without prescription buy pepcid for sale
benicar 20mg canada diamox 250mg tablet order acetazolamide 250mg generic
buy generic tacrolimus order trandate 100mg generic oral urso 150mg
buy isosorbide pills buy telmisartan 80mg sale cheap micardis 20mg
bupropion generic order strattera generic purchase quetiapine pills
molnunat 200mg brand brand lansoprazole 30mg lansoprazole online order
zoloft 50mg generic lexapro without prescription sildenafil uk
buy salbutamol generic buy viagra for sale buy viagra for sale
cost tadalafil 10mg generic viagra canadian sildenafil professional
purchase naltrexone generic order revia without prescription aripiprazole for sale online
order dapsone pills cheap allegra aceon 4mg us
order medroxyprogesterone without prescription order medroxyprogesterone 10mg pill cyproheptadine over the counter
order provigil online cheap stromectol usa ivermectin 3mg pills
order luvox for sale glucotrol 10mg usa order glipizide 5mg generic
buy accutane 40mg pill amoxicillin 1000mg over the counter order deltasone 40mg without prescription
nootropil 800mg pills purchase nootropil for sale buy viagra online
zithromax 500mg us prednisolone 20mg uk order generic neurontin
brand cialis 40mg viagra over the counter sildenafil usa
buy lasix generic purchase doxycycline pill plaquenil tablet
order tadalafil sale order tadalafil 10mg online anafranil 25mg pill
order sporanox 100mg pills prometrium 200mg without prescription order tinidazole 500mg online
order glucophage 1000mg without prescription cheap lipitor tadalafil 40mg brand
zyprexa over the counter zyprexa sale valsartan 160mg brand
cheap amlodipine sildenafil fast shipping cialis 5mg oral
order clozapine 100mg online cheap decadron oral order dexamethasone 0,5 mg
sildenafil on line lisinopril 5mg pills lisinopril 5mg over the counter
zyvox tablet free spins no deposit usa best casino online
omeprazole cheap quick hits free online slots poker online for money
buy lopressor 100mg for sale atenolol pills oral vardenafil
thesis writing services best essay service casino near me
order vardenafil generic methylprednisolone 16 mg over counter medrol 4 mg online
buying a term paper viagra 50mg tablet real viagra pills
clomiphene 50mg cost purchase ventolin without prescription poker online sites
order tadalafil 5mg brand tadalafil 5mg viagra for sale
aristocort 4mg tablet buy triamcinolone generic buy clarinex online cheap
priligy order buy synthroid online cheap order synthroid 150mcg online cheap
cialis pill viagra 50mg pills for men cheapest viagra
buy generic orlistat 60mg order xenical 120mg pill buy acyclovir without prescription
order cialis 10mg for sale cialis india plavix 75mg drug
zyloprim 300mg for sale order ezetimibe online cheap ezetimibe online
methotrexate for sale online purchase warfarin generic brand reglan 20mg
cozaar buy online buy topamax 200mg for sale order topiramate 200mg generic
baclofen online buy buy ozobax online cheap ketorolac pills
oral sumatriptan order imitrex 50mg online cheap order dutasteride sale
order colchicine generic gloperba sale play online roulette for fun
buy zantac 300mg pills zantac 300mg price celecoxib 100mg tablet
free slot games no download free roulette games free online blackjack no download
buy tamsulosin 0.4mg pills buy aldactone 25mg for sale aldactone 100mg tablet
generic tadalafil 10mg order cialis 10mg for sale cipro 1000mg ca
zocor 10mg ca propecia 5mg us finasteride 1mg us
metronidazole drug metronidazole 400mg cost bactrim order
buy fluconazole pills purchase diflucan online sildenafil mail order us
cephalexin 250mg over the counter keflex 125mg cost erythromycin 250mg sale
buy tadalafil 5mg without prescription tadalafil 40mg oral order sildenafil pill
ceftin oral ceftin 250mg us purchase methocarbamol generic
blackjack game tadalafil 20mg usa tadalafil 10mg pills
order desyrel 100mg online cheap order aurogra 50mg online buy sildenafil 50mg generic
academicwriting purchase essay online ivermectin 6mg otc
sildalis oral oral sildalis buy lamotrigine online
deltasone 5mg uk buy deltasone online cheap order amoxil 500mg generic
cheap viagra 100mg canadian viagra and healthcare tadalafil for women
blackjack online buy ed medication order tadalafil 20mg generic
buy azithromycin 500mg online buy gabapentin 800mg for sale buy gabapentin 600mg without prescription
casino games free slot machines order modafinil 100mg
buy furosemide 100mg without prescription cost hydroxychloroquine 200mg plaquenil 200mg pill
order fildena 50mg for sale buy sildenafil 50mg buy rhinocort pill
order prednisone minipress 2mg for sale mebendazole 100mg ca
tretinoin cream uk order tadalis 20mg for sale avana 200mg uk
order tadacip 20mg without prescription buy diclofenac 50mg order indocin sale
purchase biaxin pills buy clarithromycin sale buy meclizine 25 mg sale
order albuterol 100 mcg pill pantoprazole 20mg price cipro 500mg over the counter
order spiriva online hytrin usa terazosin 5mg pill
montelukast 10mg oral montelukast 5mg without prescription viagra online
cheap cialis pills poker online sites bonus casino
buy tadalafil 20mg pills otc ed pills tadalafil 5mg canada
buy ivermectin 3 mg for humans order stromectol 12mg online cheap buy dapsone pills
slot machine games gambling website online gambling slots games
generic nifedipine 30mg purchase adalat generic allegra order
online casinos for usa players online pharmacy store academic writing online
order altace 10mg pill altace 5mg brand buy etoricoxib online
doxycycline usa buy cleocin 150mg for sale cleocin 300mg cost
asacol 400mg without prescription asacol 400mg for sale irbesartan 150mg canada
buy olmesartan generic depakote 500mg ca order depakote 250mg generic
buy temovate buspirone without prescription amiodarone 100mg cheap
amoxil 250mg cheap stromectol 12mg drug price of ivermectin liquid
order priligy online order avana 200mg generic order motilium 10mg without prescription
order indocin for sale order indocin 50mg without prescription order cenforce 50mg
order doxycycline generic order aralen 250mg pills methylprednisolone 4mg without a doctor prescription
order famotidine 20mg remeron 30mg us remeron 30mg uk
tadalafil for sale amoxicillin 500mg over the counter amoxicillin 250mg pill
buy esomeprazole 20mg for sale esomeprazole oral furosemide for sale
free date web sites best dating websites local females 100% free chatting online
minocin 100mg tablet buy minocin 50mg generic buy hytrin for sale
purchase metformin generic cost tamoxifen 20mg tamoxifen usa
clomiphene medication buy lipitor 20mg pill buy prednisolone generic
prednisone tablet buy amoxicillin sale order amoxicillin online
brand isotretinoin 10mg accutane 20mg price ampicillin 500mg without prescription
stromectol 3 mg dosage order stromectol 12mg for sale prednisone 40mg price
order isotretinoin 10mg online cheap buy accutane 40mg online cheap zithromax over the counter
prednisolone 5mg over the counter prednisolone 40mg cost order lasix
help with writing an essay good essay writers write my law essay
удостоверение мвд купить
купить птс
purchase doxycycline generic vardenafil 10mg ca order zovirax 800mg
college admission essay editing services writing essays help best essay writer company
an effective thesis statement should explanatory thesis example thesis coral gables
introduction and thesis statement example working thesis statement writing a good thesis statement
ditropan 5mg over the counter order ditropan 5mg online oxcarbazepine uk
education thesis how to come up with a thesis statement 3.5 arcane thesis
random thesis generator what is a thesis in writing poverty thesis statement
cost zocor 20mg order promethazine generic sildenafil for men over 50
essay editing service online who will write my essay for me write my essay custom writing need help in writing an essay
essay writing service online essay introduction help cheapest essay writers custom law essay
alfuzosin pills desyrel price diltiazem price
definition essay help i need help writing
a compare and contrast essay help starting an essay essay proofreading service